Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Shop ear portection?

Posts

Shop ear portection?

#1

Shop ear portection?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What do you use?

I had some nice light weight "muffs" but they are getting on in age and the plastic has broken on some pairs . I also have a pair I hate. They are heavy and feel large on my head. I need replacements. They don't need to be suitable for pit row on a NASCAR race. Just typical table saw and jointer noise and that irksome swishing noise from hand planes :) .

Re: Shop ear portection?

#2

Re: Shop ear portection?

John in NM


I like these.

Re: Shop ear portection?

#3

Major disappointment

Neal in San Jose

I bought a pair of Peltor "Shop Tunes" thinking I would be more likely to wear them if I had music going on. They are so sensitive to head position and my location in the shop as to be worthless. They go from normal listening volume to nothing just by turning my head. They are pretty comfortable and work well for noise reduction, but paying extra for the music feature was a mistake.

Re: Shop ear portection?

#4

Re: Shop ear portection? *LINK*

mdclor

Bill, I use the ones at the link. They are NRR 30 which is better than the average. Also, since they are Shooters Premium, they should work especially well when you are shooting a miter with your plane. :D HTH


Shooters Premium

Re: Shop ear portection?

#5

Re: Shop ear portection?

Barry Irby

I ahve a pair fo black shooters muffs and a black Noth half mask and a face shield that is also black. Darth Vader rising...

Re: Shop ear portection?

#6

Re: Shop ear portection?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I have a pair of muffs from the Walmart sporting goods section, also shooters ear protection. Says "silencio" on them. They were about $15 I think (w/ safety glasses that I can't use in place of my prescription glasses). They work well at limiting equipment noise but I can still hear normal conversation when the machines are off.

Re: Shop ear portection?

#7

Re: Shop ear portection?

Hennebury


3M™ E-A-R Classic Earplugs, Uncorded, 8052910000, 200-Pair

I have used this type for many years, I have tried others but like these the best.

Re: Shop ear portection?

#8

I like my David Clarks

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

Mine are Government Issue, although not to me. A former classmate liberated them from the Forrestal when he served aboard back in the '60s. I don't know if he had me in mind when he took them for a walk (inadvertently, I'm sure, and in any event, the statute of limitations…), but I inherited them for shop purposes.

One set is like the current 10A and the other is the current 19A. Amazon, around $44.

The cup on the 10A is a slimmer profile than the 19A, but they both served on the flight deck around jet whines of the day, so they're pretty effective in the shop, as well. I can't tell any difference in performance between the 10 or the 19. If I had to pay to replace either, I would.

If you didn't know, David Clark is probably the principal name in aviation headset/hearing protection. They're also popular with shooters, as well, so if you go in that direction, you're in plenty of good company (I mean the brand, not the applications).

Re: Shop ear portection?

#9

Re: I like my David Clarks

Robby Wright - San Marcos, CA

I'll second the David Clark's. I have had a pair for years until the ear pads wore out. I still have them, but need to get another set of ear pads for them. One thing I like about David Clark headsets is that they will seal around the earpieces of glasses without problems, especially their liquid filled ear pads. Great if you can find them. Rugged too.

Re: Shop ear portection?

#10

Funny you should mention the pads

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

Mine have long needed replacing, too, not to mention the foam cup inserts. The foam inserts are dust, now, but the units still provide lots of noise protection.

Last night when I was prowling around for info to post I found that D-C has kits (K10 and K19 respectively) which include the gel pads and the foam inserts and are priced at less than the individual prices. They're on the way. Cost me $21.50 (+ $9 shipping) for the replacements. I should have done this years ago.

Glad you like yours, too, Robby.

Rod

Re: Shop ear portection?

#11

HF's are cheap, effective, expendable.


Re: Shop ear portection?

#12

Re: Not what they tell you

TomD

I get mine at shooting stores. First thing I do (and maybe the new ones come like this) is pull out the open cell foam inserts that form the insulation, and use them as a pattern for closed cell foam from camping mats. Attenuation is much stronger from the closed cell, great upgrade. It might even be worth using spray foam, but I haven't tried it.

The part that isn't like what they tell you is that for years I have been reading how guns make noises of 150 db. recently I saw numbers nearer 200, that with a logarithmic scale is incredibly loud. I did a little further research, and it turns out the average DB meter only goes up to 150. Maybe not a huge concern with most of the gear we use, but an eye opener for me. A good set of muffs is say 20-30 attenuation. If you are talking 180, you are still getting your hearing blown out of your head. Which is why a lot of us use ear plugs as well. Suffice it to say that if I see any more DB ratings of 150, I will be very suspicious.

I also like the foam pillows that go on eyeglasses legs to stop sound coming in past the muff pads.

Re: Shop ear portection?

#13

Re: Shop ear portection?

TomD

Active noise cancellation, has anyone tried them. LV is now selling ZEM earbands, they are supposed to be passive cancellation, has anyone tried those?

Re: Shop ear portection?

#14

Re: I like my David Clarks

fred in CT

Rod, they're cheaper direct from David Clark $34 and $36.

Re: Shop ear portection?

#15

Thanks, Fred

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

I didn't even check their prices while I was there. One always assumes the "M" in MSRP price is always going to be higher than elsewhere—at least I always do.

The irony is, I was later at their site ordering the pads and inserts, which I found quite reasonably priced. They should be here today or tomorrow.

Rod

Re: Shop ear portection?

#16

As to those…

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

Arrived today. Took me probably fifteen minutes per set to disassemble, remove pads, clean, replace pads and inserts, reassemble and test.

I'm more than extremely pleased. Even though the shells without the foam (but with the pads) knocked down a lot of sound, the foam inserts take out even more, not to mention it deadens the inside of the cups whereas they were a little live inside without them.

Here are my VN War era D-Cs:

Note the cups are black—not the green you see in modern D-Cs. The old pads were gray (grey, Jim) which was a nice contrast, but the black ones, which would contrast nicely with modern green shells, just set off the black shells. They are rockin' cool looking. In my opinion, of course.

Still love my David Clarks.

Rod

Re: Shop ear portection?

#17

Nice score !

steve mackay

We used those in Pershing. GI proof. :D