One More Opinion
Joe Burke
I really think this is a space issue. I have a vertical storage rack, and I as I thought about it just now I realized my decision was based entirely upon space. I just don't have the space to store lumber flat and unstack it to pick pieces. On the other hand, I can store between 500-1000 bdft in my vertical rack and sort through it fairly easily. Life is full of trade offs.
I'm sure boards could be stored poorly and have them warp as a result. However, I've come to suspect that a board is gonna do what it's gonna do regardless. I may be way off with that assertion, but if you start off with dead flat, straight lumber it's more likely to stay that way regardless of how it's stored. Just as if you start out with lumber that's bowed, twisted and cupped it's likely to stay that way too. All of this provided nothing is being done that's way out in left field. I've never been able to take a board with a terrible bow, for instance, and straighten it out with weight or clamps over time. Of course, I could be wrong, and it'll be interesting to hear about it.
For most of the places storing a lot of lumber the forklift is king. Not all mind you, but most. Everything is stored flat and can be easily handled by one person. They have ample space and machinery so they act accordingly.
I have seen a couple of big suppliers who stored some of their stock vertically because it allowed customers to sort through on their own a bit more easily.
It's whatever will work for you and your space.