Fortunately I only have to scribe items to walls every few years. An Accuscribe tool works well for me except that the pencil point quickly dulls, leaving a broad line. A .5mm mechanical pencil wouldn't fit the Accuscribe without trying to drill it larger. How do those who scribe all the time keep a fine pencil line?
My scribing tool is homemade, so it depends on a snug fit to hold the pencil. Have to sharpen without removing it as much as possible, so I usually use a sharp chisel. Some 150 grit paper might do it as well, but not as fast.
I've never been so good at scribing, so a fat line doesn't bother me much. I'm not likely to get so tight a scribe that a few tenths of mm matter much
What I do is put the material close to the wall, lay a washer on it, put a pencil in the hole and role the washer alone the wall with the pencil, drawing a line on the material. Most of the time I use a belt sander with a 36 grit belt to sand to the line or parallel to the line. Since the washer controls the inside edge of the line, I sand to that, leaving the line, no matter how wide it is on the material. If the fit is close to start with, I just stand the pencil up on the wall and slide it alone the wall.
Don, you don't tell what you are scribing to, but it looks like that thing would be a bit bulky trying to fit something up to a highly textured rock fireplace.
I normally just use a thin strip of wood, with a hole or notch cut into it, with the pointy end rubbing the target surface, and the pencil pushing down in the hole or notch along the edge.
Like brian, I always sharpen any pencil with a double taper wedge. #2 pencils are too soft for woodworking, so look for 2.5 hardness, and buy a box when you find them. My laminate and cabinet hardware supplier always has a box with their contact info on it, sitting on their counter for their customers, so I grab a handful every time I'm in there.
I haven't had trouble with the pencil wearing too fast. I use General Tool's little pencil compass, see link below. Fits into just about any spot, cheap, precise.
A couple of the older one- and two-star ratings are moot, as the design has been corrected. If you don't like ordering from Amazon, Woodcraft also carries it, but at full retail.
To answer concerns of some other responders, FWIW, it has a built-in pencil sharpener.