A couple weeks ago I asked about honeycomb and got some very helpful answers. At that time it was mentioned that honeycomb oak wasn't usable.
Since I have some and would like to use it if possible, will the honeycomb open up more or continue to grow once the wood is dry? I have some pieces where it only shows on one side so my thought is that I might be able to use it on the hidden side of rails or styles. I would also put a little glue into the openings and sand over the top of that to close up the opening. Thoughts?
"At that time it was mentioned that honeycomb oak wasn't usable."
I would qualify that statement. At least some of the stress has been relieved by the splits. If the splits are not visible in the application of the wood there is no appearance reason to avoid. Personally, I would have no hesitation to use the lumber in any application where it was sufficiently strong and the splits were not an appearance issue.
I have never seen much honeycomb oak so I have little experience using it. I did have a small amount of white oak dried at a small kiln and they put it on wet sticks going into the kiln. There was occasional honeycomb(splits) where the sticks contacted the boards which showed up when I planed it. I filled the cracks and used the lumber.
MD, It has been a long time since I've had any pass through my shop. But once I bought maybe 100 bf of 2" thick plane sawn Oak which had it in every board. It was worse about 2" in from the ends, and I think all of the checks were radial.
I got my supplier to take it all back, even though they claimed it was from a reputable supplier, and didn't like the idea of my returning it, it's hard to deny when it was in every board.
Since you mentioned QS, to me seems less likely than plain sawn due to the 2 -1 contraction ratio, and if it isn't in every board, maybe there is another cause. I'd like to see a photo, if you could share one.
If you choose to use it, even if it doesn't show on the face, when you rip it, there is a good chance that the splits will be along the new edges. Also, if you need to plane some down below the shell, you've got firewood.
I would not risk putting a filled crack on a show face. Cracks have a way of coming and going and cracking finish. That is a mild case which I would use with out hesitation where the appearance can be accommodated .
if that crack propagated from/or to the surface of the as received board it is simply a drying check. Oak readily suffers these cracks from drying for cases where the surface of the lumber dries too fast. Happens all the time in air drying oak in the summer in an unprotected stack. In this case there will be no internal stress from this defect, unlike the case of case hardening.
This is an insidious defect when planing with a big machine that has large infeed roll pressure. Boards that are cupped will often split where these cracks can propagate a split. I had most of a 1000 bdft pack of oak split by the company I hired to plane it. That caused some tense moments until we were able to agree to a settlement that was favorable to our case.
This problem is hard to spot because these cracks close back up in the kiln and the dry lumber looks perfect until it is planed or cross cut.
the more I study you pictures the more it looks like surface checks. Honeycomb checks are often lens shaped, not straight sided cracks. Yours look like simple cracks/checks. It's oak. Oak can easily do that.
MD, A single check isn't enough to classify as honeycombing, especially after you have milled away the original outside layer. As I mentioned earlier, it would normally be associated with plane sawn, and then, there would be a bunch of them, but all would be housed, not running out the edge, as was illustrated in Richard's walnut photo.
I would just call this a radial check. Sometimes I see them in wood while it is still in the log, but then some can come from drying.
"This problem is hard to spot because these cracks close back up in the kiln and the dry lumber looks perfect until it is planed or cross cut."
Bill, I think this must be the answer because I remember being surprised when they have shown up, "Where did that come from?"
Unfortunately, this brings me back to the beginning, since there seems to be no way to spot it before purchasing the stock. I guess it is just a shrink factor I have to absorb.
when you bought it? Take a magnifying glass and study where the medullary rays intersect the surface. I've always been able to see them unless the rough stock is really dirty. You may want to consider a different supplier, or what time of the year you purchase. If they start the cutting and the drying process in the heat of the summer, it is more likely to surface check.
Dick, I don't remember seeing any issues. Decent suppliers are hard to find here in the desert SW, Albuquerque to be specific. I have been as far as Denver and Dallas to get qswo. I will keep looking and eventually find a great source at a reasonable price.
This problem, if it is indeed surface drying checks, is nothing to do with "decent suppliers". It is a fact of life with oak. Checks could have formed on the top layer of the lumber on the truck hauling from saw mill to kiln, or a dozen other places in even the best managed operation. By the time lumber gets to NM there is no way to know when it was cut, how long the logs sat in the sun waiting to be sawed, when it was dried, where it was dried, whether packs sat in the sun in TN for a couple of days before stacking, or much else about its pedigree. Buy enough oak and you will see this problem from any supplier. If it is an occasional board, live with it. If it is a whole pack, its time to negotiate a settlement.
It is problems like this one that made us focus on larger quantity customers. If a buyer found a checked board in a 200 bdft shipment they never cared. They could use it somewhere. But for the retail customer buying 3 boards, one checked board is a crisis.