A friend is considering having the ductwork cleaned in her townhouse. She has allergy problems that someone apparently suggested might be compounded by accumulations in the ducts. Her options are to ask the local HVAC guys or look around on the Internet. Option 1 has skin in the game ($450, est.) and Option 2 . . . well, you can find any answer you want on the 'net, but with usually no idea of the knowledge or honesty behind it.
I plead ignorance, myself.
So I'm asking here: Anyone with experience, actual knowledge, entertaining stories, etc.?
I researched this quite a bit when we bought our current house. The short version is that "science" says duct cleaning is a waste of money and effort. The EPA, for example, indicates that there is no apparent benefit to duct cleaning. It is highly unlikely that any duct cleaning service will provide true environmental testing results by a certified lab after their service is complete. Why? Because they cannot back up their claims. Yes, the ducts will be "clean," or free of most dust, but vacuuming simply cannot remove or kill mold, bacteria, etc.
Simple logic says that duct cleaning can only be effective if absolutely all impurities are removed from the ducts and kept absolutely sterile. A ducted heating system is an "open" system; air flows from an outside source through the furnace/filters, through the duct work into the home, then back through the cold air return. Any particles that were in the ducting, even if completely removed, will only be deposited again...including allergens, bacteria, pollen spores.....
Add to this that "duct cleaning" is nothing more than vacuuming out the ductlwork and maybe spraying a "sanitizer," that is nothing more than a glorified air freshener.
The only people who benefit from duct cleaning are the folks who charge high dollar for sticking a high volume vacuum cleaner into the duct work. You can file this service under the heading of "too good to be true," as in injecting water vapor into your car's fuel line, increasing fuel mileage by adding a "secret miracle additive sold only on TV, etc. Can you say "...but wait!...?"
If allergens are a problem, invest in high quality furnace filters, MERV 8 at a minimum, MERV 11 or higher if your furnace can handle the restricted air flow.
My cousin who teaches mechanical engineering at a major Univ and specializes in heating and cooling gave me prety much the same advice that Joe did above.
He also said that dryer vents are a very different story and do need cleaning.
Joe has pretty much nailed it. As a Home Inspector I have never seen any benefit of cleaning ducts. I have had no clients report to me of any benefit.
They can run a flail through metal ducts, but can not through the hose version. Even with the flail it does not remove the stuff in the corners. Some company went through my neighborhood trying to sell duct cleaning. Afterward the neighbors got together (at the bus stop) and compared notes. They found that people with gray plastic ducts had been told it was no good and they needed the black version. People with black had been told it was no good and they needed the silver version. And so on. We got to wondering if they were just moving the ducts from house to house. No sales.
Have your friend put filters over the outlets for a couple of weeks. The Borgs have them or you can make them or even use a piece of pantyhose. See if you catch anything.
Cleaning the indoor coil is worthwhile if it needs it. Dirt on the coil promotes mold growth during AC season which may be a health issue, but more importantly it restricts airflow and strangle the system. The symptoms are counter intuitive. Low air floor, but the air is cooler. The Owner hears the system struggling, sticks a hand in the air stream and says, Ah, but the air is nice and cool, and dismisses it. Major killer of AC systems.
And Cleaning the dryer vent is a good idea. Not for mold, But because they are a major source of house fires. the ducting should be all metal (to contain the fire and provide a sturdy wall for cleaning. Plastic slinky ducts are a serious No No. Even at the dryer. If you have not cleaned yours in a year or more do it. I snorted at this and finally did it. Was astounded at the contents. A choked vent also chokes the dry making it dry more slowly and over heating the clothes. Do it.
I 2nd Barry's info on the duct and dryer statements. An appliance tech checked our dryer and told me the problem was the flex duct, with a long run and drooping in the crawlspace, was a major velocity killer. Replaced it with snap-lock duct from the big box store and all is well.
And the info on cleaning the dryer duct on a regular basis can not be stressed enough; I have seen my share of house fires from this. Cleaned my own last fall and was shocked at the amount of lint that was removed. Got a kit from Lowes that worked great; located in the section where the HVAC parts are sold.
Henry, While I don't think they need cleaning that often, or maybe never, but sometimes they can get pretty bad under certain circumstances, so it might be worthwhile to check it out.
I had a friend who studied peanut allergies, that indicated some individuals are so sensitive, that they don't even need to be in the same room with one.
While there is a filter on the intake side, if the ducts are under the floor, the other end is open to crap falling into that end freely, if it can fit between the fins. I stick my iPhone into dark tight spaces regularly to inspect what is back there.
But besides the duct, the air from a damp crawl space will find a way to creep into the living space.
I'd always heard of cleaning them too. I had to replace a couple sections last year. After I opened the ceiling and pulled down the bad sections I did an ARMY style inspection of the rest. Even with using "swamp cooler" exclusively, I didn't see anything in there that caused me to think the money involved was going to be money well spent. Matter of fact, I didn't see anything much at all.
the house across the street from us was empty for a few years, the new owners had their ducts proffesionally cleaned, the found mice, rats, soup cans volley balls, tuperware, pizza boxes.........this is no joke...........well worth the money spent
You are right, but I think there is a distinction. Most duct cleaning is aimed at removing accumulated dust and particulate debris, not trash. On home inspections I have found all manner of trash in ducts. I have found cases where the workers on new houses apparently used floor ducts as trash dumps and swept everything they could into them. Not sure that trash would harbor dust mites and other allergens. Dead vermin is another story. Clearly want them out of there. The trash is more likely to damage the system by restricting air flow and in effect straggling the system.
I am a skeptic on a lot of this stuff. I have not seen any reputable evidence that UV "filters" in ducts do anything. Its hard to believe that flying a pathogen past a UV light at fifty miles and hour is going to kill it.
New construction may be an exception to the "scam" consensus. Worth inspecting in any case.
When we moved into our newly built home, there was a racket coming from the swamp cooler ducts. The tech found the installation manual had been dropped into the duct work.
On a summer trip to Las Vegas a few years ago we had a discussion with a cab driver about the heat. He mentioned a device with a great name of "swamp cooler" which is a lot cooler, pun intended, than "evaporative cooler". I didn't realize they were an official cooling method in dry climates.
Where I live the humidity is very high in the summer so this method would not be effective but I am now curious about how a house is setup with one. In my case with a traditional air-conditioner the furnace ducting is used for both heating and cooling with the evaporator coil in the furnace plenum above the fan.
Swamp coolers are amazingly simple: a basin to hold water, a number of large filters surrounding the basin, a tiny pump to move the water from the basin to wet the filters, and a blower fan. The water in the damp filters evaporates quickly in our low humidity and the fan blows cool, moist air thru ducts into the house.
How the ducts are configured varies, but there is no need for returns. One leaves a window or two partially open to encourage air flow. Houses with furnaces often use the furnace ductwork by closing a gate above the furnace. One never uses the furnace and the cooler at the same time.
Since there is no compressor, swamp coolers are very economical to run.
It may be an urban myth, but I have read that the coolers originated from the old days when folks slept on screened porches at night and would spread a wet towel over a chair and put a fan behind it - todays coolers just automate that process.
I used to buy those shredded aspen pads for mine in Tucson - replaced the pads a couple times a summer just for the aroma of wet aspen wood in the cool air
Couple of things. I used to live in Phoenix and evaporative coolers were an option for many folks. "Swamp Cooler" is just a colloquial name for evaporative coolers. All evaporative coolers work the same way. Water dripped down filter media and air is moved through the the wet media. If the relative humidity of the air is low enough, evaporation occurs which cools the air.
Some problems are that it is not very efficient and their effectiveness is dependent on the relative humidity. They are most effective when the relative humidity is below 20-30%--the lower the better. They also raise the relative humidity in the house which some folks claimed lead to indoor environmental issues.
Their effectiveness is also very variable. As the outside RH changes, the cooling provided varies.
I suggest that anyone interested google "evaporative coolers" for more information.
The more sophisticated installations of evaporative,swamp coolers are set up using the same air ducts as a furnace with the furnace airflow blocked off and a thermostat. The sophistication goes down from there to having the cooler blow thru a window or doorway. A window is always partially open at the other end of the house to allow the air to escape.
It is an effective and low cost way to cool when the humidity is low, it is what I use here outside of Prescott AZ.
That is what I have installed on my front porch and have a duct elbow mounted to the cooler and thru the window. At the other end of the house...bathroom window...is opened and the cool air runs thru the entire house cooling it down when the humidity is below 25 percent. I only wish the weather person on the TV would give the humidity when they report the weather for us daily...about 8 times during the day in my area of Indio, CA.( 22 miles east of Palm Springs)