Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Veneer Substrate

Posts

Veneer Substrate

#1

Veneer Substrate

JP in 'rural' Festus, MO

Getting ready for my inaugural attempt at veneering for a Chippendale mirror. I've purchased a 1/4" sheet of birch plywood from the local big box for the substrate, but the more I think about it the more concerned I am with using it? Like all the sheets it is not perfectly flat. My concern is that after the veneer's been glued it will bow and tear the veneer. Is this a legitimate concern, or am I wringing my hands over nothing here? Would MDF be a better application here? If so, will I have to sand it to get a better bond, or just proceed as I had planned with the birch?

Thanks for your help,

John

Re: Veneer Substrate

#2

Re: Veneer Substrate

frank

You will need to veneer both sides to prevent warping.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#3

Re: Veneer Substrate

JP in 'rural' Festus, MO

That's the plan. I have some lesser walnut veneer for the backside

Thanks, Frank

Re: Veneer Substrate

#4

Re: Veneer Substrate

Tom

I would definitely us MDF. I really don't have much faith in ANY plywood from foreign sources.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#5

Re: Veneer Substrate

Jesse Cloud

I would go with the 1/4 MDF. Thin ply is very unstable, especially if it has only three plies (odd numbers are not good for stability). Also, any voids, even if "patched" may telegraph through the veneer.

Even with MDF, you will need to veneer both sides at the same time. No need to sand it.

How about some pictures? We love pictures!

Re: Veneer Substrate

#6

Re: Veneer Substrate

Tony - Memphis

I have had very good luck with MDF as a substrate. The only plywood I have veneered is some 3/4: baltic birch for a dresser (that worked very well too). I looked at the local HD birch plywood and was concerned that there are lots of voids on the edges. Not to start an argument, but I have applied veneer to one side of a substrate several times and never had a problem. Actually, I veneered one side of some 1/4 MDF with satinwood this weekend (no issues so far). But, for most projects, I prefer to have both sides finished as the MDF is not very attractive and I liek people to see wood even on the back or underneath. I made a hall tree many years ago with panels that I only veneered on one side with crotch mahogany and they are still flat as can be. Anyway, good luck with your project. I did some other pieces this weekend with waterfall bubinga on one side and satin wood on the other (yeah, I wanted the contrast). That bubinga is very chippy and hard to cut, but it sure is pretty.

Tony

Re: Veneer Substrate

#7

I'm for MDF

Howard in Toronto

Its face surfaces are "cleaner" with no imperfections.

You don't need to sand it - your glue will do the job just fine.

If you're veneering a board that'll require final trimming and using a bag, this might make your life a lot easier. After you assemble your project, lay a thicker MDF board (like 3/4") that extands past each edge by about 1/2" or so. This whole assembly lets you glue your veneer past the edge or final size and keeps your substrate flat.

FWIW - you don't HAVE to veneer the second side - you do HAVE to SEAL the second side - so you could, if your project will support it, lacquer the second side - works like a charm every time

Howard

Re: Veneer Substrate

#8

Re: Veneer Substrate

Jesse Cloud

Hmmm.... I don't want to start an argument either, but once I veneered only one side of a 1/4 piece of mdf and soon as I took it out of the bag it bowed like a hunchback. Never tried that again .;)

My understanding was that spreading glue all over one face gives you a piece thats wet on one side and dry on the other, so the wet side grows a bit and the dry side stays the same.

Then again, my shop is in the desert, with 2 or 3 per cent humidity - maybe the same thing wouldn't happen in a more humid place....

Re: Veneer Substrate

#9

Re: Veneer Substrate

Keith Newton

I'm wondering which one you have chosen, and which part. I wonder if you have ruled out using a solid wood substrate, and why? Is your face veneer running the long way? Why not resawing poplar for a substrate.

The thing about using plywood, is that you have no idea how good the glue line under face is. You could do an excellent job gluing your veneer, only to have any of the plywood glue lines fail. And of course, mdf isn't very structural, especially when it is down that thin.

If you are using a glue with any water in it, due to the thinness of veneer, by the time you saturate it with glue, it may swell before it makes contact, then is trying to contract forever after.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#10

Re: Veneer Substrate

don stephan

JP:

As you can see, differing opinions on necessity to veneer both sides. I always veneer both sides, even if the panel will be trapped in a frame. If using plywood, veneer grain ideally runs opposite that of the top layer of the plywood. If veneering both sides, veneer grain runs the same on both sides.

I haven't found significant if any voids in true baltic birch plywood from reputable source, but there may be footbal shaped patches on one or both faces. it's not likely the footballs could telegraph through your veneer.

I like to scuff sand surfaces with 150 grit, both baltic birch ply and MDF, before veneering, but again differing opinions.

Not sure how the veneered panel will be used, if it will be extensively scroll sawn with projecting pieces bb plywood probably less likely to snap off than MDF.

Both bb ply and MDF can take on a bow during storage. Veneering both sides with a rigid glue (plastic resin, epoxy) may be able to counteract the bow, maybe not.

You haven't said what type of glue or clamping system you will use.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#11

Re: Veneer Substrate

JP in 'rural' Festus

Pretty much decided to go with MDF in lieu of Baltic birch. From all your suggestions it seems to be somewhat more forgiving. I plan on attaching veneer on both sides and use several layers of thicker MDF as cauls and basically every clamp I own. I purchased a bottle of veneer tamer to condition the veneers along with a bottle of Titebond III. Other than the advice given here, YouTube has been my friend with regards to this. I watched a video awhile back that I am unable to locate again that gave me a pretty good run through. If I recall correctly the video was a woodcraft presentation in a couple of parts and the guy demonstrated building a checker/chess board. Presentation was very thorough and even addressed how to get kids involved in it.

Thanks for the advice. I'll be sure to let everyone know how it turns out. Hi-res pictures if it goes well and blurry ones if it doesn't ;)

Re: Veneer Substrate

#12

Funny...

Tony - Memphis

I do scuff the MDF with 150 to get rid of any surface dirt or blemishes.

The funny part... I went out to the shop last night and the 1/4" panel that I veneered on both sides is bowed and the panel I did on one side isn't- go figure! The single side veneer will be veneered later with a taped up design, that's why it is only veneered on one side now. I cut some sides last night and even taking a lot of effort to reduce chipout, I got some. Waterfall bubinga and satinwood are ot very friendly. Hope this whole thing works!

Tony

Re: Veneer Substrate

#13

Re: Veneer Substrate

Jp in 'rural' Festus, MO

So I've flattened the veneer (waterfall bubinga) for the fret work on the mirror, but I couldn't help notice how easily the flattening agent bled through to the other side of the veneer when it was sprayed on. Is this something that I ought to be concerned about when I glue the veneer? I'd hate to go through all this work and have the glue bleed through. Are there filling agents? As you can tell, this is my first foray into veneering.

Thanks,

John

Re: Veneer Substrate

#14

Re: Veneer Substrate

Jesse Cloud

The flattening agent is probably glycerin and water, and will soak through most anything. If you are worried about the glue bleeding through, try gluing up a scrap piece to see what will happen.

Two things you can do to minimize/work-around bleedthrough are:

1)Don't go overboard on the glue. All you need is a very thin coat, but it must cover the whole area. Make a few pencil marks on the substrate before you put the glue on. If you can't see your pencil marks clearly, you have too much glue.

2)Use dark setting glue for dark woods, and light glue for light woods. Titebond 3 would be good for Bubinga.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#15

glue bleed through

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am not highly experienced in veneering. What I learned about it though was in a professional shop that does lots of it. They use white glue and don't worry a bit about glue that sucks through the veneer in a vacuum bag. In my case lots of glue came through the crotch veneer. I sanded the surface, applied dye stain and didn't notice any effect from the glue. Same experience with later veneering projects. Apparently the glue is just in the pores, which are tiny.

I also learned that flattening is unnecessary unless the veneer is highly humped up. And inch is irrelevant. The water in the glue softens the veneer.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#16

Re: glue bleed through

Tom

The only problems with not flat veneer I have had when Vac Bagging was stuff like birdseyes. Very narrow points with some structure, can be on any piece of wood and sometimes the bag can't punch them down. I don't really know if a flattening agent would help, cauls help. At peak pressure you get 28 lbs. So devide that by say 130, for the area of a small eye, it isn't much pressure, on a small well structured spot.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#17

Peak pressure

Jesse Cloud

How much pressure you get on the bag depends on your altitude. At higher altitudes you will get less because there is less atmosphere pushing down.

For instance, I'm at 5,500 feet and we get about 21 lbs here. That's plenty for veneering.

Just saying this so you won't think you have a problem with your bag or pump if you don't get 28...

Re: Veneer Substrate

#18

Re: Veneer Substrate

don stephan

If it's difficult to flatten the veneer pushing down moderately on a caul, flatten first. Otherwise, the bag may cause a crack, a fold, joints to open, veneer to shift on the substrate, . . . none of which is good.

Lots of people use white/yellow glue, or even contact cement, and I've read a number of reports of bad results. I used yellow glue once, and will never use it again for veneer. Can't recall ever reading a similar bad report from plastic resin glue.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#19

Tom and Jess, you are talking " of Hg

Keith Newton

If you are pulling 28" of mercury, Hg, you are getting -14 psi. This doesn't sound like much, but multiplied times 144 square inches in a square foot, is 2016# per square foot, or just over a ton.

If I'm veneering a whole sheet of plywood, that 32 tons of perfectly even pressure is very handy to have available in a pump that lives under a bench, with a bit of hose, and plastic rolled up on a cardboard tube stored on a shelf.

If you don't have a platen on top, to spread the pressure out, even a small splinter or crumb of sawdust in the glue-line can cause a bump, that may be thicker than the veneer, causing you to sand through later to get it flat. As the pressure builds, any debris that can hold the veneer up acts like a tent pole, then any extra glue around it will migrate into that space, helping hold it up.

However, if you use a stiff enough platen to gain pressure from some of those surrounding inches, then you can get several hundred pounds of pressure concentrated on a chip of dust, enough to crush it.

Re: Veneer Substrate

#20

So many units

John in NM

Hard to keep them all straight.

Inches of Hg, mmHg, inches water, mmH20, bar, torr, atm, Pa...

And then us woodworkers want it in psi! :D :D :D

Re: Veneer Substrate

#21

Re: Veneer Substrate

Tony - Memphis

Ironically, I am working with some watefall bubinga right now! I have had pretty good luck with Unibond, but it is a little fussy and messy and requires wearing a respirator. I tried a product from Joe's that has a pecan shell filler that is supposed to minimize the bleed thorugh. I have been very pleased with it. I think it is basically an aplphatic resin mixed with the filler. I can't recall specifics, but you can read more at his site. I think Vacupress is selling a similar product. Nice to work with since it is water based. I did some experiments and, after it cures, it didn't seem to be bothered by water. I like that for several reasons - one being removal of veneer tape. I buckled veneer glued down with hide glue by getting too much water on it when removing the tape (and staining). One thing that Unibond is supposed to be better at is eliminating creep. I'm not sure, but I don't think that is an issue with this newer stuff I have been using. I do some inlay, seaming, etc., so creep is a concern. Also, crotch and other wild grain tends to move a bit and a rigid glue is supposed to be better at minimizing that as well.

Waterfall bubinga is beautiful stuff, but I have found it to be quite chippy.

Tony