Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Markal welder's pencil for walnut

Posts

Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#1

Markal welder's pencil for walnut

Orinda Dan

I am starting a project using walnut and found the Pilot P500 gel pens that I normally use for marking dark woods stopped writing after just light usage. I pulled out several new ones and they all gave out after a short time. I started looking for an alternative and came across the Silver-Streak welder's pencil made by Markal.

While the marks are not quite as visible as a new gel pen, it is more than adequate and can be easily sharpened by an electric pencil sharpener. I have attached a picture showing the points after sharpening in an electric pencil sharpener of the welder's pencil (left) compared with a #2 pencil (center), and a yellow artist pencil (right) that I also tried.


The next picture shows various writing instruments on black walnut:

1=new gel pen, 2=gel pen after light usage, 3=welder's pencil, 4=#2 pencil, 5=yellow artist pencil.

As evident, the welder's pencil was easily visible and approached the legibility of a new gel pen.


The last picture shows a mortise marked with the welder's pencil on 3.75x3.75" thick leg stock. The walnut is from a different batch than the above picture and is lighter in color. There is less contrast between this walnut and the pencil marks, but the marks are still quite workable. I am using a slot mortiser for the mortises, and using the welder's pencil made setting up the machine quite easy.


These pencils are also inexpensive, and a box of 12 costs less than $9 on the Staples website. I hope they will be around for a long time.

Dan

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#2

Item number?

McKay

I looked at Staples and found crayons for lumber, but not anything that would fit in a sharpener.

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#3

705850 maybe?

Henry Higginbotham

I found it by just searching for Markal Silver Streak on the Staples site.

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#4

Or maybe not

Henry Higginbotham

I just saw the less-than-$9 price and assumed. The one I gave the item number for appears to be what we used to call a lead lock in the old board drafting days. So you'd need one of those 2mm lead pointers as well.

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#5

Re: Item number? *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Try this


http://www.staples.com/Silver-Streak-Red-Riter-Welders-Pencil-Silver/product_710677

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#6

Re: Item number?

Orinda Dan

Yep, that's the one.

Sorry about the first picture showing the actual pencil I tried to load not showing up which would have made the search easier. It displayed fine when I previewed it, but the final post did not.

Here is another attempt:


Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#7

Found some on Ebay

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

Different brand from yours. $7.49 for 20 pencils w/free shipping. And they're from Canada eh!

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#9

Another Pilot alternative

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Of all the gel ink pens I have tried the Pilot ink is unique in its resistance to wicking on wood. This new pen is even finer than most, with its 0.36 mm tip. I have been using it during the chest of drawers build and intended to post results after some more evaluation. I am considering removing the barrel to make the pen smaller for getting into tight places. If it is still performing well after another month I will post a final result.

The white pencil certainly makes an easily distinguished line. A possible disadvantage could be how much maintenance it takes to keep the tip sharp enough for precision marking. What ahs been you experience in this matter?

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#10

Re: Another Pilot alternative

Orinda Dan

Hi Bill,

The welder's pen is easily sharpened with an electric pencil sharpener and requires about the same amount of maintenance as a #2 pencil I use for light colored woods.

I will give those pens a try as no sharpening will be required, but I do have a tendency to lose more pens than pencils in my shop for some strange reason.

Dan

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#11

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

Jesse Cloud

For those who like to use marking knives or gauges, try running a line of chalk in the general area, then marking. The line will stand out against the white chalk and erasing is a snap.

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#12

Blue pencil from art store works well.

John Pappas

sx

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#13

Whenever I work walnut...

David Yoho

... I have found using a white pencil works best. It is easily sharpened with a pencil sharpener as well. The difference in using a white colored pencil might be that it dulls sooner than the other options but I haven't found that to be a problem so far. In fact, although I've worked a good amount of walnut in my work, I still have the same pencil I started with.

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#14

Re: Whenever I work walnut...

TomD

I just use HB and work to the shine. Some of those alternative look pretty good, so I might give them a try. I generally find something I don't like and end up back at the pencil. And of course there are knives, with or without chalk. Silk lines and red ink.

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#15

electric pencil sharpener?

Alex Y

Dan, in two of your posts, you have specified an electric pencil sharpener for this welders pencil. Is there something special about the electric sharpener, or just what you have at hand?

For regular pencils, I find the plethora of sharp blades and abrasives in the shop fine for sharpening, and when I do take a handful of pencils upstairs for an "official" sharpening, it is at a hand-cranked sharpener. Would those alternatives not work for the welders pencil (maybe because of finer cut on the electric)?

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#16

no

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Would those alternatives not work for the welders pencil"- No. These hand tool techniques for sharpening would only be applicable on the Hand Tool forum :) Here we would use power shapening, with dust collection of course.

I wish I could do cartoons. The mental image of a DC hooked to a pencil sharpener invites a cartoon.

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#17

Re: no

Orinda Dan

Actually, the lack of dust collection was what allowed me to keep the pencil sharpener in the shop. Several years ago, the kids told my wife their pencil sharpener stopped working and she bought them another one without checking to see why it stopped working. It turns out the kids never emptied the shavings drawer and the motor was not turning! My dismay at the kids being so obtuse was only tempered by upgrading to an electric sharpener in the shop.

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#18

Re: Welder's Pencil for Walnut and Worse

William Duffield

Here's the welder's pencils I use for marking difficult wood:


They're even a bit cheaper than the ones from Staples, but the buck saved could easily be eaten up in gasoline if the hardware store were a couple miles farther away.

Here's my "pencil" sharpener:


Yes, it's electric, but a hand cranked one works just as well.

Get the point?


Hollow grind. Do you think I need to hone it? ;)

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#19

Re: Welder's Pencil for Walnut and Worse

Steve Kreitler

Always good to see people using my company's products :). That's standard soapstone, available at any hardware store (as well as holders to keep it off your hands). We also carry actual pencils with a silver "lead"- they should be near the soapstone on the peg rack. As well, we have a "slim line" welder's marker- it comes with a wide, flat red "lead", but a silver one is also available, and should be hung right next to it. I've been meaning to bring home some of those silver pencils, myself, but I keep forgetting, as most of my work is in lighter colored woods.

Here's the company website if you want to look around-

www.forneyind.com

(yes, I am a Forney rep- and also a long time woodworker and observer of wood central)

Re: Markal welder's pencil for walnut

#20

Re: Welder's Pencil for Walnut and Worse

William Duffield

Thanks for the additional info. After a bit of a search, I found the soapstone markers near the bottom of this page, but I was specifically looking for it:

https://www.forneyind.com/store/results/?product_category_id=630&per_page=25&page=2

The hardware store certainly obfuscated things when they put their sticker right on top of your trademark. I used to work for a woodworking retailer, and was always very careful not to cover up any useful product information with our price stickers.