Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Water Base Stain

Posts

Water Base Stain

#1

Water Base Stain

gfriend

I decided to try using a water base stain (General Finish Product) on a white oak project. After applying the stain I had some noticeable blotches. ( I did follow directions on applying & wiping off) ..I understood when using water base stain on white oak there would be no need to prewash. Bad Mistake. So how should I correct this? How do you remove water base stain?

Re: Water Base Stain

#2

Re: Water Base Stain

Dick Coers

Constantly amazed that folks would experiment with new finishing materials on a finished piece of furniture instead of a piece of scrap. That being said, I would try flooding the surface with denatured alcohol and scrub with a scotchbrite pad. Wear heavy rubber gloves since denatured alcohol will absorb into your skin instantly! Definitely not going to remove all the product, but will lighten it and remove a lot of color. Trouble with adding alcohol or water, is that the grain will be a rough mess. Lots of swelled fibers. You may have to use a 2 part bleach. Probably the first thing you should do is call General Finishes. Good luck!

Re: Water Base Stain

#3

Re: Water Base Stain

gfriend

Thanks Dick for candid comment....I did try it on a scrap piece of wood & it looked good. Since this is a "small" project I moved forward. Could be another issue I missed...just trying to move forward. Heck I guess I could always paint it!

Re: Water Base Stain

#4

Re: Water Base Stain

Steve Schoene

Waterbased stain is a very difficult product to use. It dries too fast so that when one area has dried, another swipe of the stain over it may darken that area further, leading to the blotches. Oil based stain is MUCH easier to use to get satisfactory results when applied by hand. I suppose someone skilled at spray application could get the waterbased stain to go on evenly.

Re: Water Base Stain

#5

Re: Water Base Stain

Dick Coers

I find it even worse to spray. It really "muddies" up the wood. The only way I have found to make it work is to use a wool pad, or foam backed pad painter. It lets you flood on the stain for a more even color, then lots of rags to wipe it up. Flooding it on is the key to not getting overlap marks. I also don't care for the color choices, they all look like some shade of brown to me. I stopped building for others, so it's just clear coats for me and the family. In business, I preferred ML Campbell's Woodsong. It really bites into the wood, and dries quickly. Best stuff ever for hard maple.

Re: Water Base Stain

#6

Re: Water Base Stain

Sgian Dubh

"Waterbased stain is a very difficult product to use."

I tend to disagree with you there Steve. Compared to spirit based dyes and stains, hand application of water based stuff is easier. It's slower drying and gives the worker time to get the stuff on and you're much less likely to end up with tide marks, which is a common fault when hand applying spirit based stuff. As Dick mentioned, the key to success is getting the colourant on pretty quickly, and I've been known to use everything from rags to wide emulsion paint brushes to do the job. (Emulsion paint brushes are the sort used in the US to paint walls with water based paints: I can't recall what American call that brush type!)

As is the case with other dyes and stains, it's a case of get the wood wet quickly, keep it wet for five or ten minutes, and wipe off with dry rags for an even job, and the user shouldn't forget to raise the grain with warm water followed up by a quick sanding with something like 220 grit abrasive paper prior to colouring up. Something that helps water dyes penetrate is a few drops of dishwashing detergent added to the mix - it makes water wetter so to speak (a surfactant). A splash of strong ammonia solution added to the mix can also help with penetration.

I like oil based dyes and stains too, and as you say these are easier still to apply, but I do think you are incorrect to categorise water based dyes as "very difficult": they're not if techniques to work with them successfully are practiced, just like every other job really I suppose. Slainte.

Re: Water Base Stain

#7

Re: Water Base Stain

Steve Schoene

I'm not talking about water based dye. That's a different beast, especially since there is no binder so it remains correctable at any time until a top coat is applied. My preference is for powdered water soluble dye. It can be flooded on, making the intensity dependent almost entirely on the concentration of the dye mix, with very little variation due to nuances of application.

Dye concentrates that can be mixed with multiple solvents ( eg.TransTint) present particular problems especially for hand application, since many topcoat solvents could lift the dye into the topcoat.

The problem is with the water borne stain, pigment or dye based, that has an acrylic binder that dries quickly, but still needs to be wiped off. And which can blotch when just dry stain is overcoated by a fresh coat of stain.

I agree spirit based dye is also challenging to apply by hand. I am aware of lacquer based wiping stain, but not spirit based stain. I don't doubt it exists but I haven't seen it.

Re: Water Base Stain

#8

Re: Water Base Stain

Sgian Dubh

I see what you're saying now Steve, and given that further elaboration on the constituents of the stain you were discussing I tend to go along with your summary of the challenge at time of application.

The problem with my response is that here in the UK the manufacturers have got into the habit of apparently randomly naming all these colourants either dye or stain according to their preference, so we can end up buying a 'dye' that's really a stain, and a 'stain' that should properly be labelled dye. We have to look carefully at the instructions to determine one from the other prior to purchasing. I'd temporarily forgotten that American manufacturers and users still recognise the difference between a dye and a stain, and created my response with that memory lapse. Slainte.