The daughter and SIL bought a house in which the builder used MDF for the baseboard. (grr!!) Naturally, water has gotten under the paint and the paint has bubbled off in some places.
Would I be correct to assume that those areas can be sanded and repainted?
In other areas, the MDF has swelled up to the degree that it is beyond sanding. Therefore, I think the MDF will need to be replaced. What is the best choice for that?
For the rest, if they're going to live there for a while, give strong consideration to replacing it with paint-grade pine, even if on some economics-driven schedule.
If it is going to be wet all the time then I'd consider PVC moulding if the needed profile is available. The problem is that most of this stuff is made for exterior use so that interior-compatible profiles can be scarce. It would also be possible to buy the raw foam PVC stock and mill it to the needed profile but then you are talking even more money. Failing everything else, paint-grade pine is probably the way to go but I'd certainly prime and paint all of the surfaces before it is installed.
I assume you have fixed the water problem since water leaking will ultimately damage more than just the baseboard. While pine might be a better material than MDF for this problem, wet wood will let the paint peel off too.
I made the mistake of using MDF base in one of my rentals. NEVER AGAIN! Not only does water rapidly destroy it, it chips easily. I used it because it was cheap and they had it in contractor pack that had about a hundred linear feet in them. Looking more closely, I found similar contractor packs of finger jointed pine and it was within pennies of the same price.
They also have high density foam or maybe its vinyl. I replaced the failed MDF with it. They only had the plastic version in OGEE and the MDF was beaded, but I just replaced the entire room.
If you use the pine, paint it all the way around as suggested above. In wet locations hold it up off the floor about 3/8" if you can to keep the bottom edge out of the water as much as possible. Install quarter round or shoe molding to hide the gap.
On a side note, I used the foam/plastic/vinyl shoe molding or quarter round. Never again on that too. If you use air driven nails they will burst it, breaking it in two. Also, After a year the tenants had "scuffed" the outside corners off every corner. In every case it had broken back to the first nail.
(To be clear, if you gave me some MDF baseboard, I would throw it away and buy the pine version.)
Thanks for the replies thus far. The locations aren't wet, except for standard cleaning, mopping, etc. Their future in this location is somewhat unclear, so I might be considering vinyl (PVC?) for the replacements. Is that the consensus recommendation?
Considering the sections that aren't bad, is sanding and repainting the way to go?