Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

Posts

sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#1

Adam of Oakland

sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

Adam of Oakland

Hi my friends - Tyro question about shelf supports here.

The span is ~28" wide between carcass uprights in the photo. I've milled 1/2" thick by 1,3/4" wide x ~80" long sawtooth sticks in the assembly. Doug fir, flat-rift sawn mostly. My question is whether you'd glue the sawtooth to the shelf carcass proper, or just use screws. Or would you screw *and* glue ala belt and suspenders.

My intuition says that 7 1,1/4" #6 wood screws should hold even the oppressive syllabus of my betrothed's higher education.

What say you? Here are some figures to help describe my position:



Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#2

Two Answers

Howard in Toronto

Wow - that looks great - I appreciate the photos - I've never seen that setup up close.

As for the answers -

1 - screws the correct length would get the job done

2 - glue and screws wouldn't hurt

My impulse would be screws only - mods down the road would be easier

Howard

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#3

Adam of Oakland

Re: Two Answers

Adam of Oakland

Thanks, Howard in Toronto - That was my intuition, especially since it'd be easier to apply finish to the components that way.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#4

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glu

John Veerkamp

With all of the load straight down, the screws only need to keep the brackets up-right. Screws only is just fine.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#5

Adam of Oakland

Good to know, Thank you 


Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#6

Counter-argument

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I can't quite tell from the photo whether the main boards of that bookcase are 1x or 2x stock. If 1x (3/4" thick, more or less), then gluing the sawtooth boards would add to the stiffness of the sides, resisting any tendency to bow out.

From the photo, that bookcase looks to be tall. Especially with only 1/2" of bearing on the shelf supports, you don't want the sides to bow out, permitting the shelves to fall off the support, leading to all those weighty tomes hitting the floor, probably the night before your bride's thesis defense, when her nerves are already a little tight.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#7

Different issue, different suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You did not mention a back for this book case. It will need one to be stiff.

It is immaterial how the saw teeth are fastened. The load is all vertical so all the screws do is hold the teeth against the sides which involves little force.

I am not a fan of saw teeth for shelf supports. They look clunky. I prefer to drill the sides for shelf pins. A drill jig is readily made from a scrap of 1 1/2" wide lumber. It is unimportant the the holes in the jig be drilled precisely so long as the jig is used in the same orientation to drill the rows of holes on each vertical support.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#8

Both for me...

John in NM

The screws alone will most likely be fine, but I tend to be a glue and screw type. Of course, I also tend to use glue + nails for this sort of job, so perhaps that is what inclines me to glue everything.

That's a pretty neat shelf, I like it. While more involved to make than some of the more pedestrian methods, it's also more interesting, which is kinda the point for us hobbyists :D

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#9

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glu

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Since the force of shelf weight is vertical and concentrated at the teeth you should consider the strength of the vertical grain between the notches. After all, you don't want one splitting along the the line between the notches. Hence , I would tend to make sure that the "inter-tooth" sections have additional support. To do that and maintain flexibility to change things later, I would use No. 6 trim head screws in each block with 3 No. 10 screws in the back strip's length. Alternatively, I'd use a spot of PVA on each block section + the other three screws to take the support stress off the blocks.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#10

Adam of Oakland

Re: Counter-argument

Adam of Oakland

Good points, Bill - I had some concerns about outward bowing with this design. Below is a snapshot of what the carcass boards are made of. They are almost 1" thick, I made them from flat sawn 2x6 shiplap, re-ripped, rotated, glued, planed.

To further secure the assembly, which is 106" tall, I plan on attaching a strip along the top of the shelf, facing back and against the wall, that extends a tab above the shelf. I could then screw this into the double-top plate in the room during install, for increased support. That said, the carcass was dovetailed together, and feels pretty sturdy. the middle tier is about 30" up, and adds a lot of rigidity, too.


Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#11

Adam of Oakland

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glu

Adam of Oakland

Yes, good points - i tried to use rift or flat sawn material for the sawteeth to improve their capacity for avoiding splits along the vertical.

My concern about using screws at each tooth would be that just drilling a hole, and placing a screw there could also introduce a split along the grain, so I was going to try shying away from applying a fastener here.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#12

Re: Screws

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

That's why you pre-drill and use #6 trim heads. All you need do is snug them up to the surface for the support. If the hole and point fixing makes you nervous, use a nickle-sized spot of glue like PVA or a dab of construction tube adhesive.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#13

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glu

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you are concerned about splitting, a concern I do not share considering the potential load on a 28" shelf, then glue it and avoid the extra labor of adding all those screws. The appearance of the screws would detract from the effect.

Again, the concern to worry about is stiffening the assembly. With no apparent cross support midway the shelf is going to be wiggly without a back.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#14

What is stiffening this assembly?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The conversation has been about attaching the "teeth", a detail that I don't see as structurally important how ever it is done. The issue of concern is what is going to stiffen this assembly? A fixed shelf at the top and bottom will be inadequate, if the shelf assembly will be free standing. Something must provide racking resistance. What is the plan for stiffening?

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#15

How About

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Screwing it to the floor and ceiling?

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#16

Adam of Oakland

Re: What is stiffening this assembly?

Adam of Oakland

Yes, stiffening! Thank you for asking guys. This is why I love the forum: bunch of pretty experienced folks. I should have been more clear from the get-go. These shelving units are going to get built into the wall of a room I'm redoing. Some sketchup below. .skp file here:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6Re44ubFkuMM1NoY0R0SDhIRmM/edit?usp=sharing

The shelves will be screwed into the doubletop plate of the room at the ceiling and to the leveling frame at the floor. I had considered applying a few reinforcing strips across the back to further prevent bowing, but the middle tier that is currently joined into the carcass with wedged tenons *feels* adequate. What do you think: crazy? pic below:


Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#17

Works For Me . .


Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#19

BTW....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Ambitious project but it will make the room both attractive and functional.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#20

Re: What is stiffening this assembly?

William Duffield

A warning: If you build a shelving and cabinet unit in one piece and it's the same height as the room, you won't be able to stand it up, because the length of the diagonal from the top back corner to the bottom front corner is longer than the height. The usual strategies are to either build it in two pieces, or make it a little shorter than the ceiling height and hide the gap with crown molding, or make the base frame and toe kick separately, or assemble each cabinet in place. Also, the room IS NOT SQUARE! It's not even close. Plan to make face frames that you can scribe to the walls. Also, make sure any long or tall units you build elsewhere can turn all the corners that you need to navigate to get them into the room. DAMHIKT!

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#21

Screwed by  Pythagoras' Theorem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Been there and done that....once. One does not make that mistake a second time.

Re: sawtooth shelving: screws? glues? screws & glues?

#22

Adam of Oakland

...and Rene Descartes!

Adam of Oakland

You are SOO RIGHT guys! I've grown to admire people who can do built-in work a lot after doing a cabinet/bench system last year in our house. It turned out OK, but I'm reaching a bit further with this ambitious project.

I did test the carcass sides when they were still in pieces within the room where they shall be installed, to make sure they do the rotation upwards without bonking the ceiling. And in theory this thing should make it into the house and around all the corners. If it doesn't fit, you will hear the wailing tears from Oakland all the way to East Tennessee!

You guys are right, nothing, NOTHING is square, or level in this 1911 bungalow, but it's okay. I will be scribing in a few pieces of trim mold before it's all said and done.