Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

Posts

Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

#1

Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The American Chestnut was a "keystone" tree in the eastern forest. It was a dominant "canopy" tree that grew to immense size in good dirt. It provided a larger and more reliable food crop than any other tree. Its size and rot resistance made it the "redwood or the east".

The Asian Chestnut is a smaller bushy tree that can not compete in the typical Appalachian forest environment.


It is easy to identify the American Chestnut from a leaf or twig. Compared to the Chinese variety the leaf of the American Chestnut is longer, more narrow, less glossy and the underside is not fuzzy. The leaf margines are described as "cresting waves". At the junction of the leaf stem with the twig is a bud. The Chinese variety protects this bud from sun burn with a green leaf like structure that provides shade. This area of the American Chestnut has "sun screen" so this covering is small and doesn't do any covering (see picture). Also the American Chestnut is reddish in this area (see picture) while the Chinese is green.

I took the leaf picture to show the lack of the shading thingy characteristic of the American bud (bud is naked) . I now see that the tree I chose has some Chinese parentage. This leaf is not as long and narrow as a full blooded American. See next picture for a true American leaf.

Re: Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

#2

Got excited once upon a time.

Basil

I thought I had found a group of good size American chestnuts...but it was chestnut oak or sometimes called swamp white oak. Very similar leaves to the chestnut and I guess that's why the name, chestnut oak.

Re: Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

#3

Re: Got excited once upon a time.

James Heaston

Thanks for the info Bill.

My question is .... Are there any American Chestnut that are actually blight resistant?

Re: Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

#4

Re: Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

Barry Irby

Did the Chestnut extend to the Richmond Va area? I would like to have something to do with restoring this tree, but I don't want to waste the seedlings, If plating them in Southside VA would not be a good location. I have some land in Nottoway County I could put a few on. Its got planted pines on it now, but there is a stream bed that I could use. I'm 65 years old, how optimistic do I have to be to plant trees?

Re: Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

#5

range

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The American Chestnut ranged from Main to Georgia.

Re: Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

#6

Re: Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

Tom Dunlap

Barry,

Rarely are trees planted for us. They're planted for them.

J. Sterling Morton, who started Arbor Day said:

Arbor Day is not like other holidays.

Each of those reposes on the past, while Arbor Day proposes for the future.

-Julius Sterling Morton



Arborists celebrate Arbor Day every day.

-Tom Dunlap

Re: Asian vs American Chestnut Tree

#7

how to get he best answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....go to acf.org and join the organization. Joining will also join you to your state chapter which will have programs throughout the year. The national meeting is in Front Royal.