Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Questions on MDF as trim, need help

Posts

Questions on MDF as trim, need help

#1

Questions on MDF as trim, need help

Barry Irby

On a Home Inspection I saw a house with MDF trim. This was sort of quasi arts and crafts or craftsman style. They just deleted all the detail. The client is complaining that they wanted full blown Craftsman style.

One problem is that the stuff mushroomed (?) at the nails. It appears a bulge occurred around the nails and then they puttied the nails and tried to sand the raised or bulged part off. Then they painted the trim with gloss paint. Now you can see the sanded spots clearly. The texture changes where the bulge used to be and you can see the sanding scratches.

Anybody got experience with using MDF trim and how to achieve a PERFECT finish? (They also have problems where it got wet and swelled.)

Re: Questions on MDF as trim, need help

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The worst of gloss and MDF, all in one.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

For one, even doing a pretty good prep job for gloss paint will probably not look good. You have to bring your prep A-game when using gloss.

You also need a whole other A-game when using MDF trim. The key would be a thorough sanding job (not just the puttied--spackle would be better--spots) and a good primer that has some build to it and provides a good tooth (mechanical adhesion) for the topcoat. Also, you'll probably need an extra topcoat.

As for swelling due to moisture or water, the only real possible solution for that would be to seal every piece in its entirety--front, back, top, bottom, ends, cuts, profiles, the whole nine lineal yards. Then rip it out a year later because it still looks like garbage and replace it with real wood.

I try to avoid both MDF and gloss. Doing one piece of furniture is one thing, doing a whole house of MDF trim is a nightmare. Doing it in gloss is a special level of Hades that's extra hot and sulfurous.

Jason

Re: Questions on MDF as trim, need help

#3

Re: need help

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

get that help from your client's real estate attorney and their lender 9a/o the builder's performance bond carrier. First line of inquiry will be the specs on the contract and whether they were explained as to materials selection.

There is one way to solve the issue: rip it out and replace it with properly primed wood. Once MDF swells, it's done as in flaking and coming apart.