I made a red oak conference table about a year ago and the owner called saying it was showing cracks. It is solid red oak, about 1 3/4" thick. Finished top and bottom. It originally had a poplar 2 1/2 band around it, same thickness, beveled under, bread board ends with the same. Ended up cutting off the ends and beveled the oak to match the sides. The ends were then stained and finished. Now it is cracking. Some along joints, but bigger cracks between.
Any thoughts on repairs and preventing it from getting worse?
Is it attached to the apron so that the top can move with seasonal moisture changes? Without benefit of a photo or knowledge of your skill level, if you glued pieces to the underside of the table across the grain, then the top cannot expand and contract as the seasons ( environmental moisture) change.
I'm guessing that may be the problem. The top was kiln dried, I don't think that is it. I supplied the top but did not attach it to the pedestals. I did loosen the screws holding it on when they called me back. I may have to widen the holes in the brackets for more movement.
Any suggestions on how to repair the cracks?
Any suggestions on how to add a picture here? I checked FAQs but I don't see the buttons they refer to.
When you hit reply, the message window opens and all you need to do is click on the Browse button to select your photo file. It must be 100 Kbytes or less in size and and jpeg file.
We'll need to know how big the table is, and if the wood is flat sawn or rift/ quartersawn. There are charts online that will show the amount of seasonal change. A flat sawn 4' red oak table may move as much as 3/8" across the grain from summer to winter. Did you have that much room for it to move? I'll need a picture to give advice to repair the cracks. Replacing the top may be the easiest. If you made the design mistake not allowing room for movement, it's up to you to make it right. A top with repaired cracks would not be my idea of a fix if I paid for it.
If you don't wish to shrink your image to the required limit, or don't know how, you also can use a link to the picture posted on a web page somewhere else. There are several free or low-cost websites for posting pictures. I use pbase. Then you don't have to limit size and you just put the URL into the optional image box.
I only supplied the top. It is about 4' wide by 11' long. It was attached to existing pedestals by someone else. I'm thinking they cinched the screws too tight to allow for much movement. The task now is to repair it without replacing it. This is the project that won't go away. I have already replaced the top once. I think they have a humidity issue in this room (too dry).
That almost looks like a kiln drying or board issue. Normally, a crack from being restrained, looks like one huge split. That crack moves back and forth across some growth rings, and is very narrow. Almost like an internal honeycomb, or it was cracked in the tree. Always hard to tell from here. Can you see other minor cracking around that on the end grain?
It looks to me like a crack that was already in the end of the lumber before it was assembled into the panel. These cracks can be difficult to detect. I usually find them during end trimming. If the end trim falls into two pieces the board needs to be trimmed some more.
Have a talk with the customer, see what he will accept for the repair. One way to fix those is to mix up a batch of tinted epoxy. Mask on the sides of the crack, pour the epoxy on the crack, then get on the other side of the board with a shop vac. The vac will pull the epoxy all the way through the crack in the board. When it starts coming through, mask it off and pour some more on top. Warming the resin in warm water will make it more viscous and pour easier. Keep an eye on it and add more resin as it settles through the crack. It's a crap shoot if he will like it or not, or if it will last more than one season. Yup, selling woodworking can turn your hair gray early. If you still have hair after pulling most of it out!
If I read your original post correctly, this 2nd tabletop originally was made with breadboard ends, and then you later cut them off? Did the breadboard ends allow for seasonal movement of the oak field?
Second, did you start with roughsawn or planed to thickness lumber, and what was your procedure from arrival of the boards to glueup?
How much oak have you used from this supplier in the past?
Can you describe the other cracks in this 2nd tabletop - are they similar in nature, are they in the same or different boards, only at one end or at both ends, only in the middle of the table or distributed all along the ends?
Finally, how does the situation with this 2nd tabletop compare with the first that you had to replace?
To me it looks exactly like a crack I had occur in a hickory dresser I made, where I had glued drawer support runners cross grain on a glued up panel. When the weather changed and the heat was turned on, the wood in the panel tried to shrink and couldn't so it cracked. I removed the offending cross piece, worked wood glue into the crack using dental floss and a shop vac to suck in the glue. Once I had a good amount of glue in the crack, I was able to clamp the crack closed, wipe off the excess glue and the crack literally disappeared and hasn't returned since in over 10 years.
I reattached the cross piece with screws in slotted holes so the wood can move seasonally.
Ripping along the crack will be difficult as it won't run straight down the length of the board and it not will it be straight in the vertical direction. If you check, the crack is probably angled relative to the top and bottom surface of the board and you won't want to remove a 1/4" or more material from the center of the top.
The original top was worn (conference table, veneered MDF ~2" thick, 4' x 11') A refinishing shop I often work with brought it to me. The customer wanted to remove the existing veneer and replace it with new oak veneer with 2" poplar veneer band around the edges. It looked good when it left the shop. After a several months, the veneer began to move and crack. Customer decided to replace it with solid wood. (top #2) Wanted the same look so I put a 2"wide beveled poplar band around the oak. Ends were made to allow movement. The finish started to crack along the joint line on the ends. Refinisher tried to fix it, with marginal results. It was decided to cut off the poplar ends to eliminate this problem. I also beveled the newly exposed oak to match the sides. Finisher stained and finished the new edges. A month or two later I got a call from the customer - cracks.
The lumber is from a trusted mill. It sat in my shop for a few weeks before I started assembling the table. 8/4 red oak planed to about 1 3/4". I was trying to avoid ripping and regluing, but maybe I will have to.
That if the check was out over a pedestal, it probably was due to the fasteners to the pedestals didn't allow the wood to move.
However, your last post says it is on the ends. Either way, the problem is due to loss of moisture content in the wood. According to Lignomat, maker of moisture meters for wood, the rate of MC loss can be 50 faster out of the end-grain than across the out the faces. This situation makes a good argument for sprung glue-lines.
However, you might save your ass, by checking the heat source at the location, to see if there is any humidity control in that space. This time of year, near the end of a really cold winter, when the heat has been running a lot, the really low humidity can take the wood lower than even KD took it. If they say their system has humidity control, have them check it to make sure it is working.
About 30 years ago, I made some gothic-arch church doors for a church near my shop. The architects gave me working drawings. I argued with them that their method was not a sound woodworking idea, that it would fail if the MC ever dropped. They countered that there was humidity control in this space. I made them take responsibility, and about two years later, they called to inform me, to which I had to say, I told you so.
When I went over to inspect. Inside the choir room behind these door, the walls had been painted with murals probably 80 years ago. You should have heard them gasp, when I pointed out how much of that old paint had been shed in chip the size of the last hand-full in the bottom of a Dorito bag. It looked like there had been a food-fight in there after all the dip was gone. Their humidifier had quit working, and nobody had noticed until the damage was done.
Moisture loss out a board end 10X faster is a common claim and assumption....for unfinished wood.
In data I have yet to post I measured the effect of finishing wood on moisture loss. A typical coating of finish on lumber greatly slows down moisture loss and especially so on ends so that typically finished ends don't loose moisture any faster than middles.
The reason moisture is lost out ends faster is that the tree's plumbing is exposed there. Fill the pipes with finish and that mode of transport is stopped.
The small additional force of a typical spring joint will be insignificant compared to the large force required to fracture wood under tension. This table edge was either constrained in a drying situation when the wood was in a high moisture state or this crack was in the end of the board when the table was glued up.
An 11' long table offers greater than normal opportunity for end shrinkage - I don't think the moisture content will remain constant over such a length.
With repeated problems, the suggestion made to spend some time at the location bears consideration before any more woodworking. Perhaps the ends of the table get intense sunlight, or receive moving air from HVAC system, or as mentioned the humidity level is out of whack.
Email your description and pictures to your lumber supplier to see if they have any thoughts.
While trying to repair the cracks is desirable, the barber pole look will be even more pronounced, and refinishing may be required.
If unavoidable, I'd consider making the next top veneered MDF to avoid the cracking potential, using plastic resin adhesive. The veneer should not move and split on clean MDF. But if solid wood has to be used, consider using quartered or rift oak lumber, which is more stable than flat sawn.
I suspect what your picture shows is end checking exacerbated by the drying process. Basically you didn't notice that the end check (or checks) extended further than you could see when you inspected the boards for this.
Sometimes as wood dries, and during the early stages of the drying process, surface checks open up along the board's length because of the stress caused by the drying shell trying to shrink whilst the wetter core is still 'fat'. Later, after the core has dried and shrunk in size, the surface checks will close up so that they're not visible. Later, in service they'll reveal themselves. Oaks are prone to this and the checks tend to follow a radial path along the 'weaker' medulla and show on the tangential face of planks. I'm not sure if this cause applies here, particularly as you mention some of the joints are opening up too.
As to a repair, some epoxy fed into the checks might work, but I think they'd still be visible without some careful disguising, and where the joints have opened might respond to the same thing, but I'm not really sure. Slainte.