Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Does White Oak Darken?- data

Posts

Does White Oak Darken?- data

#1

Does White Oak Darken?- data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


This piece of oak was planed several years ago and has been exposed to mostly indoor fluorescent light (daylight lamps) and indirect sunlight. The end was planed this morning to reveal a fresh surface. This color change was replicated with two other pieces of white oak that had seen more or less similar sun and indoor light.

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

#2

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I thought most domestic hardwoods, except Walnut, darken to some degree with exposure to light.

I guess your picture doesn't surprise me.

If somebody asked me "Does White Oak Darken (when exposed to light)?", I would answer yes.

Is this a trick question? Did I get set up?

Regarding Oak - I think I remember hearing Roy Underhill say once in an episode of his show, that if it's brown it's white, if it's white it's red. Wait, I might have that bassackwards or something...

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

#3

A better way to tell those two apart,

Keith Newton

Is to inspect the open cells closely. Red Oak pores are open, while WO cells have little baffles called tylose in the cavities, which usually are a bit smaller also.

Sometimes certain of the WO's will appear reddish, and some RO's will be more whitish.

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

#4

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is this a trick question? Did I get set up?...You must have missed Barry's question earlier

Regarding Oak - I think I remember hearing Roy Underhill say once in an episode of his show, that if it's brown it's white, if it's white it's red. Wait, I might have that bassackwards or something...

Several species get included in what is sold as white oak. The color can be nearly black, dark olive, brown and the sap wood is snow white.

Red oak can be red, pink or brown or even yellowish if it is from far south. With apologies to the southern residents I despised the oak we got from AL and GA and refused to accept it.

The bottom line is that color is not a good indication of species.

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

#5

Re: A better way to tell those two apart,

Barry Irby

I saw Roy do this and I have done it myself. Roy had a piece of red oak he had split or rived out of a billet that was about five feet long. It was about an inch square or less. He stuck one end in a bucket of water and blew through it, blowing bubbles. You can blow through red oak, but not white oak. I have used this technique to sort out whether oak flooring is red or white when I make repairs.

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

#6

I know those tips above, and...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

This-

"Red oak can be red, pink or brown or even yellowish"

describes the red oak floors in my house pretty well. :)

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

#7

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

Terry in Edmonton

yes it does, and it will continue to darken until it is almost chocolate brown.

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

#8

Re: A better way to tell those two apart,

William Duffield

Be careful not to generalize too much. The tyloses in the sap wood of white oak have not closed up, and so air (and fungus mycelia) can still move through them.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tylose

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tylosis_(botany)

I sometimes do a "parlor trick" where I tell people I can taste the difference between red and white oak. (It even works blindfolded.) I put the end of the stick in my mouth and instead of tasting it, I try to blow air through it. With a little practice, you can feel the difference in "back pressure."

Re: Does White Oak Darken?- data

#9

Rick L

Re: Sodium nitrite is guaranteed... *LINK*

Rick L

to identify white oak from red oak. In a business where one deals with stacks of milled lumber daily no one can seperate the two with perfect accuracy.


Sodium nitrite test