Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

Posts

Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#1

Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

Rob Sandow

My parents own about 50 acres of forested land in northeastern PA. Every few years, my dad brings in someone to take down some trees for commercial lumber. The last time it was just pines for 2x4s, but the guy he is bringing in this year wants to take some cherry trees, which he will then deliver to a mill where they will be sliced into flat sawn veneer, I assume probably 1/40". Can anyone tell me how the trees are typically priced while they are still standing, and what the mill would be able to get for the finished product? Just trying to make sure that he is getting a fair deal. Thanks.

Rob

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#2

impossible to say from here

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is no way someone 1000 miles away is going to know what the price

of the standing timber is worth in PA. It all depends on log grade which is only something an experienced buyer can determine after examining the trees/logs, difficulty of harvest, current demand and competition among logging companies. The price of sliced veneer will provide no useful information. You don't even know if you have a veneer log until the tree hits the ground and the log is cut from the tree. An experience buyer can speculate. Novices are best not speculate.

Most states have forestry departments that will advise land owners, or in the case of TN even make an appraisal. Additionally, everywhere has consulting firms that will scale the timber and send information about the timber to logging companies. In any case the only way to get the best price is to engage in competitive bidding. Again the State will have lists of loggers in the area.

The price of a particular species varies widely according to current demand. Before the housing crash standing oak here was bringing $1/bdft and 6 months later nobody was buying at any price. Cherry depends on foreign demand.

Growing timber is better than money in the bank, or most stocks. Unless he has to sell wait. If inflation kicks in as expected the timber is an excellent inflation hedge. I'm not logging anything I own now.

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#3

Re: impossible to say from here

Keith Newton

Bill, I talked to a timber buyer this week. Down here, some of the highest prices are for hardwood pulp, so all the trees that I would consider junk can be cleared out to help the better trees which are left.

The market now is just crazy.

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#4

Re: impossible to say from here

DaleLenz

Foresters advice: As Bill stated > In any case the only way to get the best price is to engage in competitive bidding.

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#5

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer? *LINK*

Dick Coers

Lots of horror stories about over-cutting, "mistakes" made by the cutters, ignored boundaries, etc...Get a state registered, or state employee forester to walk the woods and mark what should be cut. Ask the cutter for references and talk to at least 3 or his customers.


PA DCNR

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#6

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

TomD

I suppose someone has a lot where every tree is a veneer log, but I have yet to see even one when I have cut trees. The US seems to have a lot better lumber than my part of Canada. So there is that.

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#7

Re: impossible to say from here

TomD

Keith two questions 1) with wood, one man's junk can be useful for something else, though it could be impossible to find the person who would pay for it, or there may be no commercial market. Osage is an interesting example, a lot of it isn't nice, but there are markets for it as instrument wood and obviously bows, but a lot of it is cut for firewood, and at one time for fence posts.

2) Is it for sure that cutting away other trees will be good for the remaining ones. They might just leaf out and glow a lot of future knot holes.

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#8

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

Martin S.

I have a BSF and an MSF.

Do not, repeat, do not, sell any timber without a competitive bid.

Sealed bid auction (unless it has changed) is the preferred method.

Some states have forestry departments that work with landowners to help and educate them, sometimes for free. If not, get a consulting forester, to mark the timber, and to give you a bottom line value.

You want the trees to be sold to be marked, at DBH (chest height) and at the base of the stump. Have the paint company mix a color that only you will be able to match. That way you and the cutter know which trees are supposed to be cut, before and after. This prevents the cutter from cutting trees that were supposed to be left.

Make sure your cutting contract has been looked over by an attorney that is familiar with such contracts. You don't want it to say they can cut any time in the next 20 years, for example, as they will let the trees grow on your nickel until year 19.

You also want the contract to be specific about cleanup, who will do it, how they will do it, what will happen to the material left behind. If there is going to be reseeding or reforestation of some kind, it needs to be specific, with check points. IE, after year 2, there will be XX seedlings growing per acre.

I used to be a forester, and if I had 100 acres of timber to sell, I would not do it myself without hiring someone who knew exactly what to watch out for to make sure I was not cheated.

Never, ever, ever sell your timber to the first guy that walks up to your door and offers you money. No doubt you are being low balled.

Re: Price of standing cherry trees vs veneer?

#9

sage advice......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.......that nobody in my neck of the woods seems to heed. I think horse traders are a step up from timber buyers but nobody seems to notice.

A logger cut a veneer grade white oak and two other white oaks on our common property line and then challenged me to sue for the damages. He screwed himself in the end as he was negotiating to push an access road for logging trucks across me to reach a remote boundary he had bought. That possibility quickly ended. After dealing with a half mile skid up and over a steep ridge he abandoned logging the remote tract. I hope he lost his shirt on the deal.