While cutting some wood on my band saw yesterday, my Shop Vac. sounded like a deranged tolet going through the pangs of death,and then quit. I shut it off. I restarted it and it ran for about 20 seconds and the "noise" started again. I could not smell any thing burning. I think it was/is just tired. It is 15 years old. With out going to the bank and taking out a loan, what is a "good replacement"? I need one that I can clean with,attach to various mach. as well as cleaning out SWIMBO'S truck. A little help please.
I have no experience with the high end ones like the Fien or other brands that sell for a couple of house payments. They may be wonderful, but are too rich for my blood.
I had an old Sears/Craftsman one that lasted about thirty years and finally died for about the third time. I could not resuscitate it again. It was a howling banshee but it was powerful and Cheap. It was a 30 gallon one and if it were still available I would buy another.
I bought a Shop Vac "door buster special" at Lowe's. About 14 gallons. Under powered and worthless. Very Cheap. I gave it away. Would not buy another, it did not suck enough.
A friend gave me an old Rigid one about 16 gallons. I liked it, but it got stolen along with the rest of my tools out of a house we were remodeling. I bought another for under a hundred bucks and it is fine (but not Fien).
Compare the suction rating and noise level (on the box of the Rigid units). Buy the most powerful quietest one you can.
Some of them have an outlet on them that allows you to plug and sander (whatever) into them and the vac comes on with the tool. Seems like a neat feature, but I don't have one. You can buy an outlet setup like that from Sears that will do the same thing.
I've been happy with a ridgid "6HP, 16 gal. unit that I've had for about 15 years now. it does all the shop duties, car cleaning and general heavy duty around the house cleanup jobs, as well as having been pressed into service a couple of times for water/flood abatement. It's pretty noisy, but at the $99 price point that is what you get. I'd buy another if this one ever gives up the ghost.
It may depend on how you plan to use it, as for choosing a size. About a year ago, I did some test with 4 different ones in my shop, of various sizes. They all pulled water up a clear vinyl tube about the same height, which seems like about 25", here in LR, which is about 300' elevation. The smallest was a little 1gallon sears, the next up in size was a Rigid 4 gallon, 1.5" hose, and 2 Sears 16 gallon, 2.25" hose.
The little ones are to take out to small installs, to clean up after installing drawer pulls etc. The larger ones are wired into two of my table saw switches, and or used to clean up anything else.
The point I wanted you to think about though, is that more important than inches of water drawn up a tube, is the area increase in size at the end of the hose. The area of a 1.25 hose is 1.22", but for 2.25" jumps to 3.97". That is 3.25 time as much air can flow into that end, given the same drop in pressure, so this is another of those times where larger size matters.
I can't see spending the extra money for a quieter, since I can't hear either of these from in front of my TS's when they are running.
It may just need a cleaning and lube. Before just trashing it I would take it down and make sure that there is not an accumulation of dust and dirt causing it to hang up.
I hate to mention the "C-Word" (Craftsman) on this forum BUT . . . I run their 9 gallon as my dust collection. Probably two hours a day, most days, plus house and cars. I normally get eight or nine years out of them. If you got fifteen, you had a good one ! I considerthem more dependable and/or affordable than others. I spend a little more but I figure I get my money's worth plus.
Static pressure, measured in inches H2O and CFM. Static pressure will remain the same across a smaller opening, but the opening will limit the CFM (what you are referring to in your post). Opening up the orifice will allow the vacuum to pull more CFM at the same static pressure, until you hit the maximum CFM that the fan/motor can move - then a larger orifice will cause the static pressure to drop because the CFM stays the same.
As you say, intended use makes a huge difference. A jobsite cleanup vac can be a little one and doesn't need an aggressive suck. A vac hooked up to a router fence has (in my case) a very limited orifice so does not need to be a high CFM machine. A vac hooked up to a belt sander does need to be a high CFM machine to get all the fine dust - orifice size is effectively unlimited. Most high CFM vacs also have high static pressure ratings, and commensurately high prices
Not having a dust collector, I tend to use the vacuum in it's place when needed (like routing with a fence or sanding) and just put up with the mess where it's not as crucial (planing and jointing, etc).
One of the best vacuums I've used is a Dayton unit we have at work.
Your old vac may not be at the end of its life. It is quite likely that cleaning, brush replacement, and possibly a commutator polish will bring it back to screeching life. Other than that, I am a believer in Fein vacuums, having had their large one for 15 years and using it for many nasty tasks -- a vacuum that will handle drywall sanding dust will likely handle anything.
The Fein rep at The Woodworking Shows told me that Fein vacs were temporarily out of production. Something about a major parts supplier going out of business, I think. He said they would have a couple of new models in a few months, maybe shaped more like the Festool. That's a shame--I have a Festool and wish I had a Fein instead.
I have only used low end vacs. but in my experience the filters are too fine. The filters quickly pack up. The vac continues to work, it just blows dust out the exhaust while picking up the larger chips. I don't know about more expensive vacs. If I remember, I check the filter before using. Jerry
I had a Monkey Wards shop vac for years until it died. It was loud but did a decent job wet or dry. My Dad had a bigger Craftsman unit that screamed and did a mediocre job but had a large capacity.
I was at a Home show and saw a Demo of a Fein Turbo II and like what I saw and what I didn't hear even better. The stats on it are great.
static water lift: 90-Inch
average of 60 dB (A) noise level at 3.5-Feet (which equates to Conversational speech, 36")
16 ft vacuum hose (1-1/4 in dia.) and 5 micron filter
You can actually stand next to the vacuum when running full power and have a conversation without shouting and never feel the need to grab your sound protection head phones every time you have it running.
In this case you get what you pay for which is a machine that performs and is pleasant to work with.
I use the big Ridgid with a Rockler Dust Right Vortex bungeed to it. I got a dust bag for the small amount of fine dust that gets through and rarely need to change the bag. The filter stays clean. It's less noisy than my previous Craftsman, but ear muffs are desirable. My trick is a heavy flexible coil hose extension off the vortex to which a 20 foot special order Ridgid hose is attached. Suck is good even with this attachment. The vacuum remains parked and the hose can be moved to the table saw, the small planer, or the workbench as needed. I too recommend a unit with 2 1/4 inch hose as it will not clog with hand plane shavings or even smaller wood chunks.
Thank you one and all! After Church yesterday, my wife sugested we go to Lowe's to pick up some plants. While there, I walked to the Isle where the Shop Vacs were. She had beat me there, had employee load a Stanless Steel Vac. on a flat cart, ready to push to the check out stand. "Lets go,you deserve a new one" What a nice surprise!!!! No $$$$ out of my budget, ain't Love Grand, now I just have to put it together today, and plant the 20 or so plants.
Ditto to everything Mack said about the Rockler Vortec. I also have a Vortec and it collects the big debris and keeps the filter clean. Rarely have to clean the filter inside the shop vac, and the Vortec is a bit easier to empty.
My son has a stainless steel Shop Vac. That's a good machine.