Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Pressure Treated Wood?

Posts

Pressure Treated Wood?

#1

Pressure Treated Wood?

Tom

First off I apologize for the naive question but I recently purchased a lathe in order to one day turn baseball bats. There is a local place where I can purchase the turning blanks for the bats but in the meantime I need to practice.

Can I use pressure treated wood from a Home Depot or Lowe's to practice with? Perhaps using a 4x4 and cutting it? If not pressure treated what would be a better way to begin?

I'm just starting out and thank you for your patience. Any suggestions are greatly appreciated.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#2

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

TomD

There are different degrees of toxicity in pressure treating, and different consentrations. I wouldn't touch any of that stuff myself. One thing about dust is that it never goes away, you will be stuck with some of it probably as long as you live there. Obviously most of it can be cleaned up, but if I wouldn't want to breath it I will not cut it up in the shop, counting on it to be cleaned up later.

Bigger problem with pressure treated around here is that even the premium stuff we get around here is horrible structurally, there are alway large knots and so forth. And the 4x4 stock that is not pressure treated is still mostly heart cut with lots of branches. This could be dangerous to turn, as well as nasty. There is a reason that scaffoding based on 4x4 posts specifies nailed 2x2x4s.

I am sure the first bat I would have turned (had I not started on bowls), would have been fine to use. I still use some of the large tool handles I turned back then. Bats are hardwood, so you might as well learn on the stuff you will be turning, as harwood turns more cleanly. I would get some project wood for real bats, and maybe find some firewood for the practice cuts. You may find you are able to use wet wood to rough turn bats, which given the cost of maple would be a huge cost savings.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#3

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

Chuck Bjorgen

I would stay away from pressure treated wood for turning. It's nasty stuff to breath. Even if you don't sand it there's going to be some dust flying around. Have you tried to locate 4x4 construction lumber? That's what I would practice on. The boys in the turning forum probably will offer some ideas too.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#4

poor practice wood

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You need to be turning a hardwood to get any meaningful practice. You might try to salvage some pallet skids for practice. Unless you have access to a saw mill you may not have a cheap source of practice material.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#5

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

clay foster

Pine is lousy wood to turn, and treated pine is even worse. For learning, use some straight tree limbs, or even some firewood.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#6

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

Tony - Memphis

I wouldn't. For many reasons...not stable, lots of cracks, chemicals, etc. I would look up a local hardwood seller and buy some poplar, maple, etc. blanks. One thing to conisder is to practice with woods that have similar characteristics to your bat material. You can practice tool skills on small blanks too to save a little money.

Tony

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#7

Only if you want to shorten your life....

Dick Coers

ask a termite! Clay is right, get some firewood.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#8

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

Barry Irby

I agree with Bill (as usual) and the others. Pine is a terrible wood to turn and treated wood is worse. Almost every 4x4 at the Borgs has the pith in it, which means its Juvenile wood.

See if you can find a "yard" where they handle pipe. The dunnage under pipe is often 4x4's of hardwood. I have savaged bunches of hardwood from such places. The wood will be much more similar to bat blanks than treated wood.

If you can't find anything else I have noticed the local borgs handle some 4x4's that are not treated. They appear to be low quality fir. Another difficult wood to turn. If they were cedar, they would be better to turn but only slightly.

Find a guy with a bandsaw mill and see if he has some stuff to spare. And, don't forget you can glue up two 2x4's for practice blanks.

Baseball bats are much more subtle than they appear.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#9

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

don stephan

Your local woodturning group or club would be a great place for mentoring and perhaps some classes on spindle turning. A few hours with them may save countless hours of struggle to get comfortable with the tools and how to position and move them along the wood. Often they can get group discounts on tools and equipment as well.

What hasn't yet been mentioned is that construction timber, such as 4x4's and such, aren't kiln dried and often have shrinkage cracks. These can make for dangerous turning.

Kiln dried poplar is available from larger suppliers up to 3" and maybe greater rough thicknesses, and is a great turning wood. You can always start with pieces ripped from 2" rough poplar to gain experience and comfort working on the lathe with the different tools, and then practice on some thicker poplar before buying actual bat blanks.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#10

JL

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

JL

Hardwood is preferably - ideally ash (IMO).

You can turn things in a variety of sizes. If you try it with a 2x2 blank, you can always scale up :D .

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#11

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I made custom bats for my daughters when they were in softball. At that time it was impossible to find small bats. After turning they can be flamed with a torch and then lightly sanded. It gives the bat a special brown look, the envy of team mates.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#12

Thank you!

Tom

Thank you all for your advice. All of it is very helpful. I have taken a few classes already which helped a lot. When in doubt on wood there is a local Rockler store where I can purchase blanks. I may spend the money on blanks from them until I'm more comfortable picking out my own wood.

Family friend runs a plywood distributer. Probably an excellent place to start. Thank you all again for your advice.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#13

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

Jim Hoeller

If you live in an urban area, there may be a forestry department in a local government and that department may have a wood lot with pieces cut to nominal fire wood lengths (16" to 24"). There may also be longer pieces available. You probably will have to split the wood to get the blanks you want and the wood will be green. Green wood turns more easily than dry wood and it is free. The species will depend on where you live. In the Midwest, the most common are silver maple and sycamore.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#14

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

William Duffield

Ash is close to ideal, and much better than maple, but if you can find it, hickory is even more resilient to breaking than ash.

If Rockler uses the same supplier for their bat blanks as another major retailer used when I worked for them, make sure you pick them out in person, instead of relying on someone else to choose your blanks. Some that I have seen had more grain runout than I would find acceptable for a baseball bat.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#15

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

TomD

Ash is an example, those things are not long for this earth with that Emerald Ash Borer, you should be able to find someone with tons of trees. If they are infected, they may not be able to pass them on, but there is a lot of fire brake type work where healthy trees are being condemned.

I know some specialty canadian bats were very popular at one time, and were made of maple.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#16

Ellis Walentine

Begs the question...

Ellis Walentine

What about processed wood from infected trees? Is it infectious? Yikes. Until now I had assumed that the vector (the emerald ash borer) was the only issue. Hmm. Do you have any info on this?

Ellis

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#17

Ash Beetles

Dave Bair

Based on my experience here in Michigan (home base for the borer), ash is perfectly safe provided there is no bark on the wood. The borer's grubs never enter heartwood, just chew their way through the living layer. The borer spreads mainly through the transport of bark-on firewood or possibly through landscaping wood chips. Kiln drying should also take care of any larvae on a live-edge piece.

There is also a disease called "ash yellows" that causes gradual die-back that has been around for years in the east. I don't know if the culprit is a virus, fungus or something else. This could be spread by otherwise clean lumber.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#18

Re: Begs the question...ash issues

Tom Dunlap

Minneapolis is ramping up their program to deal with Emerald Ash Borer. There is going to be selective removal of trees that meet certain criteria. That's another story though.

Here are some things that I've gathered from talking with arborists in areas that are already heavily infested with EAB that might be germaine to woodworkers.

***The borer goes into a healthy tree but doesn't go very deep. Barely into the first layer or two of sapwood. If you've seen wood borers in other wood you'll know what they're boring tunnels look like.

***Any EAB would be cut off when the log or boards have their edge wood milled away. My guess is that if you wanted to use wany edged wood it would be safe since EAB only infest live wood. They don't infest dead tissue...the eatings aren't sustaining.

***Once the tree is dead the EAB won't reinfest.

***EAB is not a disease like ash yellows, Dutch elm disease, white pine blister rust, chestnut blight, etc. What kills the trees is the heavy infestation of EAB which girdle the trees. Google up some images, you'll see what it looks like.

***There have been a few accidents related to standing-dead ash removals. Arborists are finding that the trees dry out VERY quickly on the stump and the strength of the wood is reduced a LOT!!! Trees have shattered and broken off large limbs or at the bases when arborists have rigged limbs and generated shock loads. If the wood is so weak that it's breaking from rigging I have to wonder how different it might be for woodworking.

***There are a number of injectable or soil-drench insecticides being used to kill EAB. They are taken up by this years cambium. A small amount might transfer into past year's growth but not very much. It seems like there is possibly a three year protection going forward. What this means to wood workers is that a tree that has the insecticide in it will still have it around for three more years. This begs the question...How safe is the wood to use if it has sapwood on the edges of the boards?

For the past ten years I've been working south of the EAB line so I'm absorbing EAB info like a Sham Wow! cloth. What is hitting home is that this go-around with this tree killer is a lot like what I was doing when I started my career in the mid/late 70's in the wild days of Dutch Elm Disease. The difference is that the ash trees are a LOT smaller and have the potential for lumber or firewood useage. Arborist friends of mine closer to Detroit have told me that the EAB passes through, kills the ash, then it's back to business as usual in 3-6 years. What's left behind is a lot of stumps and hot sun...no more shade.

Tom

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#19

I have heard different

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The TN forester who gave the program I attended said the wood harbored eggs or bugs, can't remember which. It is further my understanding that neither lumber nor logs can be shipped from a quarantine area suggesting someone thinks the wood has spreading potential. Several counties to the west of me are quarantined. The bugs jumped from up North to Knoxville, TN at a rest stop on I-75 and they are spreading east.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#20

Re: I have heard different

Dave Bair

Quarantines are a farce. How can a quarantine be enforced? How many people can even tell a delimbed ash log from any other species?

The borer is believed to travel less than a mile a year on it's own. All Michigan's state parks that allow camping have the borer, despite DNR's attempts to inspect firewood being brought in. Firewood sellers are either ignorant of the species they sell or simply put profit ahead of any other concern. Even when caught, they got a slap on the wrist.

I assume Michigan is not that much different than anywhere else so you can all plan on losing every mature ash. It is clearly in Canada, too, based on my observations of dead ash trees along the 402 in Ontario.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#21

Re: I have heard different

TomD

I think you are correct about the progress of the disease. The advantage to slowing it down, would be in resources to deal with it; time to find some better solution; time to allow people to use the trees that are affected; and sorta the same concept as time with your loved one before they die of cancer. For instance we have like a 4 foot ash out in front of our house. It is a long way distant from the current center of the infection. I think it will see us through.

Re: Pressure Treated Wood?

#22

Re: I have heard different

TomD

Those are the conditions I have heard also. i don't know why, but once condemned, you can't use the stuff. And let's say the removal of bark was sufficient. That removal might be a process that would spread the disease.

In one instance which was an infestation that affected other trees than ash, some other bug or disease, they had a similar prohibition. One of the trees affected was red spruce, which is I think, a premium choice for certain SS guitars. Never used it myself. I was thinking at the time that it was merely a technical problem and that at @ 1-200 dollars a bft, it might be worth the effort to save the wood. I don't believe they had factored the wood's value, but even if they had, the mere admission that it had value would have skewed the public perception in favour of those who were fighting the removal of the trees on their own particular environmental grounds.