Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Circular saws

Posts

Circular saws

#1

Circular saws

Frank Orfanello

So it's been about 30 years since I've had to buy a circular saw but now I have to do it.

Has anyone bought one recently? While I don't make my living with it I do use it quite a bit. My old one was a Porter Cable but whatevr model it was, its no longer available.

Any help will be gratefully accepted.

Re: Circular saws

#2

Re: Circular saws

Barry Irby

I have a new Rigid 6 1/2" saw that i got recently. I had a B&D Sawcat that was 7 1/4" for about 30 years before that, but it was stolen. I like the smaller saw well enough and the smaller size has been an advantage. 30 years later, I am not as strong as I was.

Re: Circular saws

#3

Re: Circular saws

C. John Hebert

You just can't kill a Makitta

Re: Circular saws

#4

Big & Small

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If you're working heavy and/or wet wood, it's hard to beat a Milwaukee worm-drive, however if you're doing just general cutting, my favorite is a Porter Cable Saw Boss, a 6" saw that will cut 2x lumber @ 45°. Problem will be that I haven't seen one "corded" for a while and I have no experience with the current 19v cordless model.

Re: Circular saws

#5

Re: Circular saws

Frank Orfanello

Thanks everyone.

I definitely want corded, I don't need to worry about batteries.

I'll take a look at the ones recommended when I'm at the store this weekend.

Re: Circular saws

#6

Re: Circular saws

Mark Nowicki

Look for a saw with a thick base plate if you plan to use a guide.

I have a Makita and a Bosch, and, except for the base, Makita is a better saw.

Mark

Re: Circular saws

#7

Re:Sawcat and Small

Bill Howatt

I still have a B&D Sawcat that I got around 1973. I like it and it is still working fine but admittedly it gets light use.

I was given an old 6-1/2 saw (B&D?) and considered it a piece of junk at first sight. It is now my go-to saw if the blade size is not an issue. The light weight and smaller size is a real plus for typical work with 2x and thinner lumber.

Bill

Re: Circular saws

#8

Re: Circular saws

Keith Newton

Frank, There are plenty of good brands. While it may be nice to have a smaller one for around the shop, I still want plenty of power under the hood, for those times when I have lots of heavy ripping. It is hard to take some of the HP claims seriously, so I always look at the amp rating. Nothing less than 15 cuts it for me.

Re: Circular saws

#9

Re: Circular saws

Jerry Roberts

Ill second the Makita. When I bought my saw abt 8-10 yrs ago I went to the local tool,woodworking place and told the guy I wanted the best he has.He said you cant beat the Makita. Ive put it to moderate use with no problems.

Re: Circular saws

#10

Re:Sawcat and Small

Barry Irby

I don't know how long I had that Sawcat, probably from about about 1973 also. I had bought the Rigid cheap at an auction as a back up. It was new and it does fine.

Speaking of smaller saws I bought the Versacut which uses a 3 1/2" blade. Came with a diamond blade also. It also got stolen. I miss it. Very handy for trim and paneling and plywood. The diamond blade was useful for cutting marble vanity tops to size. I will get another.

Re: Circular saws

#11

Re: Circular saws

William Duffield

You didn't say what your application is. There's a lot of difference between the optimum saw for framing vs. trim carpentry vs. precision breaking down of sheet goods for cabinet and furniture making, especially if you are doing modifications in someone's home.

Re: Circular saws

#12

Re: Circular saws

Frank Orfanello

I agree. 15 amps or nothing. I should have said before this is principally for use as a framing saw.

Re: Circular saws

#13

Re: Circular saws

Frank Orfanello

Mark,

Good point. My old saw had a nice thick base plate.

Re: Circular saws

#14

Re: Circular saws

Frank Orfanello

William,

You're right, it does make a difference. I will principally be using this for framing.

Re: Circular saws

#15

Re: Circular saws

Jerry Roberts

Hmmm. Well,I definitely don't use it for furniture or real precision work. But for trouble free and ease of work and cutting 2x4s etc. you cant beat it.

Re: Circular saws

#16

Re: Circular saws

William Duffield

Then I won't recommend a Festool TS 55 REQ. :)

Re: Circular saws

#17

Re: Circular saws

Roy Girolami

I have a Milwaukee 7 1/4" saw and have used it for many years. One thing that has always bothered me is that the motor is on the left side of the blade. It seems like I'm always having to stretch my neck to see where I'm cutting. i thing PC makes saws with the motor on the left and models with the motor on the right. You might look at them to see if one suits you better.

Roy

Re: Circular saws

#18

Re: Circular saws

Barry Irby

Roy is right. My friend is left handed and we have marveled at the fact that this is the only tool that seems to made for lefty's. And I think opposite hand versions are available, but it might be an adjustment after a life time of struggling.

Worn drive saws seem to dominate the market west of the Mississippi or maybe west of the Rocky's and they seem to be made for righty's. No idea how they market split, but it seems to be true. I don't like the worm drive saws because they are "nose" heavy. the entire saw is in front of the handle and for me would require both hands to use the saw.

If you get a saw with the blade on the other side, I am pretty sure the bolt that holds the blade on will be threaded in the opposite direction you are used to. You will get used to it, but you may find yourself seeing just how tight you can get that bolt.

Re: Circular saws

#19

Think how you'll use it...

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

Most circ saws have the blade on the right for a reason. Imagine having the board on a pair of sawhorses as a right hander. The blade on the right means the bulk of the saw is on the part of the board that will not fall off when cut. Having the motor on the right and blade on the left will make the cut easier to see, but also means that the saw is now sitting on the cutoff piece. Not what I'd like to deal with.

I've used a Milwaukee Tilt Loc for years and really like it. Blade on right doesn't seem to bother me a bit.

Re: Circular saws

#20

Re: Circular saws

Robby Wright - San Marcos, CA

If you are going to use it mostly for framing, then I will kick in with the good old Skil 77. It is a bit heavy, but it is a worm drive saw that will go all day long. Because the body is inline with the blade, it doesn't have any twist to it as you push it along. And, if you are a righty, you won't have any problems seeing the blade.

I have used one for over 45 years. When my last one wore out - nothing left on the commutator - I replaced it with another.

Re: Circular saws

#21

Left Blade

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Cut from the opposite side of the workpiece ;)

Re: Circular saws

#22

I just cut from the bottom.....