Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT (kinda) DuraSeal. Oil vs Water based on floor

Posts

OT (kinda) DuraSeal. Oil vs Water based on floor

#1

OT (kinda) DuraSeal.  Oil vs Water based on floor

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I'm going to have my kitchen floor refinished. No! I am not going to I do it...

I've received a few quotes. They are all basically the same. Several told me they use DuraSeal.

They either do 3 coats of oil based, or 2 coats of water based DuraSeal. Considering wear only (not looks), is there a difference? Does one wear better than the other?

I'm thinking 3 coats of oil based *might* offer slightly better wear/protection.

Thank you.

Re: OT (kinda) DuraSeal. Oil vs Water based on floor

#2

test it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Ask were you can see a piece of wood finished in each material. Check the appearance in good light. Then see how easily you can dent with thumbnail. These tests will reveal the preferred material.

If each dents easily with thumbnail choose none of the above.

Re: OT (kinda) DuraSeal. Oil vs Water based on floor

#3

Not a fan of DuraSeal poly

Andy Halterman: A pedaling fool

If you want waterbased, Bona is the way to go. It's by far the best out there for floors. It's pricey but it's good and good to work with.

For oil poly, I've gone to using Masterline from Sherwin Williams. Cheap, good and easy to work with. Hard to beat for the price.

Buena suerte con su piso.

Andy Halterman

Gonna hit up the dirt jumps this evening in Hendersonville, NC™

Re: OT (kinda) DuraSeal. Oil vs Water based on floor

#4

Why?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Andy, I'm curious as to why you are not a fan of DuraSeal?

Thanks.