Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Any advice on how to cut this joint?

Posts

Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#1

Any advice on how to cut this joint?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

For the little half round table I am making, I plan to use this joint for the front leg. Building this table I have been loosely following a couple FWW articles and a FWW book about half round tables.

This (dovetailed) bridle joint is shown in FWW #180. It's an article by Steve Latta about building a Federal Demilune Card Table. Below is a linked image I created by doing a couple screen grabs. It shows the joint.

I have read the article numerous times trying to get my head around it. It's a great article, and Mr. Latta does great work of course, but unfortunately, the article doesn't go into great detail on how this is done (neither the dovetailed bridle joint or how the apron is cut to match it). At least I don't get it. It just isn't clicking in my head.

He shows using a block cut at 11 degrees for the DT which I get, but I can't figure out where to start the DT, how deep to go with it, or the best way to cut the vertical part of it. I'll try some ideas I have in my head on scrap. Maybe I am trying to over-think it.

What I like about this joint/technique is that the outer face of the leg lays over the veneered apron a little bit.

Maybe I should cross-post this in the hand tools forum also...

Thanks in advance for any ideas/suggestions.


Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#2

Don't make it needlessly complicated

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I wish I had paid more attention to making this kind of table when Will Neptune covered it in his joinery class. Will knocked a leg joint out in minutes and it was for sure not this unnecessarily complicated joint. I think the leg was just notched and I think the apron had an accommodating dado to accept the leg. There was a trick for removing the waste from the apron that made it all easy. I'll review my notes from class and see if I can recreate what was done.

The problem with magazine articles is apparently they need to be "novel". The table is a common piece and in 1720 someone figured out the best way to do the joinery. The challenge is to find out how it was done then and for the next 200 years.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#3

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

Keith Newton

I can't see that the bevel makes it any better than if that were parallel to the side of the leg, which would be a lot easier to cut.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#4

PIC's from Will Neptune class

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



The apron was dadoed on front face to accept the leg and leave a bit of leg proud. Scribed, sawed, waste chiseled and thickness refined with router plane.



Second picture shows tenon layout for end of apron.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#5

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

Ralph Lipeles

I'm with you. It looks to me that a mortise and tennon will provide more glue area and therefore be a stronger joint.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#6

It is not how these tables are made

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For centuries the front leg of this kind of table was fastened on with a bridle joint, which is not hard to do. The surface of the leg is designed to show/project across the face of the apron.

draw out the mortise on a curved skirt and the problem will become apparent.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#7

Re: It is not how these tables are made

Keith Newton

I think Ralph missed what I was saying. I think what joe shows qualifies as a bridle, which is fine. I just don't see any advantage to the little dovetail slant thrown in there.

What he should realize, is that when doing laminated bends, you can't bend all the way to the end of the plys. He did leave some straight extending past the spring line, which was good. If I recall correctly, I think you need 8 times the thickness of the plys to before it actually bends. Then even if you have let it run long, then come back and cut across a laminated bend, some straightening out should be expected, especially if thicker laminates were used. I think he used 1/16" veneers, so in his case this won't be much.

However, the way that dovetail is designed here, if it is really tight, it becomes like a wedge trying to split down the glueliine of the laminated bend. And that 5/32" solid out in front, won't offer much in the way of support to prevent that.

Personally, I would like to see more leg projected out in front.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#8

Very good advice!

John in NM

I've also always seen these done as Bill described. Carefully made and glued, I doubt very much that it would ever fail.

Now if the dovetail is absolutely desired, I would make it bigger and put it at the back, not the front. Odds of cosmetic errors in all that fussy cutting are high, if it's inside the apron it won't matter.

There may be something to that novelty argument.... unfortunately, it's all theoretical to me, I haven't picked up a wood rag in 10 years or more.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#9

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" I just don't see any advantage to the little dovetail slant thrown in there."

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#10

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I guess the gist of what you guys are saying is to just use a regular bridle joint.

Adding the DT is not worth the hassle/effort.

I should be able to notch out the leg using the TS, then mark out the apron and cut/chop it out.

I'll just need to be careful to get a nice clean cut on the face (veneer) of the apron. I'll score it with a sharp knife.



Thank you.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#11

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

Jesse Cloud

Lots of good advice above.

I would add the suggestion to put a strip of blue tape on the face veneer where the joint will be cut. It may help to prevent any damage to the veneer, and it will also keep any torn bits under the tape. As long as you have those, you can simply glue them back on (clamp with blue tape) and you will never know the difference.

And if you do loose a veneer chip, just find some scrap veneer that matches color and figure. Cut off a piece a little bigger than the oops, put it over the oops and cut a patch thru the scrap and the remaining veneer below. Should get a perfect fit.

Cool project!

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#12

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

gary peterson

I just completed a half round table following Latta's instructions.(sorry no pics right now). I thought a bridle would be sufficient, but not having done any veneer work prior, i thought the overlap provided by the dt would provide some protection from the edge pulling up and also to hide any mistakes, chipping, etc that may occur. I found the procedure time comsuming, tedious, and in need of sharp chisels. However, when I slipped the dt through the slot the fit was snug without any play. Whatever the degree he used in the article, that wasn't enough, I needed to increase it a bit. The 5/16 leg frontage(can't think of the word) I narrowed to 3/16 and looks great. The client wished the legs to bow in and then down, not a usual cabriole look.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#13

A couple of options

hennebury




img

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#14

How I would fit it....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are clever at table saw fixtures so you may saw out the dado in the apron. I would likely hand plane a flat where it goes, clamp the leg to the flat, mark the leg size on the apron, and saw just inside the marks to establish its width.

The result would be a dado in the apron slightly smaller than the leg size. Then I would hand plane the leg to fit the dado. I might even strive for a very slight taper so that the leg would wedge into the dado. The hand plane will remove but a few thousandths of an inch of leg per pass. With patience a good fit will be achieved with little chance of screwing something up in the process. .

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#15

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

Tony - Memphis

The dovetail does look like a lot of work. I'll be interested to see what you do and hear how it works out. I guess my first thought would be to cut it real close to the scribe line, then finish it by hand. I might even chisel the edges at a very slight angle. That technique works in a lot of situations. Good luck and we'll be waiting to see how it goes.

Tony

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#16

Re: PIC's from Will Neptune class

Keith Newton

Bill, That tenon looks like it would be pretty weak with that much grain run-out. Was that an actual part, or just a sample?

Of course Joe will have a better grain direction with his laminated bend, and I think his ends closer to a diameter of a half circle, which should help too.

Re: Any advice on how to cut this joint?

#17

Re: A couple of options

Barry Irby

Wast I would do is cut a flat on both sided of the rail, leaving as much thickness as possible. (It seems to me that cutting away too much of the laminated rail might cause it to change shape/straighten.) On the front side I would cut the bridle joint so that the leg covers the flat and the back side had edges that bear against the shoulders on the rail. The shoulders would give bearing for the leg to resist left to right racking.

If you feel you must leave some "meat" on the front of the leg, I would cut the front rabbet in the rail deeper but about an 1/4" narrower than the leg. Then I would cut an 1/8" rabbet up each side of the joint on the leg. This little rabbet would rest on the surface of the rail and "capture" the face veneer.