Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Finishing questions

Posts

Finishing questions

#1

Finishing questions

mdclor

How do you finish the part(s) of a project that won't be seen? Examples might be the underside of a table, the back of a bookcase or a chest of drawers, etc.

Do you follow your normal sanding schedule, an abbreviated sanding schedule, no sanding? Do you apply the same finish as you will use on the show areas of the project, a different finish (shellac?) or no finish?

I have seen many variations on commercially made furniture so I wondered where real woodworkers tend to fall on the continuum.

Re: Finishing questions

#2

Re: Finishing questions

don stephan

Commercial furniture would not be an example I would want to emulate, especially disposable furniture.

There are opinions both ways, but I apply at least one coat of the finish on all surfaces, more often two coats. So that the finish seals well I usually prep the hidden surfaces almost as well as the show surfaces.

Re: Finishing questions

#3

Re: Finishing questions

John in NM

Typically, I don't sand they insides and undersides of things. On table tops they usually get the same finish as the topside, though perhaps fewer coats.

Usually the insides of case work get a coat or two, but that's less of a big deal than the larger pieces like tops and panels.

Re: Finishing questions

#4

Re: Finishing questions

Dick Coers

There are a wide range of options, based on the piece of furniture. Bookcase, wouldn't touch the back of the back. Table, especially solid hardwood top, gets equal coats of finish all around, but wouldn't sand the understand to as fine of grit. Desk or free standing display cabinet, probably finished all around. I never use an oil based finish inside a piece. Smell stays too long, so I use coats of shellac inside to get the same feel as the outside. I like to finish drawers in a chest of drawers with a couple coats of shellac to give it a smooth feel.

Re: Finishing questions

#5

Re: Finishing questions

Jesse Cloud

If its something like a tabletop that will be held down mechanically, I usually don't finish it. At most a coat or two of finish so that it doesn't look raw. I read somewhere that Stickley didn't finish the underside of his tables and they held up pretty well.

One exception, if something may be sitting around in the shop for a while before getting joined to other pieces, I finish it. Learned the hard way that you don't want a cupped panel when assembly time comes....

Re: Finishing questions

#6

Re: Finishing questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I like shellac on the insides of things, drawers, etc. For the bottoms of chairs, shelves, they get finished (stained and varnish or whatever) but not to the same extent as the showing surfaces. I wouldn't do any of this but SWMBO pretty much put a stop to my unfinished ways. I argued "if Curt Buchanan leaves the bottoms of his chairs unfinished..." She argued "I don't care." Let's all guess who won.

I will not finish the guts of things that can't be seen without effort, though.

Re: Finishing questions

#7

depends

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I was making furniture to sell I would do more to refine unseen surfaces.

Do you follow your normal sanding schedule, an abbreviated sanding schedule, no sanding? ....none, but my large planer makes a nice surface right off the machine. I would not want knife marks or snipe on a back. I would not care under a table.

Do you apply the same finish as you will use on the show areas of the project, a different finish (shellac?) or no finish?......Inside I use shellac. Dries quick and I can use it indoors. On backs I use what ever is used on sides. I spray so it all gets done at once.

Eventually I will be posting data that shows that finish greatly retards the response of the lumber to changes in humidity. I concluded that it is a good idea to coat every surface with finish.

Re: Finishing questions

#8

Re: Finishing questions

don stephan

Personally I want to try to avoid incorporating stress in a piece - I don't think it ever leads to good things. Almost everyone agrees that finish slows the rate of moisture movement into and out of wood, which suggests that only finishing one side will lead to imbalance in moisture content of the opposing surfaces, one cause of warping.

Re: Finishing questions

#9

Re: Finishing questions

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

On a table, I normally rough cut to length, leaving extra length for grain match etc. I then finish plane the edges and sand or scrape to about 100 ~ 150. This lets me determine the best looking surfaces. Then I pick the best "show side" and grain match and glue up oversize. After cutting to size I sand the finish face to 220 and finish assembly. I always finish the underside of everything using the same finish as the show face. I do finish drawers with shellac (everything but the face). My planer does leave a great finish, (20" stationary with Byrd head) so may be times I don't sand underside if a "defect" makes it apparent that it won't be a show face!

Re: Finishing questions

#10

Re: Finishing questions

mdclor

Thanks for all the replies. I guess I have been overdoing things all these years. Heretofore, I have treated all surfaces the same, but based on these responses, I will stop sanding the non-show areas at 100G and only spray with 2 coats of finish. Finishing just got much less tedious! :)

Re: Finishing questions

#11

Re: Finishing questions

Howard Acheson

Here is something that might help. It;s the way we handled the issue:

How much you sand depends upon if you’re a professional or a hobbyist. If the former, it depends upon how far over your time estimate you are. ;-)

All kidding aside: people don’t just perceive furniture by looking at it. They also feel the surfaces. So those surfaces that people might touch (even if they never see them) I sand and finish to the same degree as sited surfaces - if someone touches the surface, they feel that same thing they feel on a public surface. However those surfaces that will never be seen or touched I leave--or I might sand them just to get the construction marks (pencil, lumber crayon, glue, veneer tape) out. For example the bottom of a table I sand to 80-grit because someone might turn the table over while they’re moving it and I don't want them to see a mess. But I don’t ever sand the corner blocks. The back of the apron I sand to the same degree as the public surfaces because someone might put their hand under there. But I don’t finish the surface to the same degree. I put a couple of coats of finish on that surface to seal them--then sand to get the raised grain off. I don’t put a final topcoat on those surfaces. They feel the same as the public surfaces, but they don’t have to look the same. The inside of cabinets with drawers, I take off the veneer tape but otherwise leave - just seal with a couple of coats of finish. I don't know why I even take off the veneer tape - those surfaces are completely private.

Re: Finishing questions

#12

Re: Finishing questions

Jesse Cloud

Just out of curiosity, I took a look at the few pieces of store-bought (Mastercraft, Lane, Thomasville) high end furniture we have. None of them had finishes on normally unseen areas.

Re: Finishing questions

#13

Leaving evidence of the maker

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Disclaimer, in my case I am making stuff for a daughter, granddaughter, etc.

I will purposely leave construction makes on normally hidden surfaces. I think it will be meaningful for a grown up granddaughter to discover some day a drawer number or orientation triangle, for example, penciled on the back of a drawer.

When I discover these marks on family antiques, some of which date 150 years ago, I feel a connection with the maker I otherwise would not have.

In some out of the way place I will put a note telling where the lumber was harvested from and by whom, finishing notes, construction date, etc. , anything that might be of interest a 150 years hence. I write it on the wood in archival ink and overcoat with shellac.

Re: Finishing questions

#14

Me too...

Barry Irby

I sign the inside of my pieces. If its for a family member I include the relationship between us and the info where the wood came from as well as the date and or occasion.

Sometimes I build in secret compartments and may put photos or mementos in there.

Re: Finishing questions

#15

Inside and out

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I finish inside and out all with the same finish. and the same number of coats. However, I don't sand the non-visible surfaces as much and don't worry if I happen to get a run or two or if I missed a spot of glue squeeze out somewhere it doesn't show.

Lee