Would $900.00 be a fair price for this? Owner has put in new bearings, tires and replaced the fence recently. Looks like a solid old beast. He is fairly firm on the price, he says any lower and it would not cover the money he has put in it lately. Of course I would have to buy a new or good used single phase motor. The price in the ad is of course a typo.
These are wonderful machines, but they have near useless dust collection. They have a large table, something of great value in a band saw. It will last generations.
I paid $500 for mine and was delighted to get it. It needed tires and bearings which cost about $200 to do. It did not need a motor. The single phase 1.5 HP motor that come with them resaws up to the capacity of the saw effortlessly. I would prefer this saw to an equivalent new one which are more lightly constructed and in cases have puny tables.
If you needed to buy a saw in the next month, and presuming you could get a motor for $100 and the rebuild was properly done, what would you buy instead for $1000 or less?
As important as any other feature of a band saw is the size of the table. A large table makes using the saw so much more convenient. Are there any new saws that have a table as large as this 20" Delta?
I have an almost identical Rockwell/Delta version of this saw and it works quite well. I got lucky and got mine for free from a guy that just wanted it gone. The dust collection did need some help so I removed all the stock parts and rigged up a 4" port right below the table at the blade, pretty much gets 99% of the dust. It is a heavy saw for a steel frame design and there is no vibration while running. I would tend to think $900 is high for it though. You could get most of the way into a nice 14-16" Laguna for that much and have a newer design with a smaller footprint that is probably better for most things that this one.
I would offer him$300, then maybe work up $450. If the seller bought it new, then used it through the years, he has probably totally depreciated it, and it's actual cost was probably about $15 per year, so he is not loosing money by selling it cheaper.
He surely knows that $900 is higher than he would get at auction for a 3ø tool.
The amount your seller "put into" the machine is not a valid gauge of the price. If he made a bad investment, you're not obligated to pay for his mistakes. The saw in plug-in running condition has a reasonable value and price.
Do I get from your post that you'll have to swap out the motor? That indicates that it is not ready for prime time in your shop. Bearings and tires are not expensive parts, and absent some micro-doodad fence, it appears that your guy is looking to be paid for his time to put stuff into the machine so that he could use it, rather than for purely resale purposes.
I'd call a motor shop and see what a replacement 1.5 or 2 hp motor will cost with a trade-in of the existing unit (you'll need specs of the current motor and its mounting), then I'd deduct that cost from the price to be paid.
Don't see this going for much more than $550-600 if the 3p motor is in good shape.
Would you trade a well restored Delta 20" for a new 16" Laguna? I would not.
The key is whether the saw, with suitable motor, is in perfect working order. If it is I would prefer it to any new saw in a similar price range. Most importantly it will have a much larger table, valuable for anything done on a band saw. From here on it will not loose value.
That said, $900 is more than it would sell for here without a suitable motor. If it was shop ready and I needed a band saw in the next month I would buy it without hesitation.
The saw I bought needed bearings, tires, motor switch and some one had painted it an ugly color. It had no fence. It sold at a machinery auction for $500.
Thanks for all the input. Convinced me to go new. Probably Laguna. Getting different advice on MiniMax, too many people question the value for the money.
I have the MM-16, before I purchased it I looked at several machines. After talking to the reps and comparing it directly with the Lacuna at the WW show in Indianapolis about 8 years ago, it certainly looked like a better saw. I have not used it like a commercial shop would, but I am quite happy with the construction and performance.
The only minor feature I don't like is the stop/start switch. It does work fine but is awkward to use and guess others have had some problems with the switch - It has never really given me any problems - may be that I just like the 2 button Allen Bradley type. If I ever have to replace it, I will rewire for that style. All in all, I would buy the same saw again, don't think any saw on the market in the same price range compares.
When I purchased my saw Laguna had a lot of customer service problems evidenced by reports on the internet, while the MiniMax had very few. Don't know if they have rectified that issue yet, a little research on the net will tell the story. The customer rep from MM corresponded with me several times after I purchased my saw, seemed very interested to see if I had any problems (I didn't). I am a retired Manufacturing / Quality Engineer so am pretty anal about machine alignment - did take me a few hours to level the table to my satisfaction - most would have been satisfied with the unit as received!
I've probably had my MM16 about as long. At the time Laguna was having problems like Larry mentioned. Once the saw was delivered I went through everything during setup, installed a one-inch-wide Lenox Trimaster, and haven't looked back.
I actually like the on-off switch because it prevents accidentally turning it on.