Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Making Oak look like Maple????

Posts

Making Oak look like Maple????

#1

Making Oak look like Maple????

Barry Irby

I bought another foreclosure house to remodel and sell. For some reason it has base cabinets, but no wall Cabinets. Appears it never had any. I can't see a trace, not a nail hole, not a shadow in the paint, nothing. The base cabinets are blond maple, apparently natural. Lowe's and HD unfinished oak cabinets that physically match nicely, but of course the grain and color don't. I could buy the oak cabinets and try some sort of finish that de-emphasized the grain and made the color a little more blond. I could buy cabinets that clearly did not match, something like hickory with wild grain and "feature" the wall cabinets. I could paint the base and wall cabinets. I could keep shopping for matching wall cabinets Anybody know where to buy cheap refinished maple wall cabinets? Any suggestion on what to do?

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#2

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Lowes can order Maple cabinets, but I don't know what the price structure is. I think they still deal with Kraftmaid. If Lowes doesn't Home Depot does.

Lee

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#3

Heavy primer and then paint


Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#4

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

David Yoho

I don't think you'll get oak to ever look like maple even painted. Have you looked at Cabinets To Go over on Westwood Ave. ?

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#5

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

Barry Irby

I put a set of Cabinets to Go cabinets in a house several years ago. They were flat packed, but after you got the hang of the assembly it only took a few minutes. They were nice enough, but when I checked the price on line, they were about twice what Lowe's cabinets were. Looking for something more reasonable in this house, I am in the bottom of the market.

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#6

For the Decorators among us????

Barry Irby

What do you think of completely mismatched cabinet top and bottom? I have no decorating sense. I recognize what I like, but have no way to predict what that might be.

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#7

Re: For the Decorators among us????

John E. in SC

I've never seen mismatched cabinets, and can't imagine it would look very good. I think if cost is your main concern, I would just paint them all.

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#8

Re: For the Decorators among us????

Yonak

I would rather see no uppers, and let the new owner decide on cabinets, than mismatched cabinets. My 2¢.

Also, even if you installed cheap cabinets and painted all, the grain would show through and still be mismatched, unless you filled all the grain in the oak.

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#9

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

mdclor

If painting isn't an option (and I agree that it isn't) and the price of the oak uppers is low enough, you could price out re-facing the lowers. It might not be too bad.

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#10

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

2b6

No top cabinets? Maybe the previous owner was a hunchback & every time he went to the counter to make a sandwich he banged his head on the top cabinets. :\

How about birch cabinets? Be a lot easier to match than oak. (if that is even possible)

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#11

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

Howard Acheson

You could hardly find two such dissimilar woods as maple and oak--even if you used white oak. There would be no disguising the differences.

Look on-line. There are many semi-custom cabinet and/or door builders at very reasonable prices.

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#12

Kneale Brownson

Doesn't Barry turn these houses into rentals?


Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#13

Sometimes I do.....

Barry Irby

Probably not this one. I like to rent houses that have 4+ bedrooms and 2+ baths. This one is 3 bedrooms and I bought it based on it having 1 Bathroom. Bought it at foreclosure, meaning the interior was site unseen. I broke in after buying it, they don't even have keys for them, and found it had a half bath not listed on the county records. Happy birthday to me. But, its only 960 SF and I want to turn it around in a hurry and at a minimum cost. Flip this house.

So, Internet cabinets? No upper cabinets? Mismatched cabinets? Open shelves?

I checked at Lowe's yesterday and their "special order" cabinets were $1400. I can buy internet cabinets for about $900. Cabinets to go was more than Lowe's.

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#14

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

Dick Coers

That's why I said heavy primer. If you get the pores filled in the oak, it won't look like wood at all. Same with painted maple.

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#15

Re: Sometimes I do.....

Stuart Johnson

Have you thought about building the boxes and purchasing doors?

Re: Making Oak look like Maple????

#17

Re: Sometimes I do.....

Barry Irby

Yes, I have a friend that is a cabinet maker and he orders most of the doors for his kitchens. I am going to check with him for advice. He recently had a heart valve replaced, so he can't do the work for me.