Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Urethane questions

Posts

Urethane questions

#1

Urethane questions

Barry Irby

Built a table out of QSWO. Client wants Satin Urethane, so I bought a quart of Minwax only to discover I had about a half can on the shelf of unknown age. It was very tightly sealed and appeared to be in perfect condition. No skim or scum. Stirred it as directed. Wiped the piece with Mineral spirits as directed to remove the dust. Applied a thin coat with a foam brush as directed. It took much longer to dry than expected. In fact, the top was still a bit sticky this morning after about eighteen hours. I left in my gara....er..Shop with the heater running.

So, the questions....Did I not wait for the Mineral Spirits to dry thoroughly enough?

Should I have not used the older urethane?

And, is Urethane urethane? I have some Varathane Floor finish and am considering using it to build the finish. I was going to use it altogether, but it is gloss and they want satin. Can I use it and put on a final coat of Minwax satin urethane? (Afraid I am mixing chemistry here.)

Re: Urethane questions

#2

several issues

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Varnish of any sort dries vastly slower when cool, and never when cold. Move the piece inside to a room you can get hot.

For a "satin" finish it is best to build the finish with clear and then satin for the last coat. A full satin build may result in an opaque looking finish.

Re: Urethane questions

#3

Re: Urethane questions

Dick Coers

Why on earth would you want to mess around with different brands of finishes with unknown possible incompatibility issues, old finishes, or any kind of liquid you have in the garage? Just because it's liquid doesn't mean it will work together. Spend a few bucks and buy fresh finish, IT'S WORTH IT! If you absolutely must save $15, slather it on a scrap and see what happens. Just don't experiment any longer on the finished piece until you know it works.

Re: Urethane questions

#4

Re: Urethane questions

Howard Acheson

When an oil based finish takes a long time to dry it is one of the primary indicators of the product being old. You don't say what the temperature was when you applied the finish. As long as the temperature of the air, wood and finsih was above 50 degrees there should not be problem with drying unless the finish is old.

Buy fresh finishing. No point after spending the money and time on a project to then use questionable finish.

Re: Urethane questions

#5

Re: Urethane questions

TomD

Testing is good. If you can't move the project in, just try a test piece indoors. If that dries, it should be fine, just needs to take more time. Every 10 degrees cooler twice the drying time ish.

I use old stuff. I won't sell it, but on my own stuff sure. I have a can of Z-spar captains varnish I still dip into now and again, that is over thirty years old. It's fine. I have used 20 year old epoxy. If you don't like to gamble do a test. More often than not I just wing it.

I don't worry about mixing stuff, but for the most part I use pretty simple finishes. I shoot 2 part poly and use a lot of epoxy, but for most stuff I like to do real finishes. It isn't romance, many of the old finishes are actually better. You are going to put a boat out in the sun that is one thing. But for stuff with a potential lifespan of 200 years, certainly an easy 100, the complex stuff often isn't that good. And for mixing, you can pretty much mix anything. Where it gets weird is mixing products that someone like Minwax has already formulated. Unless it is one of their base products, I have no idea what is in there.

If it won't dry, you can always hit it with drier, or use some fresher gloss and mix that in. will be fine, and the drier in the varnish will heat up your stuff a little.

Re: Urethane questions

#6

Re: Urethane questions

David Yoho

I think the other replies pretty much make the point of staying away from an old finish or testing it first, so I'll leave that alone.

However, there is another point to be made that Bill mentioned. Whenever a satin finish is desired using varnish or polyurethane from the can without rubbing it out, there's a good way and a bad way and the difference is quite noticeable. Applying multiple coats of satin tends to yield a cloudy or almost plastic look because all the reflective particles in the mix get piled up over themselves coat after coat.

For a more clear look, try using clear gloss for all but the last one or two coats. Make your last coat or two using the satin. The caution here is to watch that the gloss is totally covered by the satin or there will be shinny spots. I learned this years ago from Michael Dresdner and it made a huge difference in how my satin finishes turned out.

Re: Urethane questions

#7

I disagree both  from theory and practice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I nursed a can of favored varnish for 20+ years until it was gone and I have used urethane varnishes I have had for 15 years. If it is not geled it will be fine.

Varnish cures through a catalyzed reaction of oxygen with the polymer that makes up the film forming part of the formulation to cross link it. Nothing is going to happen to the reactive parts of the molecules that make the film. There could be some sort of chemistry that would deactivate the catalyst, but I doubt it.

What is a fact is that humidity will retard the action of the catalyst. And while I don't know the exact relationship for this chemistry it is a good rule of thumb that reaction rates, in this case the crosslinking cure, halves by every 10 degrees of temperature drop.

I spray a fair amount of varnishes. In the summer when it is 85 degrees they go dust free in 4-6 hours. (Full cure is several times longer) At 50-60 degrees I have had it take 2-3 days to get a finish hard enough to handle the piece. Using this rule of thumb a cure to dust-free of 6 hours becomes 12 hours at 75 degrees, 24 hours at 65 degrees and forever colder.

The solution to the problem is to coat where ever coating is done, let the solvent largely flash off and then move the piece to someplace warm. We have a register in a small bathroom. If I open it fully it gets much warmer here than the rest of the house. It becomes a place to cure finishes. If you have a van, the van can become a hot greenhouse on a sunny day, which is another dandy place to cure a finish.

In any case please report back whether your finish cured when you got it warm so we can know if the problem was age of stuff in the can or temperature/humidity.

Re: Urethane questions

#8

Re: I disagree both  from theory and practice

Barry Irby

The shop was cool and it was humid. Cool being probably around 60 degrees. I turned the heater one and left it over night, driving the temperature up closer to eighty. It was cured enough to sand cleanly by morning. Using 320 stearated sand paper without clogging the paper.

I will sand it out and switch to gloss finish for at least two coats and then back to satin for a coat or two.

Thanks for the help.

Re: Urethane questions

#9

Too many coats

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I only put three coats of urethane on a floor, and these are thinned coats. (Thinned varnish brushes and levels better, well, vastly better!) Unless you are going to be grinding a table top glass smooth and rubbing it back out to some gloss, more than 2 coats on furniture will build too thick a film to be attractive (I think).

Re: Urethane questions

#11

I have painted my thumb....again...

Barry Irby

Sanded it and put on a second coat of urethane, this time gloss. Will sand that tomorrow and put on a third and hopefully final cat of satin. Thanks for the help.