Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Finish for desk questions

Posts

Finish for desk questions

#1

Finish for desk questions

Barry Irby

Building a table/desk for a friend of mine. He is a house painter (in a previous life) and said he thought Urethane would be the best finish. I can spray lacquer, but have not tried Urethane. Is urethane harder than lacquer? Not harder to apply but a harder surface that would not dent as easily. The surface is White Oak. If you used urethane, how would you apply it?

Re: Finish for desk questions

#2

Re: Finish for desk questions

John Veerkamp

I like wipe on Poly-urethane in satin sheen. Apply 3 or 4 coats for the top.

Re: Finish for desk questions

#3

Re: Finish for desk questions

Dick Coers

Lacquer will cure much faster, but not sure of the final hardness of polyurethane compared to the hardness of lacquer. Fairly certain lacquer is harder. Lacquer fell out of favor for modern tables because of it's lower resistance to water, alcohol, and less heat resistance. Somewhere in history, the general public took less care of wood furniture and wanted to treat it like plastic. My Grandmother's dining table hardly ever saw the light of day. It always had thick pads under a table cloth. If she had a desk, it would have definitely had a protector on it as well.

Re: Finish for desk questions

#4

Re: Finish for desk questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have sprayed gallons of it........., in the summer. Now how you get it to harden in this cold weather will be a problem to solve. Thin some to reduce viscosity. Makes a durable surface.

An alternative would be conversion varnish.

Re: Finish for desk questions

#5

Re: Finish for desk questions

Howard Acheson

Urethane is not a "harder" finish. Instead it's a "tougher" finish. Urethane is formulated to be able to be softer so it can take more abuse. It will not scratch as much or as easily as a hard finish like laquer. It can take a hit with cracking or crazing.

Spraying an oil based finish is not advisable. Oil based finishes are slow drying so the over spray is in the form of liquid droplets that float in the air. They will cover all the surfaces in the shop and dry to a crust on them.

Spraying oil based finishes should only be done if you you have a good paint both or it you spray outside.

Re: Finish for desk questions

#6

Urethane can be and usually is harder

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Urethane name may offer a clue to how one of the components in the finish was made. Given the near infinite kinds of urethanes that could be made the "Urethane" label tells us little. However, in general urethane varnish is the hardest finish you can easily buy. Unfortunately, the wimpy urethanes easily obtainable pale compared to the urethane varnish that was common 30 years ago. It could not be easily dented even by large dog claws.

To test the hardness of a finish simply try to dent it with the thumb nail. You will find that the Urethanes vary in hardness with those formulated for floors likely hardest.

Re: Finish for desk questions

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Finish for desk questions

Clint Searl

Several coats of waterborne poly floor finish, applied with a soft bristle brush will be as good as anything. I like Bona Mega or Varathane.

Re: Finish for desk questions

#8

Re: Finish for desk questions

AZ in Colorado Springs

I refinished a kitchen table in the mid '90s, and have built a couple of tables and kitchen islands in the past four years, all coated with Minwax satin oil-based ployurethane. They've all held up well. Someone mentioned using several coats of wiping poly, but I think this is much too thin a final finish. For these surfaces I used five or six coats of brushed-on poly.

Now, you mentioned a desk. I made a desk for my daughter a few years ago, a simple design from PWM that can be dis-assembled easily, because she was in the habit of moving every summer (right after I delivered the desk to her, she bought the townhome she was renting, but she still has the desk that is easily moved ... ) For this, I also gave her a desk top pad for a writing surface, as I think the nib of a pen or the tip of a pencil could mar the surface more easily thansay dishes or flatware on a table.

I like using wipe-on poly -- especially for veritcal surfaces and around corners or covering profiled edges. You still need to be careful, but there's much less tendency for drips, runs, or sags. It builds the film finish slowly, though, so I brush on the poly for table tops.

Good luck