Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

Posts

Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#1

Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Sams cabinet- sawing veneer

The goal was to saw veneer for drawer fronts from some walnut crotch wood. I have never sawed veneer before and encountered new problems doing so.





Pictures 1 and 2 show the arrangement I use for resawing. For example, in this case I am splitting 5/4 lumber to make 7/16” drawer sides. The saw is an old repainted 20 “ Delta. The large wheels are compatible with a thicker, and hence stiffer, blade. The large gullets on this blade don’t clog with sawdust when resawing wide boards. Clogged gullets lead to blade wander. Smaller wheels work a thick blade too much, fatigue it and then it breaks. I have never broken a blade on this saw. The large table on this saw, 20 x 24” also makes resawing , or any sawing, easier.

When I sawed veneer from a piece of crotch wood two problems were encountered. First, the blade shown does not quite leave a surface smooth enough to directly glue. Second, there was tension in the crotch wood and it moved each time I took a 1/16” slice from it. As a result I was using up about 3/16” of wood for each slice of veneer I obtained- 1/16” for veneer, 1/16” for kerf and 1/16” or more to smooth and re-flatten the remains. This approach was wasteful of the nice crotch wood.

PIC 3 and 4




A friend has a band saw fitted with a variable pitch carbide resaw blade. This blade leaves a surface that can be glued to the substrate without further smoothing.



I solved the instability problem by gluing all the crotch pieces together into one billet and backed it with some 8/4 oak as shown in Picture 5. The bottom edge was jointed square, then shellaced and waxed for easy sliding. We sawed 20 pieces of veneer from this billet with no re-flattening required during the process.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#2

Interesting

Joe Burke

I've never tried sawing my own veneer because it seemed like so much trouble. Not the sawing, but rather what had to happen after the sawing. It's safe to say I couldn't ever figure out what had to happen after the sawing in order to get a face ready for gluing to the substrate without losing a bunch of wood in the process. Having a friend with the required equipment is a good thing. Without the better saw is wasting a lot of wood the only option? How were you smoothing the veneer after sawing? If you were using a drum sander I'd assume you used a sled to hold the veneer. Did it ride the sled without being fastened down somehow? I'm full of questions.

I've used a bunch of sliced veneer in my time, but the stuff is thin for sure.

Life is full of trade offs.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#3

Re: Interesting

Barry Irby

I'm not Bill and I'm not an expert on sawing veneer, but I do have some experience.

I have sawed a few dozen pieces, ranging from about an 1/8" down to under a 1/16". I found blades that would leave a face smooth enough to glue up laminations. When using a blade that left the face to rough, I ran the pieces through a drum sander. I used a piece of MDF as a sled. Run it through the sander to "prove" the surface was parallel to the drum. On thin pieces I used double stick tape on the lead end to make sure it did not slip. I sanded pieces of birds eye maple down to 1/50" and used them to make a lamp shade. They were translucent.

With the blades that sawed a rough surface (3 tpi hook tooth 1/2" blades) I sanded the face of the blank after each pass. That gave me on smooth face on the next slice. So it was sand the face (or joint it on the jointer, take a slice, sand the face, take a slice until you ran out of blank. Then run them through the sander on the sled for the other face if you needed too.

I have a love/hate relationship with the bandsaw. Basically you need an excellent blade, probably new, and then tune the saw to death. Of course the next thing you want to do with the saw is cut a bunch of bowl blanks or circles, requiring a completely different blade and setup. Switching back and forth is a PITA. The answer is two bandsaws.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#4

Re: Interesting

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

As Barry points out, the proper blade for the bandsaw and a properly tuned bandsaw are critical to efficient use of your valuable veneer.

Beyond that, however, an antique toothing plane, hot hide glue and a veneer hammer are all that is needed to successfully glue the veneer to the substrate. I think I bought my toothing plane for about $35. I put togher a glue pot for about the same amount, from a potpourri hot pot, a candy/oil thermometer, a jelly jar and some scraps of plywood and other stuff I found in the shop. I made veneer hammers from scrap and a piece of brass bar stock. I've been told by someone I consider an authority, but haven't yet verified it myself, that you can hammer veneer liquid hide glue as well, obviating the need for the glue pot. Learning how to do it is a lot easier than learning how to super tune a bandsaw and a drum sander, and you don't have to worry about glue creep or glue squeeze out ruining your finish.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#5

On the irrelevance of glue squeeze out worries

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


This piece of crotch mahogany was glued in the Headley shop using their standard procedure of slathers of white glue and vacuum bag. Bunches of glue sucked through the standing on end grain of the crotch pattern. It offered no problem to the finishing schedule of Alf Sharp-sand, dye stain, oil, shellac.

On the other hand I witnessed Alf Sharp fail to stick veneer to a bow front drawer in a SAPFM demo and the person famous for veneer and Federal Furniture (name escapes me) failed to stick veneer from the flitch illustrated to a friends desk doors with hammer veneering. It was concluded the veneer was defective. Jeff Headley proved otherwise.

The number of people vacuum bag veneering vs hide glue hammerers speaks for itself on which is easier and more reliable. Glue and vacuum bag-trivial to learn. Hot hide and hammer- a significant learning curve and, as illustrated, even the pros occasionally fail at it.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#6

Re: Interesting

Phil Smith

"I have a love/hate relationship with the bandsaw. Basically you need an excellent blade, probably new, and then tune the saw to death. Of course the next thing you want to do with the saw is cut a bunch of bowl blanks or circles, requiring a completely different blade and setup. Switching back and forth is a PITA. The answer is two bandsaws."

Curious about what you mean by tuning the saw to death? Also what is so different in setups?

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#7

Two bandsaws

David Yoho

That's why I kept my old Delta 14-inch when I got the Mini Max 16. Once I mounted the 1-inch carbide Trimaster blade on the MM, I realized what a bother it was going to be to constantly switch different blades back and forth. So I kept the smaller Delta for curved and general cuts and leave the MM set up for slicing veneers,resawing, and cutting large stock.

I get cuts off the big saw smooth enough for laminating or veneering. In this case, it's all about the blade. It's not one for the budget restrained woodworker but it sure pays off in results.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#8

Re: Interesting

Barry Irby

I started with a fairly new Delta 14" bandsaw with a riser block. It was OK for bowl blanks and light general cutting. then I decided to try resawing and cutting veneer. Started to learn about blade drift or drift angle, got the table to be EXACTLY square to the blade and the fence Exactly parallel to the blade in a vertical sense. None of this mattered if you were cutting circle out of thin stock. Then learned about Barreling and blade tensioning. And getting the wheels to be co-planar. And then there were various blades, perhaps a variable pitch, vey thin blade 1/2" wide for resawing kept very sharp and a 3/8" 3 TPI hook toothed blade with deep gullets and a wide kerf for bowl blanks. Whatever. The blades for resawing and general use and bowl blanks are different. Changing back and forth takes about 30 minutes. Don't get me started on Carter ball bearing guides and various other "upgrades" along the way. The blade swapping process is somewhat fiddly and I don't enjoy it. My tablesaw, Pull one blade off, slap another on and you are good to go in five minutes or less, Bandsaw, not so much. Who thought those stupid little Allen screws on the Carter guides were a good idea? If I had the space in my shop and the money, I would have two bandsaws and one of them would be left set up for veneer and resawing.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#9

Re: On the irrelevance of glue squeeze out worries

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I doubt it was defective veneer. Of course, I wasn't there, so I'm speculating. It's much more likely it was defective hide glue: either too old, and it had spoiled, or had been overheated. If your glue pot gets it over 150°, it cooks it, and it loses all its strength. There is a simple test: put a drop between the tip of your thumb and the tip of your index finger, and pinch it several times. It should form a bunch of strings or fibers between your fingers when you pull them apart. If it doesn't, it's no good. If it doesn't have mold on it, feed it to your shop dog.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#10

to answer your questions.......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. Why slice your own? In my case I had figured boards that would yield as a good a pattern as I could buy already sliced. I like working with thicker veneer.

2. "I couldn't ever figure out what had to happen after the sawing in order to get a face ready for gluing? " If not book matching this step is trivial. Joint the face flat and smooth on jointer. Saw off a piece of veneer. Re-flatten and smooth face on jointer. Saw off another piece of vener. Etc. The smooth side gets glued. The "show" side with saw blade marks gets smoothed after gluing.

3. If book matching then some means of smoothing the alternate sawed faces needs to be employed. The face that gets glue does not have to be perfectly smooth. In fact it can be covered with shallow saw blade teeth marks. I have roughly hand sanded these faces with 60 or 80 grit sand paper stuck to a block (I use a piece of cloth belt) or drum sanded on a sled/backer board. Traditionally a toothing plane was used to smooth veneer.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#11

Re: Two bandsaws

Joe Burke

I've got an old Yates American 20" saw, and the kicker is ... it ain't even mine. A buddy of mine bought it because it was a steal, but he didn't have room for it. I guess I'm "storing" it for him ... for the last 20 years or so.

It's a good heavy saw, but tuning it is a joke. It needs new tires, which I've yet to spring for, and it's adjustments are very rudimentary. I guess the bottom line is that with a brand new blade (Timberwolf) and all the tuning and appropriate setup I can muster I can still only get good results. Not stellar. Nothing good enough to glue down off the blade anyway.

My desire to have two bandsaws comes from the fact that I tend to go to the bandsaw just to hack stuff apart at random. Pieces need to be reduced for the trash ... bandsaw. Long story short I can ruin a good blade in short order just making random cuts in normal day to day work. I'm sure dicing up melamine does wonders for a blade. I've been conditioning myself for a couple of years to stop this behavior and it's helped. I'd still love to have a cheap 14" with a blade I never had to care about so I could leave the big, primary saw alone.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#12

critical variables

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Of course the veneer was not defective. I used the rest of the flitch without any issues of it sticking with white glue and a vacuum bag.

I doubt that the glue was defective either. Surely Alf and Robert Millard would not be using defective glue.

The problem is that hammer veneering is highly sensitive to lots of other variables of the process. If one of these variables is not optimum, the veneer doesn't stick well.

Unless one enjoys overcoming obstacles on the path to making stuff, or striving for Period correctness, most project driven woodworkers will opt for a veneering process that has fewer critical variables than hammer veneering. Sticking a sheet of veneer to a surface with a vacuum bag can be learned with a 30 min lesson. And therein lies the shortcoming. Nobody will be impressed by success in vacuum bag veneering.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#13

Re: Interesting

Joe Burke

I think one of the things that puts me off about resawing in general, not just veneer, is the tension I always seem to find within whatever I'm resawing. I never thought veneer would be any different and might be worse..

I've used most of the techniques you described in one way or another over the years, and they'd certainly work for making veneer. The best part of working with veneer for me, however, was the grain match that could be produced. The more you have to machine to process each piece the farther and farther you get from a good looking book match. Of course, the book match isn't always the point.

I guess that leads me back to the tension issues. I work with kiln dried lumber bought from local suppliers. In my experience, when I resaw I just assume the boards are going to be bowed when I'm done. The only question is how much? Do they peel apart like Blue Angels breaking formation? Do the ends pinch together so hard that the board sort of explodes at the end as opposed to the blade finishing the cut? Case hardening I believe. One never knows. I just know that if I'm resawing it's usually for a desired match, and if I get two pieces that are straight enough off the saw that I don't have to machine the best part of the match away ... I'm happy and surprised.

Given all that I'm pretty sure I've assumed sawing my own veneer would be frustrating at best.

Hello Certainly Wood.

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#14

Sounds like you have made a good argument for.... *LINK*

Keith Newton

giving epoxy a try for veneering. It is the only glue i use for veneering for over 20 years. The rougher the texture, the better it should grip. However, I don't have any problems when it is smooth.

There is no water or volatiles to escape, so no built in expansion contraction built into the finished product.

Bleed through has never been a finishing problem, except when I left some on to long, making the full cure as hard to sand as formica.

I really don't understand why you or others want to put yourself through the hassles of making your own veneer. I can always find better figure offered through good veneer suppliers than I can from lumber suppliers. When you / I break it down to time / cost, there doesn't seem to be any savings by making my own.

I'm sure you have gone through some of the suppliers inventory, but there may be others following this that might not know, so here is a link


http://www.certainlywood.com/?gclid=CPTN9KH3ubACFSdeTAodxmZZNA

Re: Samantha's dresser 10- sawing veneer problems

#15

several incorrect assumptions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



Shown are veneered drawers of cherry chest of drawers

1. "I really don't understand why you or others want to put yourself through the hassles" . In the case shown it was trivial to slice the necessary veneer. The large drawer veneer was all sliced from a piece of 8/4 cherry with grain I found attractive for the application- joint, slice,joint, slice . No hassle involved. The veneer for the top small drawers was sliced from a piece of firewood I had been splitting. It had a stunning grain and it was a tree from the farm, meaningful to the recipient of the piece.

Furthermore, I did not want to cock bead these drawers. The thicker (3/32") veneer I sawed for this job enabled me to not need to protect the edges with cock beading.

2. "I can always find better figure offered through good veneer suppliers than I can from lumber suppliers." My results differ. But then I live where hardwood lumber is gown and sawed and I hang around sawmills.

3. "When you / I break it down to time / cost, there doesn't seem to be any savings by making my own." For me it is not about saving money. It is about using some figured wood I have collected or cut myself.