Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

Posts

OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#1

OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

don stephan

Our driveway, and that of the neighboring two family, meet along the property line with an existing 4' chain link fence on the line. Last week another resident in the two family dragged along the fence and bent over two 1 1/2" diameter upright posts until they broke off. There are often lots of visitors to the two family, and without the fence we fear having cars hang over into our driveway.

The posts are set in concrete and break off at grade when bent severely. Will filling these narrow posts with concrete when they are replaced make them significantly stiffer? Are there any drawbacks to filling with concrete? Thanks.

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#2

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

Barry Irby

I doubt filling them with concrete (grouting them) would have much effect. At least not significant enough to matter with a car impacting them. If anything I suspect they would tend to snap off rather than bending and then breaking. You could try 2" posts set in concrete and then install a 1/2" or 5/8" rebar and grout that with some sort of thin cement Grout. Might have to make it pretty soupy and tap or vibrate it to fill the posts. Still don't think it would be enough to protect you from

errant autos. How about some sort of curb?

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#3

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

concrete has little shear strength. I doubt filling them will provide any significant benefit. Any reason you can not replace with a 4" post?

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#4

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

John McGaw

Concrete will have no beneficial effect in such a small cross-section. If it was my property and I was really concerned about future damage then I'd be tempted to install posts of 2" DOM tubing, spaced more closely together. If repeat performances are to be expected then setting extra-deep sleeves to receive the 2" tubing (i.e. DOM tubing with 2"+ internal diameter) would allow for replacement of the posts in the future but a steel disk would be needed to be used to close off the bottom of the sleeve from the surrounding concrete. The effect shouldn't be too visually jarring but will have a definite controlling effect on low-speed vehicles (high-speed vehicles need not apply).

Even the least of these methods will be way more expensive than your typical fence posts so you might want to compromise and install standard 'end' posts which are at least a bit stouter than the usual mid-span posts.

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#5

bigger diameter or solid steel


Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: A old buddy of mine.......

Jesper, Denmark

Back in WV (the State) in the days of racing '57 Chevy's used to amuse himself and his buddies at New Year by taking out mailboxes with the stock car.

That is till one of the mail boxes was mounted on a 4" pipe, deep in the ground and filled with concrete.

Mail box 1, Chevy 0

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#7

Back on the farm.....

Barry Irby

We had to set up a folding sign that said Cattle Crossing, when we brought the herd up to milk them. There was young fellow that lived nearby that thought it was great fun to to open his car door and knock the sign down. It got more and more beat up. My dad got tired of it and put a bale of hay behind the sign. The guy just demolished the bale. Dad set our anvil behind the sign. It was mount on a short log/stump and weighed 175 pounds. Nearly killed him it slammed the door so hard. He got the police. Dad sort of innocently said "Oh!, Been looking for that anvil." Police told Dad to put the anvil away and the guy to leave the sign alone.

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#8

Had Several Of Those

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

But here the game is "baseball".

So one night Sluggo must have been "swinging for the fences" but missed the box and hit the 6x6 post that was planted in concrete. "Oh! Sports fans! We have a broken bat and nobody on."

Very next night Sluggo comes back in a F-250 and dead centers that post. Post snapped, and box went flying. But

2 feet of 6x6 went cleanly through his grill and radiator. Then

The concrete ball came out of the ground just far enough to take out his oil pan.

Cops found the truck about a mile down the road.

Sometimes belief in The Almighty gets reinforced . . . .

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#9

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

GolfSteve in Calgary

Why do you want to make the new posts stiffer? If you do make them stiffer then next time you'll just end up with a bent or crooked post that needs to be replaced, along with more damage to the vehicle.

Filling with concrete won't help prevent the type of damage you've described.

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#10

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Wanted to put the new box on a 5" steel post (filled) but the policia said "no dice" due to traffic a/o plow hazard :(

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#11

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

Gary Smyth

Was it an accident or intentional? Accidents are just that, accidents. If intentional I was imagining how the movies would devise a solution. Like the interstate highway signs, you could consider a two piece post. One metal piece (like a highway route or stop sign steel “u” channel) secure in the ground but with about 12” above the surface. To that piece sister a post the remainder of the height anchored using screws or bolts thin enough to break. If a car hits the post it snaps off, but leaves the lower portion to generate a major impediment to further travel of the offending item. Another alternative could be one used by the military. Weld up a metal “L” made of perforated “u” channel steel. Plant the base of the “L” in the ground. Should the post get hit in one direction the visible portion of the post “flops” and the buried portion might rotate up and might inflict problems. Of course I’m fantasizing. These thoughts are purely hypothetical. To follow through with these thoughts could be, potentially, destructive. I would not recommend this be done in real life

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#13

Good Fences Make Good Neighbors

don stephan

Thanks for very helpful comments and feedback. I may just plant the new posts in packed bank run gravel to make replacement easier.

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#14

Why are you responsible for fixing?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Why are you having to do anything? When someone runs off the road and through one of my farm fences they become responsible for fixing it. If I choose to, I fix it and bill them. Or they can hire someone else. BTW, It pays well, best when the errant driver is drunk.

That said, there is no post that is going to resist a car. After the offending fence destroyer pays a time or two to replace the damage I think the problem will fix itself.

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#15

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Back in the 1950's I lived in a small town, only had one or two stop signs. One of these was mounted on a standard "Tee" sign post in the middle of the road that met route 10, drivers normally went to the right of the sign while entering cars went on the left. Sign worked well for many years until we had a couple of nerdowell young lads that thought it was great fun to run over the sign. After the road crew had replaced it three or four times, they tired of his sport and instead of replacing the sign post, they dug the hole deeper and installed a section of railroad rail 3 or 4 foot into the ground and mounted the sign at the usual height.

Couple of days later the problem was solved as the boys drove into the sign at a pretty good clip, it did require the road crew to straighten the sign as the rail had tilted slightly. However the automobile in question left the scene pulled with a chain as the rail had demolished the entire front end of the car including the motor. There was a lot of laughter in the town, I'm sure the road crew also had a few chuckles.

Although I believe this was a great idea, in today suing society with ambulance chasers on every road, probably wouldn't work.

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#16

Re: Why are you responsible for fixing?

John in NM

I would imagine that tracking down the offending party and getting them to cough up would be more trouble than just building it stout. A rental with lots of traffic? Betcha their guests don't have two nickels to rub together.

I think I would go the route of welding some re-enforcing bits around the base.... kinda like a small one of these:


Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

#17

Re: OT - Stiffening Round Posts Along Driveway

Don Orr

After my mailbox was smashed on 3 consecutive days a few years back I mentioned to the State Trooper that I was going to replace it with a piece of railroad rail. He suggested it was not a good idea because I would then be liable for someone getting injured while DAMAGING MY PROPERTY! I ended up sinking a PT 6x6x8' post about 4' in the ground and building a nice mailbox support from it. Nicest one around if you ask me. :D

How about some nail strips in the grass next to the fence?