New Article: Drying Stresses in Lumber *LINK*
Ellis Walentine
Bill Tindall has contributed yet another article to the WoodCentral Articles department, this one in the wake of a recent discussion of stresses in resawn lumber. Have a look.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
New Article: Drying Stresses in Lumber *LINK*
Ellis Walentine
Bill Tindall has contributed yet another article to the WoodCentral Articles department, this one in the wake of a recent discussion of stresses in resawn lumber. Have a look.
Great info. Thank you.
Honeycomb Questions
mdclor
I mostly work with qswo and usually try to buy 5/4 up to 8/4 depending on my project. Arts & Crafts typically requires thicker stock.
I have seen honeycomb many times and as mentioned in Bill's article the wood is unusable. However, I don't know the wood is honeycombed until after I get is home and start machining it. Since this is a fault with the drying process, should I return the stock to my source? Is it reasonable for me to expect the seller to make good on my purchase? Is there a way to know if the wood might be honeycombed before I buy it?
I should mention that living in the desert Southwest, there aren't a lot of sources for lumber. Thanks for any suggestions/guidance.
answers
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I don't know the wood is honeycombed until after I get is home and start machining it....there are tell tale signs.
Since this is a fault with the drying process, should I return the stock to my source? Yes. In this day and age you should never see honeycomb oak. Unlike lumber with residual stress than can occur in the best of operations, It is a product of careless or ignorant kiln operation. As a supplier I would want to know if my source was producing defective lumber. No matter where you live there are many sources of lumber a the wholesale level. There is no need for your supplier to put up with a product from a faulty kiln operation.
Is it reasonable for me to expect the seller to make good on my purchase? In this case, yes. I probably set the bar for being intolerant of picky customers. But when it came to honeycomb or improper moisture content, both a result of poor kiln management, I was ready to make good the buyers purchase and then I would raise hell with who sold it to us. An important point......we NEVER got honeycomb or out of specification moisture content from suppliers such as Hunterville Hardwoods. When we thought we found a less expensive source, typically a smaller kiln operation, we sometimes encountered problems.
Is there a way to know if the wood might be honeycombed before I buy it? Yes, I can spot it. Now whether I can describe it is another matter. The lumber surface will be distorted from what looks normal. The surface might appear rippled or concave. It just doesn't look right. It may only be part of a board.
Thank you!
follow up with example
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This piece of oak is honey comb because it was a miscut. One end was 5/4 and the other 4/4 and it went in the kiln with a charge of 4/4. Hence, the 5/4 end dried too quickly for its thickness.
It will be the center of the board that will still be wet when the faces and edges are dry. Hence, this is the location to look for distortions of the board, and the honeycomb that will like within.
Note the odd distorted shape of the cross section. From this end view try to imagine what the surface would look like. The center is sunken and wavy. It doesn' t look right or feel right as you run you hand over the surface.
Re: follow up with example
mdclor
That is very helpful. Now I need to go look at some stock to look for this type irregularity. I appreciate your initial article and the great follow up.
Mdclor note.....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
.....the irregular bottom edge in the walnut picture. If you ran your hand across this surface it would feel wavy/abnormal. Apparently the stress relieved mostly out this side of the board as the other side appears flat. In any case, when the interior becomes so stressed that it fractures this event will distort one or both surfaces. I am sure that in some cases this distortion will be so subtle as to not be readily noticeable, but in most cases it can be detected.
That was one unhappy camper to find a charge of 12/4 walnut worthless!
Re: Mdclor note.....
Sgian Dubh
Bill, your observations about the wavy lower surface are of course correct ...
... but I'm completely mystified by your reference to Mdclor note.
Please explain. Slainte.
Richard Note.....
Barry Irby
the names of the posters above.....Bill and mdclor were posting back and forth and you jumped in. Bill was telling him to note the distortion in your pic. Great picture by the way.
You do get the names of the posters on your end don't you? this interweb thing is still a mystery to me.
Re: Richard Note.....
Sgian Dubh
Barry, I realised later it was a brain fart on my part, but decided it would be even sillier to delete the post which I think would have been my only option at that stage. Yes, of course we see the name of the poster over here in the UK. But for some reason, probably because I was quickly dashing off a response between one task and another during a current hectic work schedule, I was concentrating on getting the relevant image in place and just didn't register the MDclor poster name. Stupid ... or what? Slainte.
Re: follow example? I'm not so sure
Keith Newton
Bill, I don't think that is a very typical example. Are you sure that the forces involved during the drying process would follow that annual ring? Are you absolutely sure that the ring shake wasn't in the wood beforehand? I think it was already in the wood before drying, and that you should look for an example which is more typical, if you are going to leave this with your article.
response
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Bill, I don't think that is a very typical example....... It's what I could readily find. It clearly illustrates how the internal fractures telegraph to the board surface causing it to look atypical, which was the point of the post.
Are you sure that the forces involved during the drying process would follow that annual ring? They did to some extent in the walnut example. I am sure Richard posted the walnut example because it looked more typical, or maybe he wanted to share the sadness of a charge of 12/4 walnut ruined.
When under severe tension by too fast drying the internal volume will fracture at the weakest spot. In this oak case the fracturing in this part of the board was more on the rings and less on the rays. (there was no fracturing in the 4/4 end of this board which dried at an acceptable rate for its thickness). In the walnut picture fracture was more on the rays, yet some on the rings. But in both cases the fractures revealed themselves in an abnormal surface appearance, which addresses mdclor's question. That was the objective of my posting.
That's Nothing.....
Barry Irby
I have been known to notice my cell phone is missing, Panic and start looking for it and then realize the reason I can't find it is that I am talking on it.
I figured you got the names, but there are questions here all the time about names and E-mail addresses and what not. Some of it seems to be related to whether you have a profile or not. I am only semi literate when it comes to computers, so I wondered.