Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

OT - Oil Based Products going away?

Posts

OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#1

OT - Oil Based Products going away?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Ok, this will probably get the most votes for "Dumb question of the day", but...

They guy at Sherwin Williams told my wife the other day that all Oil Based paints and products are being discontinued due to laws.

I suppose I missed this here already, but is that true? Is it just an Ohio thing? Oil based paints are going away? Oil based varnishes and so on?

Perhaps she misunderstood the guy.

What is the real story?

Thank you.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#2

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

C. John Hebert

It's sad to see this happening because I love oil so much but it's true. Looks like it's going to be a latex world and more work for replacement wood carpenters, as latex offers absolutely no protection for food at all. Let the war begin ha ha ha

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#3

Ditto

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"They guy at Sherwin Williams told my wife the other day that all Oil Based paints and products are being discontinued due to laws."

I was told the same thing 21 years by "the guy" at Sherwin Williams when I insisted on oil based trim paint for the new house.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#4

Re: Ditto

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Well, I guess the jury is still out then.

I'm not a paint guy. I still don't know the difference between paint thinner and mineral spirits.

I hate to paint. Wife does all the painting. She's always painting something. Windows, trim, porch, doors, on and on.

What I do know is that I really dislike Latex paint. The stuff seems to stay soft (rubbery) for ever and makes windows and doors stick. It's also not very durable.

Thanks.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#5

Disagree somewhat

Bill Howatt

Modern, quality latex paint is in my opinion actually quite good and is light-years away from the early versions. I won't argue that oil-based has some characteristics that are better but the gap between them is narrowed.

The evolutionary path was to use latex on most of the house but oil in kitchens and bathrooms. We have Sherwin-Williams latex in our kitchen (about 5 years) and my wife says that in terms of cleaning, etc she has no problem with it at all.

In terms of odor and cleanup, well, oil is the loser period.

billh

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#6

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

Bill Howatt

I think it is happening and even though various oil-based (using the term in a broad sense) finishes are still around you may find the formulations are not the same as the older products with the same name.

Consider the relative shelf-space area for water-based vs oil-based products in the store compared to what it was several years ago.

Bill

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Agree somewhat.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I would go beyond modern acrylics ("latex" is just an awful term) being "quite good", rather, "very good".

I've had to use oil products several times over the years. I really don't get what people like about them. They stink, are a pain to clean up, take forever to dry (and recoat), don't flex with wood, yellow with age, chalk and fade.

As for the durability, if you just grab the cheapest can of whatever acrylic off the shelf, it probably won't hold up. Use a modern, acrylic enamel, and its durability will probably surpass the best oil paints you can find. Virtually all of the R&D in consumer coatings in the last 25 years has been in acrylics, and it has paid off in spades.

Jason, who may or may not have a strong opinion on this subject...

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#8

joining the fray......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I painted the trailer bed the paint formulations expert advised me to use oil based porch floor paint for durability.

For trim, oil trim paint levels better because it dries slower. It is curious that people object to the smell of mineral spirits, incorrectly equating smell with toxic effects, and ignore the lower odor threshold glycol ether or other solvents in latex paints.

I find the smell of mineral spirits or turpentine no problem and I can wash oil paint from a brush faster than water based paint.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#9

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In parts of California, the limits on volatile organic compounds are getting strict enough that oil-based finishes can't comply, not (as I understand it) because of the oil but because of the solvent.

In our area, we can't even buy traditional mineral spirits/paint thinner anymore. Instead, we are treated to some substance that leaves an oily residue on the brush and rapidly gels into something that resembles mechanic's hand soap, but without the effectiveness. I've got a half gallon in my shop, waiting for the next trip to the dump on a hazmat day, when I will turn it in, because it's useless.

I support laws and regulations that will increase the likelihood that my grandchildren, if any, won't be living in the mountains, watching the ocean waves from their porches. But I wish there were more effective substitutes. Oil-based finishes accomplish certain things that no latex I've seen yet can do.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#10

Re: Agree somewhat.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"I would go beyond modern acrylics ("latex" is just an awful term) being "quite good", rather, "very good"."

So, are acrylic and latex paints one in the same?

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#11

Re: joining the fray......

C. John Hebert

BINGO! The longer paint takes to dry, the deeper the penetration and bond. Quick dry isn't better because it's just a surface coating. All these excuses are designed for the home owners and home centers to sell more paint. I've been hearing the "BETTER" improved latex for years, and I just keep replcing the latex cover wood over. It's good for business....keep em comin

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#12

Re: Agree somewhat.

John in NM

Good info Jason. I've been satisfied with premium paint from B-M, no idea what they called it. I'll look out for acrylic enamel.

Our trim needs repainting after a few years in the desert sun. It was from Home Depot as I recall. Lucky for me, the house itself is a tinted whitewash over lime stucco - no painting needed :D

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#13

Latex defined-chemistry content

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Latex is a polymer chemistry description applied to tiny balls of polymer dispersed in water. Latex paint is any composition of polymer so dispersed. There are hundreds of compositions of latex paints varying in cost, durability, crosslinking, luster, etc.

Latex rubber is rubber polymer dispersed in water. Titebond glue is a latex.

It all works the same. The polymer balls are made mushy with solvent (yes latex paint has solvent). The water evaporates, the mushy balls coalesce into a film, the solvent evaporates leaving behind a film whose properties are determined by polymer composition.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#14

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

BrianMonumentCO

But Don't you think that some of the laws in CA have gone TOO far?

Remember that in the dark ages disease was not understood and they acted on things based upon smell alone. CA science sometimes seems to be in that area.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#15

Almost gone... but some still around

mark hennebury

Its the Same in Canada, they have removed all of the oil based paints....except



Rust paint in Home Depot, Farm paints in the Tractor Supply Store, you can still get a few oil based paints, but it is getting harder to find.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#16

I guess that is the dilema...

John in NM

Eco friendly or effective - sadly it seems we cannot have both.

Personally, I have some serious doubts about whether low VOC regulations are necessary, given the scale of things. Taken to an irrational extreme, you are "polluting" with every breath - where do we draw the lines? An appreciation of scale seems kind of important to me when drafting policy.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#17

Recent oil paint experience

Tony Shaftel

Late last year I disassembled and reconditioned a lovely 1947 Delta 17" drill press. Obviously I wanted to use oil paint to repaint it, and found a 'close enough' color chip at a local Sherwin-Williams. "Can I get it in oil?" "Oh yes no problem." I also checked at a closer Dunn-Edwards store. "No, we no longer sell oil paint because local fire department ordinances require special storage."

In mid January, ready to paint the DP, I returned to the S-W store to buy the paint. "Oh I'm so sorry. As of ten days ago we can no longer mix oil paint colors due to Air Quality Management Board regulations. You can only get premixed cans off the shelf." You know, like black, white, red, a couple others.

No problem, that weekend we happened to be visiting our daughter in Nevada, which does not restrict the mixing of oil paint colors. I went to the nearest S-W store in Henderson and whaddayaknow, it's closed...due to fire damage. I had to drive a few extra miles to the next store.

No editorial opinion, just found myself bemused.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#18

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

TomD

You probably have a point there about the food. Wood on the other hand is well protected by latex. Most side by sides against oil, when we could still get it, showed latex was the best.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#19

Re: Ditto

TomD

I use Berh Super gloss inside outside on all general wood trim. You have a point about stickyness, but this stuff is about as good as it gets, that I have seen. One can't try everyting. With a quality brush it lays down like an enamel.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#20

Re: joining the fray......

TomD

You can drink turps. The latex stuff has been getting scarier and scarier. I often come out feeling not so good when painting a room. I will wear a mask if one is handy. Not overly sensitive to finishes. We use Behr super gloss on our boats, and it wears as well as Awlgrip. Well it does well in the sun, surely is not as hard, but then it is easily recoated. People are looking at all kinds of finishes theses days, I just recently was told there is some latex for finishing aluminum they are now using on boats. And people are using road point when they can get it. I want to try some nano paints, but I haven't got around to it. Some pretty amazing stuff is in cans.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#21

Re: I guess that is the dilema...

TomD

There are thousands of chemicals, they are on a jihad on only a few of them, and do nothing about the rest. Obviously durability ought to be an enviro concern since it isn't all that cool for the environment doing everything five times.

I am not sure I would want to live under California regulations, but I love the stuff that comes out of it. The ink was only dry on some of the laws when we got all kinds of amazing stuff like "water based" LPUs. Not something one would have thought possible. Or all the UV cures, and Infusion processes. Not to mention EVOs that don't slurp oil every which way. Not even Harley could solve that one in house.

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#22

Re: OT - Strictly heresay

C. John Hebert

been working on houses for 40+ years, including old historic houses and the only reason I replace wood on these older homes is not from rot or decay, but it would be cost prohibitive to sand the scaled paint off an and repaint. Alot of reason's for scaled paint especially on the southern exposed sides that I won't go into. Almost all wood replacement I've done is due to latex covered wood, especially exterior doors. This thread reminds me of the table saw wars lol

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#23

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: joining the fray......

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

"Leveling better" is an obsolete argument. Acrylic enamels intended for trim have excellent leveling properties. Couple that with good technique (can't mindlessly brush it over and over) or spraying, and I've painted many lineal miles of trim that is indistinguishable from oil paint. But it will stand out in 10 years, because it will not have yellowed. It is also tough, yet flexible without feeling rubbery, so it can move with the wood more than the oil paints can, which tend to chip and crack readily (I've re-painted many miles of oil-painted trim in older houses, too).

As for exterior durability, quality acrylics win hands down, including acrylic primers. I haven't gotten to talk to the guy, but at our local Big Ten university, there was a professor who did a long-term weathering test on different paints and application schedules. The hands-down winner was a clear sealer (waterborne), followed by an acrylic primer, and top-coated with two coats of a quality acrylic paint (you get what you pay for). As I recall, next best was to skip the clear sealer. He even had a large display downtown next to the county parking garage with a sampling of the test panels for a number of years.

Jason

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#24

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: joining the fray......

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I've been drunk several times from using oil-based finishes. Once (the worst) I was spot-spraying oil primer in a rental unit without a respirator. I ended up having to work a couple hours longer than I intended that day because I was way too drunk to make the 45-minute drive home, and it wasn't near as pleasurable as having 5-6 beers.

Another time I was painting some kitchen cabinets by hand in the basement of a synagogue. The fumes from the oil paint gave me a slight buzz and a bad headache.

I've NEVER had a similar experience with waterborne products. A few have had an objectionable smell, but I've never experienced the physiological effects I have with oil-based products.

Jason

Re: OT - Oil Based Products going away?

#25

Re: Recent oil paint experience

Tony - Memphis

Wow, that's wild. I guess I haven't looked for oil paint in many years. Had no idea!

I grew up in Biloxi, MS. We lived on the beach. Our house was over 100 years old (neat old shotgun). Anyway, I remember painting..and painting...and painting. Its like we never quit. The worst was those old shutters that were dark green. Still remember the smell and the paint was like syrup! What a pin to paint those things. Subsequent owners destroyed the quaint old house by "updating" and Katrina floated it off its supports and dropped it a few feet away...sad. Anyway, I don't miss oil based paints! Our current houe has very little to paint (brick) and I am so glad! We tried S.W. Duration and it has been really good paint. We'll use it again unless I'm convinced there is something better. With so little to paint, I don't mind the extra money.

Tony - who does not enjoy painting! Had it sprayed last time.