My favorable experience
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The discussion assumes one starts with a freshly sawed piece of wood 4" thick. Somewhere there may be a 4" piece of dry walnut but it will be hard to find it and the price will leave knees weak. I recall seeing someone that specialized in these thick pieces and prices went up to $10-20/bdft
I have a walnut mantle that is 6" thick and it is not split either. However, it was dried under carefully controlled conditions(more than a year) before it was installed in an environment where it could/would experience rapid drying conditions.
Drying 4" thick lumber is a whole different world than drying 4/4 lumber. In my experience obtaining and/ or planing thick mantles for people they don't have the patience to dry something this thick. It looks dry, they stick it above the fire plane, the heat goes on and the wood dries so fast on the outside and ends that it becomes severely stressed.
Other's results may differ.