Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Heating woodshop

Posts

Heating woodshop

#1

Heating woodshop

Lee Ohmart

My shop plans are coming along. Thanks for the input on lighting, it helped. Now I'm looking at heating. I'm fairly well sold on a Fujitsu 12RLS2 high efficiency split heat pump to provide the bulk of my heating needs. Several people in my area have installed them and are happy as clams. It will provide heat, air conditioning and keep the humidity level in my space controlled. For back up when temps get so low that the Fujitsu unit is inefficient, I was looking at a Rinnai EX22C gas heater. One contractor is trying to talk me into a sealed Modine HE-35 Hot Dawg heated citing issues with wood dust clogging the filter, finish fumes exploding the shop and lack of being able to direct the Rinnai output into the center of the room. I think he's blowing smoke. Your thoughts?

Re: Heating woodshop

#2

Re: Heating woodshop

Bradkansas

Lee,

I have a garage shop in Lawrence, Kansas exposed to the weather on all four sides where we have very gold spells and very hot spells. I mean below zero and over 100 for days on end.

My shop is about 20'X20' with a vaulted ceiling. The walls are 2X6 on 24" centers filled with 6" fiber glass batting. The ceiling is well insulated as well.

I asked my heating man to install electric heat and cooling systems. He snorted and told me to get a couple small space heaters and a window AC because it is so well insulated. I finished building the garage at the end of the summer.

I got two gell radiators from Wal-Mart as well as a 6000BTU window AC. That was fourteen years ago and I've never needed more than the radiators turned to medium and the AC is set for about 70. I mostly work in a T-shirt. When we could use 100 watt incandescent bulbs, that was enough to build a base of heat.

I've told lots of people about what I use for heating and cooling and how lucky I am that my heating guy put me on to a significantly less expensive system than I anticipated or needed. Quite a few have gone the same route. Depending on your structure, this might work for you and others who read this as well.

Re: Heating woodshop

#3

Re: Heating woodshop

Lee Ohmart

Thanks for the input. The building I'm planning has 6.5 in. R-30 SIPS panel walls and 10.25 in. R-43 SIPS panel roofing housing a 24x32 ft. shop attached on one side to the rear of my garage. The floor will be a 5 in. concrete slab separated from the ground and frost wall by 2 in. Blueboard foam. The SE and SW walls are set up with lots of glass so the sun will assist in heating by heating up the slab. Because of the SIPS panel design, I need to set up for heating, electrical and plumbing before the panels a built. I had given thought to a minimalist heating scheme like the one suggested to you by decided on the split heat pump as a necessary minimum. Originally I had thought of using a portable kerosene heater for those days the temps dropped below -5 F but was drawn to gas when our local natural gas supplier offered to install pipes up our street. I'm now wondering if that might be overkill as installation of this kind of heater can be done after the fact.

Re: Heating woodshop

#4

Re: Heating woodshop

Bruce, a MN Galoot

At work I have a website that provides really good information on a pro-level DIY solar panel that will take care of any heating problems you have. I'll send it to you tomorrow.

Re: Heating woodshop

#6

Re: Heating woodshop

Tom

I think there are a lot of factors. If it is a slab, it will suck all the cold into the shop. it is a good idea to bury the perimeter under foam board.

It depends a lot on the stuff you have. I used to be pretty comfy in my wood shop, until I started adding metal working tools. Now the place is never warm, and I can open it to the outdoors during the spring to warm it up, or I get rust everywhere. I finally found a solution for the spring, when I started pumping air out of the attic space, a source of free heat, and I circulate the shop air to the upstairs shop as cooling. But the overall point is you have rack of wood a wooden bench, hand tools and a badsaw, wooden walls, etc... It can be cosy. You have drywall, a slab, and heavy iron everywhere, it can be really cold.

Re: Heating woodshop

#7

Re: Heating woodshop

Bradkansas

Beware open flame in woodshop.

Re: Heating woodshop

#8

Re: Heating woodshop

Lee Ohmart

Could you elaborate? Other than the obvious ignition of oil based finishes, I don't see the risk. My Jet filter seems to do an outstanding job of clearing wood dust from the air. I rarely used anything other than BLO/Poly/Turp wiping finish and can easily swap from the gas heater to the electric heat pump when finishing.

Re: Heating woodshop

#9

Re: found it

Lee Ohmart

Cool link. Thanks. I'll have to give it a good study and see if I can figure out an application to my addition. This may be the first project.

Re: Heating woodshop

#10

Re: Heating woodshop

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Lee, I worked at a second job for over 25 years - contracting and sub-contracting a lot of heating / air conditioning jobs - residential, commercial and did a little Industrial HVAC at my first job as an Engineer.

When I built my shop, I did super insulate it. The shop is designed so that I have an upstairs room - don't know if you have one or not. In my case I installed a natural gas furnace with central air in the upstairs room. This allowed me to install trunk and pipes to the perimeter and install vents in the ceiling. I installed the return air in the ceiling near the center of the room. My furnace is a high efficiency unit with a sealed combustion chamber that draws outside air in for combustion and exhausts combustion products out - both through PVC pipe.

I do not know your location - a lot depends on your average temperatures as to whether a Heat pump is more efficient than a conventional High efficiency gas furnace. I have had my shop for about 9 years and am very satisfied with both the heat and air. In central Indiana it is a lot less cost to run a HE gas furnace than a Heat pump with electrical backup. (efficiency of air/air heat pumps are better above about 40F - but much worse at lower temperatures). I would not be very concerned with "dust" clogging a filter if the air filter is located near the ceiling. I have to change my shop filter less often than my house filter.

I also would not be overly concerned with spontaneous combustion in a normal workshop. You would have to do a lot of spray finishing in a closed shop to get near a dangerous level of solvent in the air - probably more than a normal person could stay in and work. The same applies to the quantity of wood dust in the shop. However there is a possibility of damage to the heat exchanger of any heating unit when it is exposed to some finish solvents. Some of the solvents, when exposed to flame, produce highly corrosive chemicals which can corrode and destroy the metal in the heat exchangers / burner assemblies etc. Therefore I would stay with equipment that has sealed combustion chambers (drawing the combustion air from the outside), or units like the Heat pump that does not have combustion products.

Re: Heating woodshop

#11

Re: Heating woodshop

Ronster

Check out this guy's shop floor with the 9/8 ply over foam & sleepers on a slab. I found this diary invaluable when I built my shop with the same floor and in-ground DC a couple of years ago. Instead of stain I rolled on oil-based floor poly heavily. I'm so happy with it and the insulation power has been impressive. My shop is spray foamed on outer walls and ceiling, so h/c is not demanding.

https://plus.google.com/photos/111054095273118925044/albums/5123529115774759329?banner=pwa