How "air tight" is your shop? My shop is heated for the winter months and air conditioned in the summer months,( it is a all-in-one unit). I very seldom have the small door or a window " cracked" open a little bit. What are your thoughts about outside air in the shop in relationship to humidity, etc.? I do have a JDS air cleaner and a dust collection system.
I have always opened up the doors and windows in my shops. I enjoy the breeze and like the fresh air. I am not sure what it does to the humidity but I feel that if is cool enough outside to open the windows and it is not 90% humidity it should be fine.
No DC or air cleaner you can reasonably buy and install will remove all the really dangerous particulates from the air in your shop. You will, therefore, be breathing and rebreathing that air, using your lungs as a third dust removal system.
Open up or get yourself an organic vapor-rated mask that you put on before you enter the shop and only take off after you've left because fine dust is not the only thing polluting your shop air. Ozone, solvent vapors, mold spores, etm. etm. will be building and concentrating in your space. While you're at it, consider a sealing onesie that you can use in the shop so that you're not dragging dust with you into the house etm. in your hair and on your clothes and shoes.
Sound extreme? Absolutely, but the same kind of thing has been happening in what were term "super-insulated" homes, many of which now suffer from what they sometimes call Sick-House Syndrome.
Mark makes some good points. Perhaps extreme, but the problem is that on an individual basis you can only tell if he is correct years from now when you are sick. Its very difficult to get quality information on things like the threat of working around wood dust and harder still to know how it will affect YOU. If you are in your shop an hour a week its different that if you in there twenty hours a week. If you wear personal protective gear and have good dust collection its different that if you don't.
Here on WC we recently had a discussion about spalting wood. (Probably on the Turning Board). Someone brought a woman known as Dr. Spalt. She is a researcher at a university studying spalting and how to generate colors and other aspects of the fungi that spalt wood. I wrote her and E-mail concerning the danger of turning spalted wood. Her response was that there was good information that indicated wood dust was more dangerous than the spores.
Mark's point is that its the dust in the air that you can not see that is more dangerous than the the stuff you can see. The heavy stuff that falls out and settles onto everything is really not dangerous. Its the stuff you inhale that gets you. That's why personal protective gear is so important.
As a contrary argument, check out this article by a woodworker who purchased an air quality meter to test his shop. IIRC, he found the air in his shop was much cleaner than the air in the rest of his house and even outside air:
My shop is in the basement, below ground. If I opened it small window to the outside in the winter it would get cold.
In the summer the basement is cool and I dehumidify it. If I were to open the window the moist outside air would enter the cool basement, the humidity would rise and everything would rust. Hence, the shop stays largely shut up.
Of course I am a smoker (over 50 years), worked in the steel mills about 4 years, long before OSHA and the EPA. I've worked around many chemicals that are now considered carcinogenic, around quite a bit of asbestos dust (used to power wire brush brake linings to get rid of the glaze left when wheel cylinders leaked and also used it to insulate chimneys when installing furnaces).
My shop is sealed most of the time (central heat and air), when the weather is great I open the big door. Usually blow the dust out with a leaf blower (creates a storm). I do have a dust collection system for my machines (3 hp Griz. cyclone), but no sanding table. Don't own or intend to purchase any "personal protective gear".
I am 73, Doc lectures me about my smoking habit, seems to be a little disappointed when she checks my lungs, but admits they are still clear.
Way I figure it, I am very sure something is going to be my demise, but stress from worrying what is going to do me in isn't going to be one of the causes! Maybe the dangers proclaimed by all the various Doctors and others are legitimate for people with sensitivities to chemicals, dust and the like. Personally, I think genetics has a lot more to do with shortened life and health issues.
Totally agree about genetics. I can't say that doing things that are known to be bad for you is a great idea but genetics is a primary factor. Unfortunately, we don't really know what our genetic sensitivity is before we start out.
My shop is shared with the wife's car in an unheated 2-car garage. Everything is on wheels. Given that Seattle's average annual temperature is supposedly 42 degrees, I usually open one or both garage doors when I am working except the coldest periods when I tend not to work in the shop at all. I appreciate the fresh air and, the additional natural lighting the open garage doors provide. Now that the kids have moved out, my bench room is the spare bedroom just inside the garage so, I do all my hand tool and fine work there. The bench is in front of a north-facing window which provides nice indirect lighting.
I enjoy smoking cigars when in the shop so have installed a bathroom exhaust fan. I run it periodically whether I am smoking or not. Use of the fan is influenced by outside temperature and humidity as all exhausted air is replaced by outside air.
My shop is conditioned year round and stays closed unless the temp is moderate and humidity low and/or I'm spraying. At 73, shop air quality is among the least of my concerns.
I haven't done any air quality comparisons between inside my shop and outside. I'd bet though that outside is just as bad as inside in terms of PPM's. , just different ones. I live in the country and there is abundant dust, pollen and assorted farm chemicals in the air that I" not concerned with replacing one group of particles with another group. I do collect sanding dust at the lathe with a Festool Vac and a home made funnel system. I also run a JDS air filter.
I did say I was painting an "extreme" situation, and to some I've far overstated the risks (even though I don't live in California). The point has been made that none of us really know our individual susceptibility and genetic weaknesses when it comes to environmental conditions that we subject ourselves to in the course of our lives. It's also true that none of us will be establishing "clean room" environments in our wood shops. But a tightly closed shop will foster concentration of whatever risky substances happen to be floating about in the space, and, I'll posit that some fresh air can only help.
hey thanks for the link to that guy's site, Lars - I peruse it once in a while, but hadn't seen the article on dust collection and discussion with doctor on the topic. It is funny how after reading a lot of woodworking forum topics on the matter, i start getting more and more anxious about lung disease. hearing a differing point of view helps prop my mind open -- a good thing.
My shop is rather porous even when the door is shut. it being such a decrepit structure, opossums call it home and live under the flooring.
anyway, I had been thinking about building a 'machine room' inside the garage, primarily for better sound containment, but also to better contain the dust that i get from power tools. It would have some sort of dust extraction system beyond a shop-vac (meh, maybe just a dust-deputy attachment), and maybe even an air filtration unit...but somehow the latter seems excessive.
You're welcome Adam. I know exactly what you mean about reading too much forum crap about wood dust and getting anxiety. I was in those shoes a couple a years ago. It helps to see some hard evidence that says it's actually not such a big deal. Woodworking is hard enough even when you're not terrified that you're killing your future self or about to amputate part of your current self.
That said, I still think a decent dust collection system is a good thing to have, for a number of reasons:
1.) I do still worry that the dust is killing me. Or, well maybe just maiming. Having good dust collection appeases that fear enough that I am comfortable working without a dust mask 95% of the time.
I totally agree with Larry, I smoked for about 50yrs too, quit on Oct. 24th, 1984...cold turkey...chewed a lot of gum, but no-more cigs. I worked in construction all my life...retired in 1991, and started into my woodworking again making things for family and friends. I do have COPD from smoking but no other afflictions. ...to speak of. Vacuum up my dust after working on a project, but no leaf blower is necessary....LOL>
The other thing you hear about is that kids brought up too sheltered from dirt have problems because they didn't develop resistance, or something, so they have us worrying from both sides.
My own feeling about dust, not all of which is wood, and can be very bad for you, is that once it gets to that point one needs to use hand tools, They aren't dust free, but they are much better than power tools. There are certain projects I will only undertake out of doors, and there are some others I will not do in my suburban neighbourhood. Sometimes on just has to say no.
I tend to disregard the findings about lung cancer and such that came to light probably about the time that the greatest generation were retiring. Goodness knows what they went through prior to arriving at the mill. Then, 40 years of smoking, and working in a mill with minimal safety precautions, then cancer, in '85 in time for OSHA to take up the cause.
But on the other hand. The craft revolution has led to an ever escalating competition in which many of us have way more stuff than any number of pros, and some of the amateurs might put in more hours to boot. What few have is a large shop with high ceilings, which is one way to dilute the dust, along with other methods. So we do need to show some care. We may not have the time in the job many other have, but we can have some considerable time combined with no OSHA to push us around, tight little places and poor safety procedures.
Now on sound, I wear muffs at the first sign of noise. Don't want to hear it, or loose my hearing to it. Sound is always getting through, harder to know whether some dust will even have any effect.