Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Finishing repair - mid project!

Posts

Finishing repair - mid project!

#1

Finishing repair - mid project!

matthew

Hi there! I have a slab of pecan (about 6' long and 18" wide) that has sap and heart wood as well as some crotch. My pan (which I did) was to sand with an orbital sander (60 through 320 grit),and the apply a number of coats of Liberon Finishing Oil. After coat number two ...... I can see the RO scratches in three small areas of the slab - visible enough to bother me and want to fix it. In fact I have two of these slabs which are bookmarked. The intent is to hang them on the wall side by side - like a piece of "art!" :)

The problem is that one of these areas is right at eye level and travels between the lighter heartwood grain to the darker crotch. No, it does not "slap you in the face" ..... but it certainly is there.

I wonder if you would be kind enough to suggest a fix? The areas are about 3" x 2".

I must need a new pair of glasses!

Thanks,

Ollie.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

After the oil cures - about a month - start with 220, and hand sand the slabs, then go to 320, hand sand again, and reapply the oil.

That should do it.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#3

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

Howard Acheson

The only repair that will look good is to remove the finish and then re-sand the affected area.

You've run into a common problem when using a ROS. They frequently do not allow surfaces to be properly sanded. In most cases machine sanding with a grit higher than 180 can lead to problems. Above 180 it's best to sand by hand unless you have a straight-line sander. Sand by hand sanding in the direction of the grain.

Finally, wet a rag with mineral spirits and wipe it over your sanded surface. This will not only preview the color that the item will take if finished with a clear finish, it will also highlight any areas with sanding miscues or misses.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#4

scrape

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

if you have not yet learned to sharpen and use a scraper this is a good opportunity. scrape and reoil. If the reoiling doesn't blend then scrape the whole thing.

It makes not sense to sand beyond something in the range of 180 to 220 if you intend to oil or varnish.

ROS is an evil tool. You will find it tedious to remove coarse scratches made by one.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#5

Evil?

Dave Bair

It's not an evil tool, just misunderstood and misused. People like to bear down on the machine, like they see the folks doing on the home improvement shows. Or tip it on edge like it's a grinder/buffer. And they don't thoroughly clean the wood surface when they change grits. Let the weight of the sander hold it on the work, just guide it. And vacuum (even if you've attached a vac to the sander) the wood between grits to avoid carrying a piece of that 100 grit material right through to your final pass with 320. I don't get pig tails if I follow my own advice.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#6

Satan

matthew

Had a chat with Lucifer, he advised that this exercise was a result of operator error. I was using a Festool Rotex 125 with Fein vacuum attacked and vacuumed between grits. I simply must have overlooked a couple of areas - and I thought I was being careful!

Have just had my first scrape - things look good.

Thank you for the help and advice./

Ollie.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#7

Re: Satan

Barry Irby

I call the first coat of finish the REVEAL coat. It reveals the flaws. Maybe the mineral spirits idea is a good one.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#8

Re: Evil?

Tom

In boat building I don't have any choice about sanding, though I try to never sand glass. ROS is a good tool. Another cause of bad scratches is to let it wind down on the surface of the wood. But normally just keeping it in fresh paper is all it takes. Be prepared to go through a lot of paper. On the one hand some projects are small on the other, most of the sanding is done on a small donut of paper, and you have to toss the paper, at the first sign of reduced productivity for the grit. The pneumo ROSs will power on through heavy pressure, so you can actually use a heavy hand, but slowing down a small electric tool doesn't make much sense.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#9

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

matthew

Well, ended sanding the whole slab to 180 grit and now it looks good. The question is there to go from here! Would you think that wet sanding woukld be feasible? My concern is that that sanding the various woods (sap, heart, crotch) will produce a different color sawdust which could discolor an adjacent piece. SEcondly, the slab has a number of voids so I would have to remove any slurry that made its way into the cracks and knotholes. I really like the look of Liberon Finishing Oul and wonder whether whether this approach would be appropriate?

Thank you once again,

Matthew.

Re: Finishing repair - mid project!

#10

Wet sanding?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know what "wt sanding" is, but I am sure I never did it for any of the acres of walnut I have finished.

Keep in mind that the oil is going to yellow with age and the dark color of the walnut is going to change too. The result will be that the sap wood will yellow and the dark areas will stay darker(but change shade) than if you used lacquer, for example.