We are doing a complete remodel of our kitchen. Our countertops will be a high quality laminate, with the exception of the island where a gas cooktop will be located. I plan to build the island top myself, using porcelain or ceramic tile that will stand up to the heat from a hot pan being placed on it.
My question deals with the substrate I should use. My thinking is to use a 1 1/2" thick layer of MDF as the basic substrate, then a 1/4" thick layer of cement board. All of this will be glued together with heavy duty construction adhesive, then covered with the layer of tile.
What do you think of my substrate plan? Would MDF suffice? Would another material be better? Am I messing up somewhere?
Industrial grade particleboard is a lot harder and stiffer than mdf, and you can get it 1 1/8" thick if you feel like you need more than 3/4" for longer spans.
Of course, harder comes at the expense of being heavier.
If the sink and dishwasher are to be in the island, you should be careful around them to seal the edges of whatever you use. I find the particle board and MDF damaged under the edge of countertops where they get wet repeatedly, either from drips at the sink or the steam form the dishwasher. I find the MDF they use at the edge for post formed tops swollen and bulging and in a few cases it has fallen out. Not sure, but several coats of some sort of sealer seem like a good idea. Or sue a more waterproof material.
Also, I have seen tops deformed over time by the weight of heavy appliances hanging on them. Don't put too much wight on them.
......joints. There is good reason that tiled counters were a fashion that came and left. You will find the joints difficult, if not annoying, to maintain. Presuming the stove will be used for cooking (not such a dumb statement in today's trophy kitchen environment) it will generate grease and grime which will accumulate in the joints. No matter the sealant the joints will be more porous than the tile. If tile is a must at least minimize the number and size of the joints.
Tile likes stiff under it. Personally, I would use 3/4" plywood and any of the tile underlayment boards, and of course a high temperature fired non-porous tile, or stone.
My understanding is that tile, and the grouted joints, do not have inherent structural stiffness - this must be provided by the underlayment. Although a tile countertop might not have to last as long as a tiled floor, I would err on the side of caution and make the underlayment as stiff as possible. A single sheet of particleboard and 1/4" backer board could be made stiffer. The comment about industrial particleboard was interesting, but not sure how commonly available this product would be in single sheets.
I like plywood too, but it must be screwed down well, as these days all but the best plywood will bow on you now and then. I usually screw it down from below, which is a pain in the neck (literally ), but does make demo a lot easier on the off chance that fashions change one day.
I tend to like the heavier cement board (1/2") unless there is a compelling reason to use 1/4". I also like the Hardibacker brand over Durarock. Precut the cement board to fit, mud it in with thinset and screw it down. They say to tape the joints so I always do, but I'm not convinced that it matters.
I did a counter once with 1/16" grout lines. Man were those a pain to try to level!
for an island with a cook top -go with granite. That isn't a big piece of stone. Granite fabricators will have left overs from big slabs that can be relatively inexpensive. Build the base and they do the rest.
Well yes but, if there is a long overhang, like lots of islands have, don't think just because it is stone, that it doesn't need good support. I don't recall the exact numbers for certain stones / thickness, but it usually won't be enough to get your knees under, without some brackets.
ANother good option, is to use the plastic lam, then inset a square of stone or tile beside the stove top.
Yes, I know that, and is the point I was making. But I wouldn't count on a 3/4" piece of plywood alone to carry 12" overhang, without some bracing under it.
I'm not saying you can't do it, but the hardness of stone comes at the price of brittleness. Stone isn't that strong on the tension side, then cutting a big hole out in the middle for a sink or stove top weakens both the plywood, as well as the stone.
Then, it's probably a good idea to warn the customer not to assume that the stone is indestructible. All it would take to crack a top, is for a moderate shock load out on the edge of the cantilever, like a kid dropping a big load of books.
My concept is to build the island open in the middle/underneath. Think a pedestal desk arrangement...21" wide drawer units on either end, with the countertop connecting them. 2" maximum overhang on any given side. The open area underneath is for trash bins and easy access to gas shutoff, electric hookups and downdraft pop-up Broan vent system. (An easily removable panel will hide all the hardware underneath.)
I can strengthen the cutout area by adding 3/4 x 3 framing underneath, on all 4 sides of the cutout. This would be hidden by a 6" front fascia board already.
For grouting, I plan to use an epoxy grout. A total pain to mess with, but almost stainproof. I used it on a 36'x10' porcelain over old concrete porch a few years back and it still looks brand new...almost impossible to damage. I would NOT want to do a 36x10 in this again, ever...really is hard to work with for an amateur, but a small countertop would not be so hard I think. Think "cake decorating squeeze bag" application.
Thanks for all the tips so far. I appreciate them, and look forward to anything else you can add.
Barry, I don't doubt you see lots of failures in your line of work. But I've never used anything but solid wood for the front edge, glued and nailed on. Since all the steam comes out the top front of the door, it shouldn't cause a problem back behind that.
As for the usual problems around the sink, that may be more of a problem of using a plumber that doesn't know or care enough to be bothered with sealing around the sink when they set it. Since Joe will likely be the one setting the sink, and doing the dishes, whenever his handler allows it. I'm betting there would never be any standing water left over any seams.
Since all the steam comes out the top front of the door, it shouldn't cause a problem back behind that.
We've just about completed updating our 17-year-old kitchen. To that end, we replaced several appliances with new ones. In shopping, reading reviews, and talking to our appliance guy, it seems today's dishwashers mostly vent on the side of the door instead of the front, like our old Kitchen Aid did. It's actually hard to find one that has a front vent anymore.
Knowing how this would affect the cabinetry, we opted for a German-made brand that has no vent at all. Actually, it has no heating element like those found in most dishwashers for drying. I learned a lot during my research into the appliances before purchase. I was surprised how things have changed since we last bought them.
I find the failures to be ....Disreputable.....???? I recently built a counter top out of 25" wide by 12' long particle board sold wholesale by a cabinet supplier for the purpose. I went to get it in my pickup and it had rained the night before. I did not wipe the water out of the bed and the end of the piece on the bottom swelled noticeably during the fifteen minute ride to the shop. Why would a reputable seller handle a materiel for counter tops that won't stand for a few drops of water for a few minutes? Why don't they just shoot me?
I bought some post formed tops from Lowe's a year ago and when the tenant moved out the front edges had swollen and bulged. I went back to Lowe's and they told me it was just what their supplier used. I suggested they DEMAND better material. The guy I talked to explained they had nothing to do with it and that if I shopped around I could have somebody custom build tops for me. I was a real DUHH! moment. I was trying to give feed back but it was a real failure in communication.
And, you are right about the wooden edge strip. In most cases it sufficient. If you want to improve it, put a "drip groove" in the bottom of it. Just a saw kerf about and 1/8" deep will cause any water to drip off rather than run back under the top.