MDF
Vance Hough
I need to reface 50 stair risers with 1/8" mdf board that I will paint. The thinnest that I can find is 1/4" thick. I would like to know if you can thickness plane mdf to achieve the 1/8" I need.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
MDF
Vance Hough
I need to reface 50 stair risers with 1/8" mdf board that I will paint. The thinnest that I can find is 1/4" thick. I would like to know if you can thickness plane mdf to achieve the 1/8" I need.
Consider Masonite
Ellis Walentine
Masonite, the untempered, good-one-side stuff is essentially medium density fiberboard for all intents and purposes. I guess contact cement might be a decent way to apply it without buggering it up with screws or nails. You sure won't get clamps on it.
Ellis
Re: Consider Masonite
Vance Hough
I thought of that but I think mdf will paint better. I'm wondering the effect of the mdf on planer blades.
Re: Consider Masonite
John Lucas
Coat it with a sanding sealer and then it paints fine. I have used it for a workbench top. Glued it down with Contact cement.
Re: Consider Masonite
Yonak
I believe the finished surface of MDF and Masonite are the same. In fact masonite might be considered HDF. If you plane MDF you can, of course, only plane one side.
1/8" MDF is made, but it may not be readily available. I used to get it as a protective covering on bundles of MDF, but no more. The sheets now come often battered from shipment.
It would sure be an interesting experiment
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
MDF doesn't have a lot of internal structure; in that thinness, I would expect an explosion of dust, with not much material left. But no way to know without trying.
I'm with Ellis, although I'd recommend the tempered masonite instead. More stiffness*, and it takes paint well. The untempered stuff might tend to swell under water-based paint (if that's what you're using).
--------
*Although what I can get as "tempered" masonite around here is nothing like the older tempered masonite, which was dark brown and very stiff. I used some as the finished roof, like sheet metal, for an early woodshed. It lasted a good ten years in the elements. Modern stuff would go maybe a year.
Re: MDF
Keith Newton
Is there some good reason that you can't use 1/4"? How much difference can that 1/8" more make? If it pushes the stair cove out too far, I would make new cove that is narrower across the top.
Also, I'm wondering why you need to cover the old risers, could Bondo be an easier path to getting a new look?
Re: MDF
TomD
Or wood filler. The stuff they make today that is sorta foamy in a tub spreads and sands very nicely. I made a painted bookcase where I wanted to use shelves of 1.5 inch and painted. I used 2x lumber for the shelves, but it had some bad surfaces on it, even after I planed it. I just filled it, went fast. I only belaboured the visible parts. There was a quite a bit of hand planing that went into it also, as that was the fastest way to get a really clean surface on softwood.
Re: MDF
Barry Irby
I just typed a long winded response and it evaporated into the ether, so lucky you, this is the short version.
I agree with the Masonite, except that I might scuff sand the face before painting.
Contact cement has not worked well for me lately in the field. Fine in the shop, but in the filed with less than perfect cleanness and imperfect matching surfaces, not so much, so I would try construction adhesive like PL 400.
And, I think I would look at plastic Laminate, like Formica. Comes in hundreds of colors, textures, patrons, water proof, no need to paint or plane.
(I can't imagine planning MDF successfully. At the very least you would have to shower before going into the house and you would die from the dust.)
Re: MDF dust
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I recall the first time I routed an edge detail on some MDF, in the shop. I looked around when I finished the first run, and wondered where the camels were, because I'd somehow been transported to the Sahara during a sandstorm.
Re: MDF dust
Barry Irby
Planing MDF????? I think my dust collector would run away screaming something about "I did NOT sign up for this". Without dust collection we would have to send in the search dogs. But they would come back with a sinus headache would never find anything again. I need a shower just thinking about it.
Re: Consider Masonite
Howard Acheson
>>>> I'm wondering the effect of the mdf on planer blades.
The planer blades will be rapidly dulled. Masonite is a better paint surface than MDF.
Use baltic birch instead?
dIZd
Readily available in 1/8"