The rule drag method (simple, effective)
Grant in Iowa
Joe,
Unplug stuff, don't cut yourself, don't do this drunk, yadayadayada:
I am a former machinist, so I like to work in thousandths, but this is a too-easy way to get the job done efficiently without the fancy measuring tools that require bifocals these days:
First, you need a steel rule that will stand on its edge by itself. I have an old craftsman rule from a combination square that works well for this procedure. I did "lap" the edges on mine slightly to allow it to stand nicely on its edge. Decide on an edge and an end and mark it with a sharpie so you use the same edge and side each time you do the ruler drag procedure below.
Install the fresh knives in to the jointer and snug them *almost* tight, yet loose enough that the jack screws can move them. Next, mark each knife with your sharpie by putting a 1,2,3 on the cutter head to ease confusion.
Now, make two marks on your outfeed table at the very edge where it overhangs the cutter head. Make each mark near the jack screws, yet allowing access to the jack screws for adjustment purposes. These marks will be where you place your rule laterally.
Now, stand your steel rule on edge such that the 3" mark (or any specific spot really) is exactly on the edge of the outfeed table, with the first 3" overhanging the cutter head. Don't forget to use the edge and end of the rule we talked about above! Lets start on the mark described in the paragraph above nearest the fence. Then rotate by hand the cutter knife labeled "1" so the arc of the knife goes past the overhanging ruler towards the infeed table. If no contact between the ruler and cutter knife is made as it passes, raise the jack screw associated with that end of the #1 knife. Move the ruler to the same 3" location over the other mark you made on the outfeed table and repeat the cutter rotating procedure, adjusting the jack screw upwards until it just makes contact with the ruler as it goes by.
Now, here's the cool part. Once you have the knives in the butter zone, they will each begin "dragging" the ruler a tiny bit as they go by. This tiny amount of drag is what we'll measure knife height with. The math doesn't matter, just know you want them all to drag your ruler about 1/8" from the 3" mark. Always return your ruler to the 3" mark each time you do a knife "fly-by".
Your mileage may vary, but for me, in my shop, with my pseudo calibrated steel rule, and for my particular jointer technique, I find that about a 1/8" ruler drag results in good jointing results. Sure there'll be some purist mathematician engineer type who will interject something about how it is all wrong. He'll undoubtedly use words like Pi, tangential, radii, and other egg headed words. Let me just respond right here and now that if you do this and set each cutter knife so it drags your steel rule about 1/8", you will be reeeeally close to being right on the money. Get your dial caliper out if you doubt me (I did...once, then I put it away and do it this way every time). What results is jointing bliss.
Obviously, you repeat this process with each knife, then check them all once more after you tighten the retainer bolts, then wash rinse repeat until the coveted 1/8" ruler drag is reached when they are tight and you'll be happy. Never again will you dread jointer knife changes, nor covet other men's jointer knife jigs, nor will you waste precious resources on a mag-O-matic setting jig that you could have spent on a good steel rule that has so many other uses.
"But Grant", you say. "It seems like your technique will result in knives that are higher than your outfeed table". Correct you are. They have to be. Consider that a jointed board has a bunch of tiny little arcs cut in it like waves on an elven ocean. Just look real close and you will see them for yourself. The height of these waves is determined by two things: height of jointer knives and feed speed. So, if you can maintain a steady feed speed equal to mine, and you set the knives like I did, you get good results. This is because the knives are set to eeeever so slightly higher than the difference between the wave peaks and valleys. Make sense? How fast do I feed? I do lots of face jointing, and I would guess that I feed about 2 or 3 inches per second, but I never tried to measured it. A 20" board takes me around 10 or so seconds to feed though.
It is really much simpler in real life than it is in text. I promise. If confusion ensues, I trust someone will google up a video of the process, which will make it all crystal clear.
Regards,
Grant in Iowa