Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Fireplace mantel

Posts

Fireplace mantel

#1

Fireplace mantel

Don in Central Illinois

Friends of mine are remodeling abd want a new mantel. She is thinking of a solid piece of walnut, about 72" x 10" x 4". Central Illinois. I need to know an approximate cost and where I can find hunk of wood lije this. Any hrlp greatly appreciated.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#2

Re: Fireplace mantel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

my experience....it will need to be custom sawed. The house owner will not patient drying it as it will need to be dried (slowly for many months). It will get installed and soon split, and cup as it further dries.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#3

My dad's fireplace mantel was solid

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My father installed a piece of ash of similar dimensions as the mantel in the place I grew up in probably 55 years ago. It was unsplit when we children sold the house five years ago; and the house recently went up for sale again, with the same mantel. The real estate photos didn't show any splits. I think splitting/not will depend on whether it's fastened to allow for wood movement, and the climate.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#4

Re: Fireplace mantel

Howard Norman

I have a solid wood mantel with similar dimensions made from Ponderosa Pine. It was custom sawed about 12 or so years ago and resided in my garage for about five years before it was installed. It has been in place for eight years without any cracking or other bad stuff happening.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#5

My favorable experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The discussion assumes one starts with a freshly sawed piece of wood 4" thick. Somewhere there may be a 4" piece of dry walnut but it will be hard to find it and the price will leave knees weak. I recall seeing someone that specialized in these thick pieces and prices went up to $10-20/bdft

I have a walnut mantle that is 6" thick and it is not split either. However, it was dried under carefully controlled conditions(more than a year) before it was installed in an environment where it could/would experience rapid drying conditions.

Drying 4" thick lumber is a whole different world than drying 4/4 lumber. In my experience obtaining and/ or planing thick mantles for people they don't have the patience to dry something this thick. It looks dry, they stick it above the fire plane, the heat goes on and the wood dries so fast on the outside and ends that it becomes severely stressed.

Other's results may differ.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#6

Re: Fireplace mantel

Chuck Jurvelin

I built one of our former houses in the seventies and made a 5x12 inch x 10 ft. Oak mantel that I had a local mill cut for me. I carefully dried it for about 18 months before installing. One winter evening, with the fireplace burning, my wife and I heard what sounded like a small caliber gunshot. Careful inspection revealed a large crack over half the length of the mantel. I don't know if it was totally due to moisture content or stress that was in the slab of oak or both factors. I removed the mantel and installed a couple of long lag screws to assure that it would stay together, and to my knowledge it still is.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#7

Ellis Walentine

Try Woodfinder®

Ellis Walentine

You might find a Woodfinder supplier who happens to have a plank the right size, but as others have said, it will probably be hit or miss, and the cost to bring it in from California or Pennsylvania might be more than the job is worth.

I made a similar mantle about 35 years ago for a house (and living-room fireplace) I was renovating. It has not suffered any problems, mostly because it was air-dry for several years before I worked it, and it was a crown plank, essentially quartersawn with no pith. Heat and further shrinkage didn't have any noticeable effect on it.

Ellis


Re: Fireplace mantel

#8

Re: Try Woodfinder®

Don in Central Illinois

Spoke sith homeowner last night snd expkained problems and cost of a piece that size and already dry. Think I' m going to build something out of some 1" stock I have on hand.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#9

Another possibility

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I laid one up for daughter's house out of MDF and veneered it.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#10

Re: Another possibility

TomD

Yuck I like veneer a lot, but in a piece like this I wouldn't bother, it just shows one has no idea what one has in the house, which given the popularity of plastic veneer flooring isn't a problem for most people. Nice picture.

I cut a beech slab that dried almost overnight. Vac drying is a possibility. In any case those dimensions are shy 24 board feet, which at 2-20 dollars a bft doesn't sound that crazy for what people spend on junk like granite in the kitchen. You would have to want it.

I lived for a while in a rental that was a smallish concrete block house with beautiful wood and arts and craft details. It had a great fireplace, and the mantel was a huge stick of wood. I can't remember if it checked, it wasn't a problem. Place got bulldozed for a firewood lot.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#11

Re: Oops

TomD

Sorry, I didn't mean to imply those things about your mantel. It looks shipshape. I meant that about veneer relative to the kind of "stick" I assume the OP's folks are after. I don't like that in veneer. But sure, for something refined like what is in your picture, I can see why it would be done that way. I hate MDF, and I think part of the reason is that the stuff I get is so stinky. I got a sheet once that was from a special pallet of "green" MDF, that stuff was great. But the stuff I normally get smells like mushrooms in a bad way.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#12

got one here in St. Louis

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

Woodfinder would have found us too. See lower right of this picture. Price is on the piece (not in front of me) but should be something like $5/bf. Several years old but not kiln dry. Others to choose from too.


Re: Fireplace mantel

#14

Dale Lenz

Ellis:

Dale Lenz

Please define a crown plank? TIA

Re: Fireplace mantel

#15

Re: plus

Don in Central Illinois

Tom, couldn't open either photo. I will try to look at your website. I only live 1 1/2 hours and will try to stopby early next week. Thanks.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#16

Re: plus

Don in Central Illinois

Tom, opened the photos with another computer. Will try for early next week.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#17

call first

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

Weekday visits are by appointment only. Call me 314-570-1175

Re: Fireplace mantel

#18

Ellis Walentine

Crown planks

Ellis Walentine

I've heard that term applies to the first planks either side of the pith of the tree when sawn through and through, basically the widest, best planks in the log. I suppose it could apply to the quartered planks adjacent to the pith on either side.

Maybe finer definitions will prevail.

Ellis

Re: Fireplace mantel

#19

A quibble

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"basically the widest, best planks in the log". It would be a rare tree that had no limbs for the first XX feet, say 12' for an example. Any limbs the tree had in its youth in this 12' are going to be knots in this board. (personally I never heard the term, but then I never saw a log sawed that way because this is typically not the best plank nor the best way to get the best(clearest) lumber.)

The best (clearest) boards are going to be located on the outside of the log. Typically a log is turned as it is sawed and when it gets to about 4=5" the rest goes for pallet lumber. This fact leads to the conclusion that any plank that was sawed within 2" of the pith will include pallet lumber on one face, in most cases.

For a first time I will be sawing a log next week without turning it. There is a crotch involved that I want to recover fiddle back from and that trumps worrying about what the rest of the log is doing. Fiddle back must be sawed parallel to the face of the crotch. I will get a picture of this plank and presumably it will show knots from the the juvenile limbs.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#20

Dale Lenz

Respectfully, I agree...But...I wonder

Dale Lenz

if the term could of came from as Ellis said from a quarter sawn plank near the pith would curve when drying like this: )), hence you get a crown? IDK, just guessing here.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#21

Re: call first

Don in Central Illinois

Will do,thanks.

Re: Fireplace mantel

#22

a distinction

Tom Sontag

Ellis was talking about thick mantle pieces, not 4/4 or even 8/4 boards. It is true that the best grade lumber comes from near the perimeter of the log, but those also have very unbalanced drying forces that would ruin a mantle piece. Balanced drying forces occur when the timber is quarter sawn with equal amounts of wood from both sides of the log. I presume this is why railroad ties always include the pith; nobody wants ties raising up a rail.

So you both are right. Best grade lumber from near the bark, but best humongous whole mantle pieces (where a knot or two is really no big deal anyway) from near the pith.