What are the pros and cons of this system? I would like to try this system, as I have admired Bill Tindall's Line and Barry projects. Questions---- what woods are best suited for this type of work? Is oak a good wood? ( because of the open grain, etc.)
Questions for Bill Tindall -(1) do you have ALL of the components of the system, (2) where do you find the different patterns for L&B. (3) Whats the learning curve for this system. (4) what techniques have YOU adopted for this system.
Buy Steve Lattas's DVD. It will answer your questions. If you can get into one of his classes it will rocket you up the learning curve.
What are the pros and cons of this system? Simple answer here. None of the pros I asked recommended LV. Get the LN system.
what woods are best suited for this type of work? walnut. the white holly on the dark walnut is the most striking. Holly is by far the easiest wood to bend.
Is oak a good wood? I think it would be miserable to scratch the troughs in oak.
Questions for Bill Tindall -(1) do you have ALL of the components of the system. I have the LN circle and straight line scratcher. If I was going to do a lot of L&B I would own two circle scratchers. For straight lines Latta likes the router and I have to agree with him on that. If you are going to be doing much straight line get a trim router and the fence for it. (buy several bits as you will break one before you get the hang of it)
Where do you find the different patterns for L&B. There is a recent issue of Popular Woodworking where I describe laying out the pattern for the drawers I did. It may be here in the WC articles too.
(3) Whats the learning curve for this system? I found it easy to learn and do. After making two practice patterns I was off and running.
(4) what techniques have YOU adopted for this system? I do what Latta does.
If you are in the neighborhood stop by and I will show you
Michael Fortune did a fantastic article on inlay, specifically string inlay, in the great Woodwork magazine. American Woodworker, the horrible magazine company that bought Woodwork and now sells "special" issues made of articles from the magazine, maintains a website for the magazine. The article may be up there, or do a search for it. It was the February 2002 issue, pages 45-54, and titled, "The Elements of Inlay". If I remember correctly, he made most, if not all, of the tools he used for inlay.
For some weird reason, he also dd an article on the subject for Fine Homebuilding. You need member access to the site to see it, but here's a link to the page that mentions it.
(Sorry about the AW rant. Really don't like that magazine and really miss Woodwork.)
Bill, as usual, pretty much nailed the question with his answers. I also think that straight cuts should be done with routers. I would add that if you are doing a lot of the same curve, its worth it to make a router template for that curve instead of using the radius tool from either LN or LV. I, too, love the contrast between walnut and holly.
Where I differ is mainly in personal preference. The LN tools are mostly close copies of historical tools. Those who value working in period appropriate methods should definitely get them. Thats just not important to me. I particularly dislike the thickener and the saw-like radius guide. The tool for slicing veneer is, in my opinion, a waste of money and time. Get an exact-o knife and a straight edge or use the jig shown in the LV set. Thickness veneer with a drum sander or a sanding cylinder on a drill press with a fence, aka luthier's friend.
So I bought the LN tools then sold them. Bought the LV radius tool and do the rest with general purpose shop tools. By the way, I liked the video in the LN set so much I wound up buying it again separately after I sold the set.
As for the learning curve, it depends on how intricate you want to be. I suggest starting off simple with something like straight lines on a drawer or table leg. Then try radiuses on the corners of those. Play with some circles on the end of lines and try shading them with hot sand. Steve Latta's video will walk you through all of these. With those skills, you are ready to do bell flowers and all kinds of stuff.
And by the way, I don't mean to put down LN tools. I have a few that I use just about every day and always enjoy them.
My thought would be get the real Latta tools. They look like this:
Couple of scraps of wood and a few screws. We're not making bicycles here. The only slightly skilled part to make is the blade, and you could buy one of those from the vendors. Of course if the whole point of the project is to get some more flash brass stuff, you are in good company here. Been there and got the... brass stuff.
It would be interesting to know how many pros have used all three sets and have been forthcoming with their opinions.
There used to be a pretty good video with Latta in the Woodwright series. I looked for it but didn't find it, it was from 2003. There are plenty of videos online to get you going. I found the noden inlay method interesting, if mostly for leather.
To replicate the pattern I used for the drawers required two sized scratchers per drawer size. I would have had to make 8 scratchers to do this chest of drawers. And if I built a slightly different sized piece next time, yet more scratchers would need to be made. If you prefer making furniture to making tools, buy a circle scratcher.
The LN scratchers will cut a radius faster than a router. What everyone I talked to that had compared LV vs LN said was how much faster the LN was at cutting circular troughs. While this factor might be unimportant in inlaying a radius on a Federal leg, L&B is all radius work. There was about 100' of troughs cut for the chest of drawers.
Cutting the circular though is not a delicate operation. Ideally the scratcher should have some ergonomic attributes, that is, it can be held and swung comfortably with considerable pressure applied to the cutter.