Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Table base guidance, please

Posts

Table base guidance, please

#1

Table base guidance, please

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A friend has asked me to make a base for a table he has designed. The table is 5' long, 2' wide but the ends angle off at about a 15º angle. For legs he wants me to use leftover stair spindles -- 14 of them. The base will look something like this:


I tried talking him into another design, one that would have thicker legs with rails between them or even square steel tubing legs (there's a tubing support under the table top, and he's a wonderful welder), but he didn't want that. I have serious concerns about the lateral stability of this thing, but that's the way it goes.

I'm planning on using round tenons on the spindles.

Here's the question: Is it easier to turn each of those round tenons onto the ends of the spindles, or should I counterbore the spindles and stick in dowels?

Any help will be appreciated.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#2

Re: Table base guidance, please

Pat Evans

I would use dowels, but then I don't have a lathe. If your friend didn't like the thicker legs, could you at least talk him into rails (or skirt... whichever you call them) between the spindles at the top. They wouldn't have to be too deep. Just something to add rigidity.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#3

I'm lost

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't understand what is being tenoned, or the whole arrangement of the table.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#4

Re: Table base guidance, please

TomD

Easier is always a tough one, since people's abilities, or equipment differ. For instance, if you have a stand up drill press, mill, lathe, etc... You can rig them to use an anular cutter or a plug cutter, to cut the tenons in a single pass. Normally turning would take longer. Dowels if you can get them in straight and fast, will be stronger than the tenon to mortise joint, since that joint will be sidegrain.

Is the idea to tenon them into that thin plate? That does not seem overly strong, though you will have a ton of them. If it is going into a thin plate, I would drill and tap holes, and hold them in with those flat headed hardware bolts. You would have a lot more positive engagement. I have use two of those to hold a guitar neck on, and they are much more highly stressed in that app.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#5

What an...interesting...design

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'd look to talk him into little stubby aprons between each leg. That would give you some more support. If that's not affordable, something similar would be desirable - little corbels or something.

We have a stool, one of those things with the built-in ladder under the seat. As a result of the requirements for tucking the ladder inside the legs, the legs just use a stub tenon into the top. Someone drove nails through the top down into the legs in an attempt to stabilize it, but it still wobbles like someone who left the condition "three sheets to the wind" behind him several sheets ago.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#6

Re: Table base guidance, please

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Yup, the spindles are going to be tenoned into a top and a base, the plate they are sitting on. That piece is 3/4" thick and I have in mind to drill the round mortises all the way through. The top plate thingy will be screwed to the underside of the table, and the base will be screwed to the floor. This thing won't be moving around. There are two units like this, so, in all, there will be 14 spindle/legs preventing the table top from crashing to the ground.

I do have a floor model drill press, so counterboring might be the more expedient way to do the tenons. I don't have a round tenon cutter, which would make things exquisitely easier.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#7

Re: What an...interesting...design

Bruce, a MN Galoot

He didn't really want tenons of any kind, just have the spindles screwed into place through the top and bottom.

I think I'm going to take your suggestion, Bill. It would take a bit more, but now that I think of it, it might work to join little stubby rails to the legs with sliding dovetails. They don't take much more effort than straight M/T joints and would provide a good mechanical lock.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#8

He has to help out with his welding

Yonak

I don't think there's anything you can do, given the parameters he requires, to keep the table stable. Can he weld a couple of plates that will insert into the bottoms of the foot pads with metal dowels that would insert into bored holes as far up into the spindle legs as you can drill ? This setup top and bottom would be better.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#9

Re: The right way

TomD

Well maybe the best way...

Is to hardware bond in threaded studs. So you get some drill rod and cut it into studs, or some bolts with the heads off, or studs if you can find them. Say they are 1/4" in diameter. You drill 1/4" holes as if you were mounting them as dowels, then you open those holes to 1/2" (or the reverse, depends on your tooling). Then tap the bolts in, so the are centered in the oversized holes. Pour in epoxy to fill the void, something good, like WEST. Let cure, and repeat on the downside. You now had a connection of stud to spindle that you could lift a small car with. You only need to do the outbound spindles, just as one only has solid posts on the ends of a railing, the rest will float in the middle. You then use nuts to bolt these through your plates, and hide the nut into the table top, etc... These rigidly attached spindles will hold the others as floaters. This really works, and if you just plough on through, forgetting that it is unfamiliar, it is really easy to do, for one thing because the accuracy is dialled in because you just need to align the stud in a loose hole, the epoxy does the rest. You don't have to produce exquisite joinery.

I use this technique on all kinds of stuff: The stretchers on my bench, it is a lot neater than captured nuts. Same with the huge breadboards on my bench. It is used to mount windmill blades of wood to their spinner. These blades can be 80 feet long, for 160 foot span, and they use about 24 1/4" studs, Just imagine the load on the roots of those blades. This is the strongest and most versatile way of joining stuff. Normally you would use something conventional, but spindles are likely to be loose even on sturdy railings, let alone this approach.

Spindles are not normally the mainstrenght posts in a rail system, but in this application they will be. That is why it might be justifies in this case. If you could get a lot of penetration for your dowels, you would have other options. Another option is threaded rods held by nuts. In compression the joinery is a lot easier. Actually, a slightly weird option would be biscuits. They would show at the point of intersections but you could cut that excess off. This would mainly be acceptable if the project was to be painted. Actually biscuits would be a lot stiffer than dowels.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#10

Re: The right way

Barry Irby

I have not used a lot of epoxy, but have had good success when I did.

The key to making this base work if it will work at all if to develop a joint that has maximum "withdrawal" strength. (Think of a hammer trying to pull and nail and then trying to pull a screw with the same hammer)

Once you assemble the bases, trying to push the top around and leaving the bottom attached to the floor will bend the pickets. The tops and bottoms of the pickets will act like the hammer trying to pull the connector out of the joints. and it will be trying to bend the top and bottom plates. Spread the pickets as far as you can and I thinks it will be surprisingly sturdy. I would use threaded rod and epoxy in slightly over sized holes. Lets us know how it works.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#11

Re: Table base guidance, please

don stephan

A threaded rod, in wood or epoxy, will have withdrawal resistance, but what about lateral force splitting out the ends of the spindles? And 3/4" top and bottom plates won't have a lot of thickness between spindle and recessed nut, lock washer, and washer.

You might make a mockup using 2x2's and test against typical forces on a table.

Re: Table base guidance, please

#12

Re: Table base guidance, please

James Heaston

How about morticing the square ends of the balusters into the base? Why do you have to have round tenons? You could pocket hole (that's not a bad word on here is it?) screw 'em from the bottom of the base.

So he is screwing the base into the floor. Is this out in the middle of the floor were you can walk around it? If it goes up against a wall then attach the top to the wall.