Re: Finish for desk questions
AZ in Colorado Springs
I refinished a kitchen table in the mid '90s, and have built a couple of tables and kitchen islands in the past four years, all coated with Minwax satin oil-based ployurethane. They've all held up well. Someone mentioned using several coats of wiping poly, but I think this is much too thin a final finish. For these surfaces I used five or six coats of brushed-on poly.
Now, you mentioned a desk. I made a desk for my daughter a few years ago, a simple design from PWM that can be dis-assembled easily, because she was in the habit of moving every summer (right after I delivered the desk to her, she bought the townhome she was renting, but she still has the desk that is easily moved ... ) For this, I also gave her a desk top pad for a writing surface, as I think the nib of a pen or the tip of a pencil could mar the surface more easily thansay dishes or flatware on a table.
I like using wipe-on poly -- especially for veritcal surfaces and around corners or covering profiled edges. You still need to be careful, but there's much less tendency for drips, runs, or sags. It builds the film finish slowly, though, so I brush on the poly for table tops.
Good luck