Re: Old piano finishes
DLCinSTL
Your description of wanting to add "luster and shine" suggests that, generally the piano finishes aren't deeply scratched, but simply somewhat dull in appearance from very fine scratches. For lacquer, there is an array of automotive refinishing products available from companies such as 3M or Meguiar's that are for the specific purpose of restoring, i.e., polishing, painted finishes.
Depending on the degree of "dullness", one can begin with a course product, then work in steps to the very finest product. You may have to do some shopping to find an automotive store or auto-body supply store that carries a product for hand application, as these type products are generally used with buffers in a shop environment.
These products range from: rubbing compounds, generally for newly sprayed or very dull surfaces; polishing compounds, which are to be used after the rubbing compound is used or for lightly dulled surfaces; or swirl removers, which are used to polish out the last of the marks left by the polishing compounds.
For hand use they are all used similarly. Using a slightly damp, folded cotton cloth, apply the product sparingly to a small are, rubbing in circles. As the product begins to dry, apply lighter pressure, then buff clean with a soft cloth and move on. Don't expect to not see some dullness until you finish with the swirl remover, as all the previous compounds will leave some dullness. And don't let the cloth get too dirty or built-up with compound.
I would think that for what what you want to do, you can start with one of the finest polishing compounds and quickly move to the swirl remover.
And don't go overboard and rub through the finish, especially on the edges. Regretfully, it's like so many other things in life, it takes practice. But here is the good part. You can find yourself an older car with a worn finish and practice on it. That way, you can get a feel for how the different compounds work in relationship to each other. And the darker the finish the better. That's where a dull finish shows up the most.