Re: Water Base Stain
Sgian Dubh
"Waterbased stain is a very difficult product to use."
I tend to disagree with you there Steve. Compared to spirit based dyes and stains, hand application of water based stuff is easier. It's slower drying and gives the worker time to get the stuff on and you're much less likely to end up with tide marks, which is a common fault when hand applying spirit based stuff. As Dick mentioned, the key to success is getting the colourant on pretty quickly, and I've been known to use everything from rags to wide emulsion paint brushes to do the job. (Emulsion paint brushes are the sort used in the US to paint walls with water based paints: I can't recall what American call that brush type!)
As is the case with other dyes and stains, it's a case of get the wood wet quickly, keep it wet for five or ten minutes, and wipe off with dry rags for an even job, and the user shouldn't forget to raise the grain with warm water followed up by a quick sanding with something like 220 grit abrasive paper prior to colouring up. Something that helps water dyes penetrate is a few drops of dishwashing detergent added to the mix - it makes water wetter so to speak (a surfactant). A splash of strong ammonia solution added to the mix can also help with penetration.
I like oil based dyes and stains too, and as you say these are easier still to apply, but I do think you are incorrect to categorise water based dyes as "very difficult": they're not if techniques to work with them successfully are practiced, just like every other job really I suppose. Slainte.