Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

placement of blast gate

Posts

placement of blast gate

#1

placement of blast gate

eliot feldman

Suppose I have a dust collector with a Y connection at the dust collector so that two hoses are connected to two power tools. While using one tool, I would want to have a blast gate shut on the other hose so that all the suction works for the operation tool. Dose it matter if this blast gate is inserted at the dust collector or at the tool? My first thought was that it shouldn't matter, but then I began to imagine the case for very long hoses, in which case it would seem that closer to the dust collector would have to be better.

Re: placement of blast gate

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: placement of blast gate

Jesper, Denmark

It makes no difference where you put it, but maybe it is most practical to have it at the tool.

Re: placement of blast gate

#3

Re: placement of blast gate

eliot feldman

What about my concern in the case where the hose to the turned off machine is extremely long? Isn't there a large pressure drop in proportion to the length of that hose? I mean, imagine it a mile long.

Re: placement of blast gate

#4

Re: placement of blast gate

del schisler

i have the delta dust collector and have 1 single run from the collector and have some elbow's and 1 Y , and i have my gates where it they are handy to use, most run's off the single are 3 feet and on to the other maybe a 5 foot run and another one around 6 foot , i have no trouble with chip's and dust. i have 4 gates close to my equiptment for easy use , my opion won't matter where you put them

Re: placement of blast gate

#5

Re: placement of blast gate

John Veerkamp

unless you have significant leaks in the longer rub, it will make no difference on performance. The second or so to evacuate the extra length is immaterial.

Re: placement of blast gate

#6

Re: placement of blast gate

Keith Newton

It should not matter, except it might be better to keep all your Y's flat, as they would lay on the floor. If you get into long runs where there are multiple drops down to tools, there is a better chance of drop-out of heavier material into a branch in between the longest run and the blower, if they were up on edge.

Otherwise, I put all mine at the tool.

Re: placement of blast gate

#7

Convenience

Bill Howatt

As others have said, it doesn't matter from a technical aspect.

It it does matter from the human nature aspect. Put them in the most convenient place so you will operate them when you should. If you have to keep walking back and forth to make the switch, you'll be moving them to better location later or what's worse, you'll start making a quick cut without the collection enabled for that tool.

The level of convenience depends on your shop layout. I have 2 runs off mine and have it setup with the planar and jointer on a single line with a garbage can chip separator. My TS, BS and sander are on another line. The proximity of the tools on each line makes it easy to enable the in-use tool only. I have to walk by the DC to get from one line to the other so it is also easy to do the turn-on/off of the appropriate lines.

Bill

Re: placement of blast gate

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: placement of blast gate

Jesper, Denmark

When the hose is turned off, there is no flow and no pressure drop in the hose. The pressure drop is at infinity at the closed blast gate.

Re: placement of blast gate

#9

Re: placement of blast gate

eliot feldman

"The pressure drop is at infinity". How interesting! You must be making a mathematical statement. Do you have some sort of equation ( the solution to a differential equation?) that you could share? I'm still concerned about the "thought" experiment when the run is extremely long. I'm beginning to think that there may be a transient phase during which time there is a pressure drop , but that it disappears after an interval (perhaps depending on the length of the run) to a non-pressure drop steady state. Could that be what would happen? Thank you for your attention.