Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

Posts

Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#1

Kick back video quite scary but good  *LINK*


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u7sRrC2Jpp4

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#2

Wow!, thanks....

Barry Irby

I always think "What would happen if the wood just evaporated?" As in Poof, gone. The Tablesaw, shaper, and jointer all give me pause. Somehow it did not occurred to me that your hand would be jerked INTO the blade.

We discuss the Line Of Fire on the lathe regularly. I have wondered why we don't advocate standing out of the line of fire on the TS. I generally stand behind the saw when ripping. That block would have seriously hurt me.

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#3

John, I ran across this about a month ago. *LINK*

Keith Newton

It seems that the purpose is to teach people to fear the TS, and hopefully not to follow this guy's example. However, there are some finer points that could be shared that could prevent some kickbacks which this fellow probably doesn't even know to share.

First, I hope he isn't training new users to stand to the right side of the fence as a safety solution. Don't stand straight in front of the blade either. Standing to the left is much better.

Second, think of the center of your effort pushing against the combined resistance against the stock. His scary video is going to make new users want to keep their hands as far away from the blade as possible. Without knowing better, this could lead to a kickback.

As you are feeding wood across the saw, there is drag under the wood against the table, and some against the fence, but most of the resistance generated while making the cut on a good saw will come from the blade. The center of your pressure should be just to the left, or blade side of the combined resistance, and it should be directed slightly toward the fence rather than straight back. and NEVER stop feeding until the wood is well clear of the back of the blade.

To help understand what I'm talking about above, here is a little example to try.

take a short scrap with two straight parallel sides, and set the fence so it passes through with a little pressure against the blade. Now, without turning the saw on, use only the eraser end of a pencil to push the block through, starting out well in front of the blade.

Just starting out, you will see that if the pressure is to the right of center, the front end of the wood starts steering left before it even gets to the blade, so you must either use the other hand to guide it back to the fence, or move the center of effort over to the left of center to send it through where it needs to go. If you used the left hand to start it, the tendency to rotate left still exist, and is there to get you as the wood reaches the back of the blade.

Added to this, is that most fences will have a little play on the back ends. Some people, especially the stout ones, will feed with more pressure toward the fence, causing it to flex. Of course, it is hard to maintain that same pressure as you are finishing the cut, so the springback pushes the wood toward the blade right when it least needs to go over.

Just so you won't think I'm making this up, I just set my unfence with a dial indicator locked down to the table, then used a spring scale to measure the movement. 3# moved .005", and 8# took it to .010". This may not seem like much, but that amount of pressure is probably within a normal user range, and if it were suddenly released, could send a small piece even more.

Notice above, I wrote NEVER in all caps. Whenever I offer advice on the forums, I normally avoid using the words always or never. Over my 40 years as a professional woodworker, you would be surprised how many other professionals I've given a talk to about leaving a board between the fence and blade, then reaching for the off switch.

OK, anybody need this soapbox, I'm through. But if you want another cringe-worthy example of how to use your TS, try this one.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDdb5euMVfw

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#4

Re: John, I ran across this about a month ago.

John Lucas

I have to admit. I used a setup not totally different than he used in the video when cutting sheets of plywood on my Shopsmith about 30 years ago. May be rickety and bad for the saw and blade but your hands never get near the blade. Of course I know better now and also have a bigger saw with outfeed table and the place to operate it. In the old days I had neither of the above so you do what you gotta do, you just try to be safe about it.

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#5

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good

BrianMonumentCO

Thanks for posting this scary but useful video.

Useful how? To remind us all to use splitters and really good push sticks.

I have personally witnessed two potentially dangerous situtations.

One happened when my father was visiting me after heart attack.

We were in my shop fixing a problem with closet, and a piece wood got kicked back.

Fortunately it hit my father on a muscle and not on his private parts.

The 2nd happened to me, I had a push stick selection failure. My pushstick was not sufficient and my finger tip slipped off the push stick over the end of the board and into the jointer knife.

A small amount of the end of middle finger left hand was cut off by the jointer.

I still have all my fingers a numb spot on the the end of that finger to remind me of how powerful our tools are.

A third situation I heard about and know the person it happened to.

He was not in my class so I didn't witness it.

It was a gunsmith school and involved a metal lathe.

The victim had failed to remove the chuck key, on a metal lathe these keys are much larger than a hand drill chuck key, from the 3 jawed chuck he was using.

He started the motor and the lathe rotated around and the key hit his finger and chopped it right off.

Chuck key against an angled part of the lathe bed made a cutting edge and he lost his finger.

The lathe class instructor hammered it into the class NEVER to leave the chuck key in the chuck.

He made a big deal out of it. For a damned good reason.

The guy in this video may appear to be an idiot for doing it but it helps to remind us all about the safety tools and just how dangerous our shop can be.

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#6

Honestly, I have mixed feelings about this vid....

John in NM

While I understand the motivation to make vids like this and put them up on youtube, I still have this nagging thought that this really illustrates the old adage that a little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

But on the plus side, I generally agree with his conclusion - use a splitter or other mechanism to control the piece after the cut. When this was posted on SMC recently, there was also a lot of discussion about the short fences that come on Eurosaws that sounded pretty reasonable. If I had a unifence rather than the older Rockwell fence on my saw I would try moving the fence rail back and see how it worked.

He doesn't mention in this vid that there is really no safer place to stand at a saw, but he does cover that in another vid. Nowhere has he advocated the "stand to the right" business, and in the other vid mentions that this would be a very awkward and dangerous position for a right handed user. In the kickback vid I gather he was way to the right because he knew what was coming.

I remember FWW doing a similar demo maybe 10-15 years ago, using a piece of styrofoam painted red. Much safer way to demonstrate the effect. Theirs was a series of photos of course, rather than a video.

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#7

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good

Tom

Another thing is to be balanced. If the piece exits rapidly and your weight is towards the blade, even only to the extent that you feel necessary to hold the workpiece down, you will end up riding the blade.

Saying that kickback is not related to width of piece but only whether you did or didn't use a splitter is not terribly helpful to people who don't have a spliter, and more than saying that table saw safety is 100% related to having a blade stop. There are many factors to kickback: too short; too wide; too thick; feed; blade; fence geometry; plunge cutting, etc...

The only time I almost lost a finger to kickback was with a router table. Router tables are super sneaky, unlike a saw that basically has the same dynamic, routers in tables have dozens of different ways to bite you. Which is just great, because I not only got hurt, but I felt stupid. What I did was i was routing in the middle of a stick, where the bit was to the left of the fence, not hidden in it. The idea was to reverse the piece and pass it through a second, time. The exact dimension of the groove was not terribly important, what counted was that it was centred. I rand the first piece through and then turned it around to make the second pass, which ought to have been cake, since there was little material left to remove. Instead the piece shot out of the router and I rested my hand on the end of the still turning bit. Ouch.

What had happened was that the fence had been positioned a little bit to the inside of where it should have been. That was the beauty of the set-up, it didn't mater about measurements, it would all even up with the second cut. But the bit I hadn't seen was that the second cut could come off from four positions, and one of those would be a climb cut with the piece shot out like a canon. Of course a cut like that with the bit buried, seems really safe for the hands, what could happen.

The average table saw is doing about 250 fps at the perimeter of the blade. That is about 25% faster than a heavy traditional longbow shoots an arrow. Such a bow, can kill an elephant with an arrow weighing about 2 ounces. The point being that a 1.3 ounce piece of wood, that left the saw at unreduced surface speed, would hit with the force of an arrow that has destroyed elephant. Of course those arrows have metal points on them. But then I once took a pencil sized splinter to the forearm, and it nuzzled right in.

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#8

Am I wrong?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Am I wrong to think "wow, what a fool"?

I can't imagine ever doing that to show people what happens.

That said, the TS scares me. I always stay out of the way of kickback. I always try to keep that in mind and what will happen if it does happen. I always use the splitter (when possible), push sticks, feather boards, whatever it takes to keep flesh away from that blade.

Actually, I try to avoid using the TS when I can and use the bandsaw or something else instead if I can.

Sheesh. That video just creeps me out...

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#9

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good

charlie belden

If you think about the forces involved, most, but probably not all, kickbacks - or flip 'n fly - can be prevented. I thought about that a LOT after setting up my first table saw (on an 1100 pound, 3, real 3 HP, combination machine (Robland X-31) - which came with a riving knife). I put together the stuff I learned on some web pages a) to remind me of what I could do to reduce the lifeklyhood of a "kickback" and b) make it available to other woodworkers. Were I to look for another table saw - it'd be a Left Tilt.

http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/KickBack/KickBack1.html

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#10

Re: Am I wrong?

Tom

Fool, hard to say. He obviously wasn't prepared for the fact that his hand would come that close to the blade, even though he had done it before.

Push sticks are great. If it can't be done with them, it probably shouldn't be done without. I remember one old hand saying that the only industrial woodworkers he knew that did not have missing fingers were the pattern makers, and they always used push sticks

I will use whatever tool works best under the circumstances. I won't push a table saw to do stuff that is silly. Bandsaw apparently cause more, serious axidents, per mile, though they aren't anywhere near as common. The reason is because people think they are safe, and they have pretty unlimited geometry. It is a bandsaw they use for sectioning meat, not a table saw.

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#11

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good

Tom

One other thing I think he is wrong about, and that I didn't already mention is that you can hold on to a piece and smother a kickback. I have done it many times. My dad had a saw with a 3/4 hp motor on it, and it was easy to overpower, then you are in a lock down with the saw, and then the breaker or fuse goes. This will not happen with a saw that has 3 belts and a powerful motor, it is going to win before you even know what is happening.

Re: Kick back video quite scary but good *LINK*

#12

Re: I use Grr-rippers

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I would not do any table saw work without my Grr-rippers, I have used them for several years, and also installed the add on Micro-jig splitter to my saw inserts. I have had kickbacks prior to the use of these, NONE since. I have had to replace parts of my set a few times (got in a hurry and didn't set them up right). I sure feel a whole lot safer using them - they also give me much better control of the board I am sawing so have truer cuts and less stock loss from wandering material on the saw.

(No connection of any kind with the company - just a real satisfied user)