Rotten Stone or pumice, which comes first?
Barry Irby
Which is finer? Which comes first in rubbing out a table top?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Rotten Stone or pumice, which comes first?
Barry Irby
Which is finer? Which comes first in rubbing out a table top?
pumice is the coarser of the two
Re: Rotten Stone or pumice, which comes first? *LINK*
Dick Coers
Rottenstone is one word, also known as tripoli. With todays quality abrasives, that's a tough way to go in my opinion. I much prefer rubber block/wet sanding to 600, then going to Abralon. With a little lubricant, Abralon on a random orbit sander will get the job done much more quickly. You can achieve from matt to gloss with a run through Abralon grits.
per Lee Valley
Re: Rotten Stone or pumice, which comes first?
John in NM
Pumice first. The 2F is just about like 600 grit sandpaper, maybe a little less.
I like the technique a lot, but it is a lot of work. I've only done this a few times on some stocks, with varying results. In about 20 years I may be able to give you all the answers 
Re: Rotten Stone or pumice, which comes first?
jcousins
several years ago i switched over from rottenstone to auto swirl remover by meguire - a higher polish and not as messy as sloshing around the paraffin oil. buffs out great
jerry
Re: Rotten Stone or pumice, which comes first?
Steve Schoene
Although you often here these products as if they were to be used in sequence that isn't really the best proceedure. Sand to a something like 600 grit and then go to pumice for the final rub if your goal is to end up with a satin finish. If you are going for gloss, sand to at least 1200 CAMI or 2000P and then shift to rottenstone for the final rubbing. I lubricate either with paraffin oil. But you can substitute a rubbing compound for the pumice or a polishing compound for the rottenstone. You can get even higher gloss using "swirl remover" compound after the polishing compound.