Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

Posts

Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#1

Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

Barry Irby

I have a young friend who seems to be something of a savant when it comes to repairing computers. He is very limited in other abilities, socially inept, unemployable, but seems gifted with computers. Another friend asked me to ask him to recover the files on a hard drive on a computer that had crashed. Their local store had tried to repair the computer and failed.

So I take it to my young friend with the explanation that if he can repair the computer that would be good, but the real mission is to get the files off the hard drive. He decides it needs a new mother board and we order one off Ebay. That did not help and he has re-installed the old one. He spent an hour starring at it and found that the fans come on when the unit starts up but one of them runs about thirty seconds and stops, the other one runs about thirty five seconds and stops. He also discovered some bent pins on the CPU and repaired them. The display won't come up.

This is an HP pavillion a6430f PC.

He seems fixated on repairing the computer. My friend has moved on to bigger and better things and just wants the pictures and files back. My question to him was why can't he put the hard drive in another computer and start it there, scan it for viruses, recover the files, and trash the whole thing?

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#2

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

Chuck in Mtl.

at this point your friend should just recover the files from the hard d rive and forget repairing an old computer. Assuming the hard drive still functions it will be an easy task to copy the files over to flash drive or burn them to a cd or other. If the contents of the drive are corrupted then it becomes more difficult. if your friend is a good as you say then the process to recover is not beyond his/her abilities. If the files are very valuable then many companies specialize in this type of recovery but it is expensive. your friend my be "stuck" on repairing the computer to demonstrate to you and himself that hew has this ability but no one should be afraid to learn from the experience. JMHO

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#3

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

Bill Howatt

Yes, that can be done. Having said that, I'll give you some possible "buts".

If the disk file structure was damaged by the main problem on the motherboard or whatever then recovery may be very difficult. There are programs that will do recovery and often they have a free trial version that will show you what you would get back but won't do it until you pay.

The PC being used to read the drive has to have the same interface. If the drive happens to be of the old IDE drive type (data cable is about 2" wide) then the PC needs an IDE interface and if it is real new it may be SATA only (data cable about 1/2" wide).

There are USB to hard-drive adapters, about $25, that adapt drives so they can be accessed via USB. They are universal and will handle IDE, 3.5" SATA, 2.5" SATA drives.

This is not very likely, but I've heard of some laptop PCs using a different drive geometry and it wouldn't work in another machine but this machine is a desktop.

BTW, bent pins on the CPU? - doesn't sound like he or somebody is very careful. The sockets are what are called zero insertion force and if the chip is properly oriented the pins should never get bent.

Bill

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#4

Bent Pins?

Jerry Nicholson

The guy probably bent the pins when he installed the CPU on the new motherboard or re-installed it on the old one. If he did that, he also probably didn't use the proper thermal paste on the re-installation of the CPU and the CPU is probably overheating and shutting down the system after a few seconds.

Sounds to me like the young guy doesn't know nearly as much about computer hardware as he thinks he does.

Jerry

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#5

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

BrianMonumentCO

If the original owner of the hard drive really wants just the data, perhaps you should remind your savant friend to focus on restoring the data from the hard drive to another drive so the data can be used on your friends NEW computer. Doing this hopefully refocuses his efforts on the main function and not restoring the computer. Some older computers are NOT worth the effort to restore.

Take it from me I have em all the way back to the IMSAI 8080 and some are poor imitations of boat anchors.

On the good luck part, it is possible the old drive could just put in a portable box with power and IF cable to connect to a new machine. I had that done for my laptop when I spilled something on the keyboard.

Was able set up the old drive as an external drive for my new laptop.

The old one ready to be replaced anyway.

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#6

put in another comp. and act as a slave ?


Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#7

Can't Break something already broken

Barry Irby

This computer was DOA. My friend had tried and given up on having it repaired. When she heard about the good luck my young friend had repairing my son's laptop, she gave it to me in hopes he could recover her files, but with the understanding that he might mot get them. Sort of a nothing to lose situation.

Thanks for the idea's. We will see if he manages do save anything. And you all are right. With new computers costing only a few hundred dollars, they are not worth fixing, except to retrieve the data. A good argument for Carbonite or some similar solution.

I need to learn the lesson myself. The only thing I ave stored in the Cloud is irrigation.

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#8

Backup! Backup! Backup!

Jerry Nicholson

I have been in this computer game for a lot of years and it seems like NOBODY will listen when the necessity of backing up important data is stressed. That is, until they lose their data! Then they expect magic to happen.

I have multiple hard drives in my main computers so I can easily keep copies of important stuff, like photos and videos (mostly of my grand children). I keep copies on multiple computers. I periodically copy new stuff to an external drive. I cycle a fresh copy into my safe deposit box about every six months.

OK - so I am paranoid! But that is better then losing the irreplaceable! A few years ago I videoed one of my grand daughters dancing around and acting really silly on Christmas Eve (a sugar high, I think). I can be heard on the video telling her I would show it to her boyfriend someday. I showed it to her boyfriend last week!

Jerry

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#9

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

Rick Christopherson

In over simplified terms, most hard drive failures can be divided into 2 classes: Hardware failure and File structure problems. If it's a hardware failure, the drive is more or less a brick to the average person. But the good news is that hardware failures are the least common.

Install the drive in another computer as a second internal drive. If the computer tries to boot to that drive (not likely) then go into the BIOS and make sure the primary boot drive is still the computer's native drive.

The reason for specifying that you install it as an internal SATA drive is because Windows will take some extra repair steps with an internal drive that it will not perform on an external drive (such as a USB connected drive).

Before you boot the computer, have a plan in place on where and how you will extract the data. If it is a partial hardware failure, you may have only a short time to get critical data before it totally fails. Also, you need to pull the data off in the least traumatic way possible. This means don't use any backup or cloning software! Just take the most critical files first and dump them to another drive. Take the files in small chunks to give the drive some "down-time" between transfers to rest it a little. If the drive runs for a little while and fails, then consider some way of keeping the drive cool, such as a ziplock back of ice over the top of it.

Boot the computer and let Windows scan the drive. Windows will likely be able to repair any file structure errors and make the drive usable for extracting files.

Have 2 instances of Windows explorer (file manager) open so you can quickly drag and drop files from the old drive to the backup drive. Prioritize what you take first. Take smaller files before large files. If you still haven't gotten a hardware failure by this point, then you can be more aggressive and use software to either backup or even clone the entire drive (if you wish).

As for the old computer itself, my fist guess from the symptoms would be that the power supply is beginning to fail. It can't provide enough power to the computer for very long, and this will cause the symptoms you see.

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#10

Oh, So True!

Bill Howatt

I guess part of the problem is that hardware really is very good these days lulling people into a false sense of security - "hasn't broken in X years, why would it break now?".

I have friends who have gone through drive failure and the resulting data loss and the need to completely re-install Windows and applications. I have told them about the benefits of drive imaging and even offered to set it up for them, all to no avail.

Bill

Re: Completely OT, Hard drive recovery question

#11

Lessons are learned the herad way....

Chuck in Mtl.

Some lessons are only learned the hard way and backing up is one of them. once the data is lost or compromised only then do we think of it.