Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Shop Floors

Posts

Shop Floors

#1

Shop Floors

Erik in Augusta, GA

I am about to start installing some eastern white pine floors in my new shop and have been thinking about what, if any, finish to use. At this point I am leaning towards tung oil....any other recommendations out there?

I would like to add a little color just to darken the floor a little and something that will provide a little protection but it will be a shop so I expect plenty of scratches, dents, dings, stains, etc. The bonus room above will also be finished and will be more of a finished studio space for the rest of the family.

Re: Shop Floors

#2

Is practical a consideration?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If so paint it an off white oil based porch enamel. According to my brother in law the lighting engineer a light colored floor will reflect significant light back to the work area, a good thing that will reduce lighting source needs.

One philosophy of floor finish is that a durable floor finish will absorb the abuse and not the wood, making refinishing easier. White pine is a very soft material for a floor.

A painted floor will be easier to sweep.

I can't think of any attribute of oil that would make it a desirable floor finish.

Re: Shop Floors

#3

"White pine is a very soft material for a floor"

Henry (Raleigh NC)

I doubt I would use such a soft material. It will have plenty of 'character' soon after you use it.

Henry

Re: Shop Floors

#4

Re: Shop Floors

John Veerkamp

I second the paint for easier cleanup. Porch and floor paints are available in many colors. If you want to keep it "natural" any oil will darken it some. I'd then coat it with a poly in whatever sheen you like.

Re: Shop Floors

#5

Re: Shop Floors

Howard

I would consider adding anti slip grit to the paint.

Howard

Re: Shop Floors

#6

Re: Shop Floors

BrianMonumentCO

I agree that pine is too soft for a shop floor.

There are other harder woods that are better suited for a shop floor.

But I would never use pine under stationary power tools such as a table saw, jointer, planer or drill press.

They need harder bases to sit upon.

If you use mobile bases the pine will fail......

Re: Shop Floors

#7

Pine won't hold up.

David McDonnel "Mac"

I've seen too many plywood floors fail where the soft grain wears away. Pine would do the same. I found a local flooring manufacturer an bought 4" wide strip oak then coated it with McClosky Gymseal three coats. Wearing like iron after 10+ years of abuse!

Re: Shop Floors

#8

Paul Kramer

Re: Shop Floors

Paul Kramer

I used 3/4" plywood covered with 1/4" hardboard (Masonite) and then coated with floor paint with grit. It has held up well to rolling machines, etc. but hasn't done any significant damage to dropped tools. I'd do it over the same way if I had to do it again.

Paul

Re: Shop Floors

#9

JL

How about SYP?

JL

I have used SYP for my stair treads. It has held up well.

The stage floor of the playhouse consists of two layers of SYP.

SYP - Southern Yellow Pine.

Re: Shop Floors

#10

Ellis Walentine

Echo the recommendations

Ellis Walentine

You won't be happy with a white pine shop floor. I have white pine in my downstairs addition and in one bedroom. Even with three coats of polyurethane, it is no match for foot traffic, rolling chairs, grit or dropped items. Without a hard coating, it would be much worse, and in a shop, well I know I'd regret it.

I had southern yellow pine in my previous shop and it held up fine. I now have T&G yellow pine plywood with a coat of hard primer on it and it's also held up well for the past 15 years.

Whatever you use, seal or coat it with something durable and abrasion resistant.

My 2¢.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Shop Floors

#11

Re: Echo the recommendations

TomD

It is an old story, but historically pine was prized for flooring, an impression that may persist. Old growth pine had tight grain lines, and in softwood, tight grain makes the pine harder wearing. Fast growth modern plantation pine is weak where compression is concerned. It isn't bad for certain structural uses that do not rely on resistance to compression perp to the grain.

In contrast, old grown ring porous woods like oak, were riddled with the brittle pores that a tighter placement of the rings would provide. These woods were "brash". But their faster growth versions today are ok for flooring.

At least, I heard it that way.