Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

Posts

Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#1

Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I have this molding all over my house. I'm sure it's the original ~100 year old molding.

It sits on top of the base board.

I have to replace some in a couple rooms including the kitchen.

I have a 2 speed Delta Wood Shaper that I have never used. I don't have any cutters for it either except a bull nose cutter. My dad gave me this shaper. He used it once... it's like new.

Maybe I can have a cutter made? Any idea what that might cost?

Any suggestions on how to make molding like this? I've never made anything like this.

Thank you.


Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#2

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Investigate Lee Valley "Stanley 55" profiles and then go to Eagle and see what they have that might be close.

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Find someone with the right cutters

Ellis Walentine

I made tons of custom moldings in the old days. If I didn't already have the cutters, either I took the job to someone local who had the cutters for his shaper or molding machine, or I ordered cutters for my shaper or overarm router to do the job. Only on short runs did I try to recreate a profile through some combination of saw cuts and router or shaper profiles.

I'd do some snookering around and see if any local millwork shops have something similar in stock. I have a buddy nearby who might be able to help. I'll send him your profile pic and see if he has the cutters.

Ellis

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#4

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

William Duffield

When you say "Delta Wood Shaper" do you mean a real shaper, or that cheesy table top aluminum router table gizmo with the underpowered router motor in it with the incompetent collet and abysmal height adjustment mechanism?

After that depressing introduction, I'm changing horses in midstream to tell you that I would make that molding the same way I make all my moldings, with a sticking board, a rabbet plane and a half set of hollows and rounds. That one is simple enough that you'll only need two hollows and one round, and no side rounds or snipe bills.

More info on the tools and process can be found here:

http://musingsfrombigpink.blogspot.com/

and here:

http://lostartpress.com/collections/books/products/mouldings-in-practice

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#5

Replace don't rebuild

Tom Dunlap

It's hard for me to imagine that Cleveland doesn't have at least one 'old house' store where you could find some moulding taken from a demo house. In every city that I've lived in I've found this sort of store. they're full of bits and bobs to use when restoring old houses.

In the Twin Cities I know of 3-4, you must have one.

Tom

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#6

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding? *LINK*

Dick Coers

Depends on the footage needed, whether you have it made, or order custom cutters and head. Look at the Junior line on the link for smaller spindles.


http://www.cggschmidt.com/store/shaper_cutters.php

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#7

This is the shaper I have

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I use it to store things on...


Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#8

That's no fun

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Then I wouldn't be able to buy a tool...

Sheesh, I hope my wife doesn't read this.

:)

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#9

Re: This is the shaper I have

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

No, that's not the "shaper" of my nightmares.

Probably, Ellis's advice is the way to go. A custom shaper head to fit your shaper will come with "sticker shock," probably to the tune of a couple of Franlkins, and a couple weeks to a month of lead time. OTOH, hollows and rounds (antique wooden molding planes) will either come with major sticker shock or will need sharpening and maybe repairs, and lots of practice if you want to gain proficiency. Sharpening and tuning molding planes is not nearly as simple as getting an old #5 Stanley working. Their only real advantage in today's world is you can use them and the required skills to escape the need to get a new custom cutter every time you need to make a short run of a new molding. It's not surprising that so many hobbyists limit themselves to Shaker, Stickley or lately campaign furniture.

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#10

Here is how I suggest

Keith Newton

I would use a molding head for the table saw. Sears made a set long ago, but I don't know if they still do, but you can find them on ebay. Just so you know, I have 3 shapers, and lots of cutters, and steel blanks that I could grind from scratch, or reshape if I had something close to start with.

Because of the nature of this long slope, I would NOT saw my blanks to 1 x 2 to start with. Once you start developing the shape, there would not be enough flat to keep it from rolling into the cutter, so best to do two back to back until the shape is complete, saving the rabbet until last.

I would put the ogee bit on first, and do the top as you show it, then grind a thumbnail sweep on the straight cutter set, to finish on down to the widest part. The nice thing about using the TS head, is that you can tilt the blade, which makes something generic get pretty close.

If you are running long length, feather-boards are your friend. Best not to try for the final cut in one pass. When you are taking a large cut, there will be lots of chatter, but the final 1/8" or less will be a lot smoother.

Then you can cut the 2", and cut the rabbet, and little quarter round to finish the bottom.

While you are at it, if you need to do 2 rooms, go ahead and run enough to a 3rd, to put in the attic for later. The cost of the material is nothing compared to doing all the setups.

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#11

Here is where I found crown  *LINK*

Dustmaker Mike

I had to replace a piece of crown molding in my house a few weeks ago. I couldn't find it at any of the BORGS or lumber yards around here. I went to Aile's Mill-work in Kent to see if the could duplicate it. The second he looked at it he said that is a B&B product. So he sent me to them to get it. They are a distributor so you will need to go thru a company to get it. Here is there webpage.


B&B

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#12

Different suggestion- Stanley 55, a LV story

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

No, not that useless molding plane. (Well, it may work for straight grained white pine.)

I have made a fair amount of short run molding. Here is what I have learned.....

1. Mow these molding pieces off the edges of a piece of 8/4 lumber. Do a profile on each edge, then rip off the molding piece with table saw.

2. You don't need an exact match. Nobody scrutinizes these profiles to the nearest 1/32 inch.

3. A properly sharpened scraper filed to some shape is amazingly fast at modifying a profile that has been gotten close by other means .

In you specific case the Lee Valley Stanley 55 bit "D" will make most of the shape you need. You can find some round over bit to finish it off. The transition between bit profiles can be scraped smooth.

I didn't look at Eagle bits to see if they had something better.

The story:

When facing a similar task I thought how nice it would be if some company made router bits that replicated the Stanley 55 cutters. So I wrote Eagle with the suggestion. It was rejected. Then I wrote Mr. Lee. I received a note back telling me that the bits would be reproduced. A few months later I received a box from LV that contained the complete set of bits. I have used many of them just for this kind of job.

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#13

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

TomD

You should be able to make that with a table saw.

1) Saw out rectangular section that would hold the finished piece.

2) Cut rebate

3) Cut angle that will be the cove part.

4) Set up the a batten at an angle to the blade, such that it is at the operators side, such that:

a) The height of the blade is the depth of the cove, and

b) the diagonal exposes the width of the cove. This is not difficult to do but a test piece will be needed. If the exposure is 1/4" from straight on you will get a 1/4"x1/8" cut, but from the 90 degree, you will get a cove 1/8" high, and with a radius of 5".

You can decide to cut this step before or after you do the round overs. This will allow you to design the best cove to cut, to best use the table saw blade profile

5) If you haven't cut the roundovers, use a roundover bit, plane, etc... to make these easy shapes.

Re: Any suggestions on how to make this molding?

#14

Ellis Walentine

Sage advice, Keith

Ellis Walentine

That's definitely what I would do if I couldn't find someone else with the right cutters. Great advice.

Ellis