Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

Posts

Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#1

Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

Barry Irby

I think I know the answer to this. (no)

Before I bought it, the handy man putting the half bath into the house cut into the main 3" pvc sewer and added a line for a new toilet. It leaks on both sides of the tee. I think I have to cut it out and do it over, using Fernco or No Hub connectors. There is no easy legitimate fix is there? No super glue that properly seals the joints at this late date?

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I suppose...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...you could try running some PVC primer and glue around each joint, hoping that some would wick into the joints and seal them, but I wouldn't be confident of that as a long-term fix. It may work, but I sure wouldn't want to take bets on it. Of course, then there's always silicone tape, but both of these solutions are cheap, quick fixes and not "right". I don't see much point in trying to save $20 and an hour or two of your time.

Jason

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#3

Fitting saver

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

They make tools for cutting out the old pipe from inside a fitting like a tee so the tee can be reused. They aren't cheap, but they will work where removing the fitting is difficult. They are called fitting savers.

Lee

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#4

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I doubt there is any "quick fix" that will hold up. If you have the room, the cheapest and best way would be to cut off the existing pipes far enough back to allow you to add 3 PVC couplings, short sections of pipe and glue in properly. Otherwise the rubber couplings will work ok.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#5

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

John in NM

Apparently, that handyman hasn't learned yet to get the big tub of glue for big pipe. The large fittings need lots of glue.

You could try some of the thin glue made for PVC shower pan liners, I think it's thin enough to wick into the joint, and given that a sewer is low pressure, it might work. You could also try some Plastruct plastic weld cement from the hobby store. It's intended for styrene and ABS but might work as well for PVC. It's definitely thin enough to wick into a joint.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#6

Re: PVC plumbing leak

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Trying to seal the defective joints from the outside in PVC is largely a waste of time. At best you will get a temporary (and fragile) fix.

Cut out the section and renew the area with a new T, slip couplings, and a few sections of pipe.

BTW, if that's a main sewer line, it should be 4" rather than 3" as you wrote.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#7

Codes vary

John in NM

Last time I checked here, you could have 3" throughout in some cases (we do). Depends on your local codes and expected use.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#8

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

Pete in Holland MI

Correct adhesives fail due to improper surface prep.

Being your joint has all ready leaked, the surfaces are now contaminated, and impossible to clean inside of the joint.

Cutting out the old pipe and putting in new....correctly....is the only positive solution.

Pete

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#9

Re: Codes vary

Barry Irby

I would have to look it up also, but smaller houses are permitted to use three inch mains. This was a one bath house and has been converted by the previous owner to a bath and a half. Even so, I am sure the three inch line is adequate, both Code-wise and in the real world.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#10

Thanks, Pete and everyone else.

Barry Irby

I pretty much knew for the beginning it was going to be cut it out and replace it. Won't be much of a job, just hateful. I want to do a proper job, now its just time to screw up my courage to the sticking point.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#11

Re: Thanks, Pete and everyone else.

Steve Schoene

Why can't the "handy man" be called back to fix his error?

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#12

Handyman.....

Barry Irby

Its a long and convoluted tale..... I bought the house at foreclosure, so that pretty much severs the relationship with anyone who went before me. Beyond that, the neighbors tell me the woman who lived in the house was wheelchair bound and pretty much crazy. Some one in the family tried to take the house from her and had the handyman "remodeling" it basically over her objections. Somehow they got her committed and relatives moved in, but failed to make the payments and it went up for sale. The work was incomplete and in some ways sort of bizarre, but most of it is serviceable and pretty nearly Code worthy. Not nearly as bad as some of the goofy amateur stuff I often find. I have no idea who it was or how to find them and I doubt they would fess up, so I will fix it. And improve it while I am at it.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#13

Re: Handyman.....

TomD

Unless you are flipping it on a buyer beware basis, for what PVC costs, why not rip it back to the walls and start all over. One of the simplest, and fastest materials to work with. Of course if this is the only one part he touched...

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#14

Re: Handyman.....

Barry Irby

He seems to have done a reasonably good job on whatever plumbing he touched. I think his problem in this case was he tried to inset the Tee into the main sewer line. It looks to me like it would have been almost impossible to spread the "cut apart enough to insert the Tee and then close the gap enough to get proper insertion into the Tee. I am betting that I will find the pipe barely enters the tee when I cut it out.

And I am flipping this one. I still want to do it well.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#15

Some of the low flow toilets...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...work better with the 3" lines. As I understand it, the water and solids contents of the flush need to sort of fill the pipe, or the water will drain away, leaving future work for the Roto Rooter man or woman.

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#16

Re: Handyman.....

Tony - Memphis

Hey Barry, have you ever looked at the inspection horrors section at the This Old House site? If you haven't, give it a looksie. It is comical and scary.

Tony

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#17

Re: Handyman.....

John McGaw

That scenario had me a bit paranoid when I was doing the tile floor in the bathroom I'm trying to re-do so my elderly mother will be safer and more comfortable when I move her in. There was a great tension between getting the floor level low enough so as not be cause a trip hazard at the doorway yet high enough that the existing toilet flange would be at the right height to set the new accessible toilet all the while keeping the floor level and planar. Had the toilet flange had to drop there was no way I could have handled it myself, the drain piping in the house being a combination of cast iron and galvanized. I could, and did, modify the galvanized so that I could raise the drain for the floating vanity and installed the fancy Schluter shower drain and new trap. I replumbed the hot and cold for that too as well as for the shower and toilet. Had the cast iron needed dropping though and I would have had to bring in a real plumber no matter the cost. My 'on call' plumber treats me well and doesn't gouge but I don't doubt that it would have been hundreds to do what needed to be done. Sometimes you just have to admit to your own limitations (something I don't do well).

Re: Another OT, PVC plumbing leak???

#18

Re: Some of the low flow toilets...

Barry Irby

Plumbing can be touchy. The proper slope on a drain line is between 1/8" per foot to 1/4" per foot. Less, and the water does not have enough velocity to carry the solids, more and the solids get left behind. Truly a case where more is not better. The Early low flow toilets were basically standard toilets with reduced tanks. The joke was that if you flushed them three or four times they worked fine. They changed the internal diameter of the out fall from 2 1/2" to 3 inches and they now work much better.

My understanding is that some cities are suffering from the reduced slow and are have to occasionally flush the sewers. They are combining flushing the supply lines with flushing the sewers. No good deed goes unpunished.