Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Trestle Table question

Posts

Trestle Table question

#1

Trestle Table question

Tom

I am considering Shaker style trestle dining room table. The plan/idea is from Fine Woodworking, Christian Beckvort' article. Here is a link http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/shaker-dining-plan.aspx

But my question/concern is I am wonder if it will rack?

Anyone had experience with this type of table?

Thanks!

Re: Trestle Table question

#2

JL

Re: Trestle Table question

JL

No, it shouldn't rack - if you are referring to the undercarriage.

That's why shoulders are good things.

Re: Trestle Table question

#3

Re: Trestle Table question

John in NM

I built a few at a shop I used to work for. They are sturdy when the stretcher has enough shoulder, sturdier than the average table I would say.

The downside to a trestle table is the amount of wood required and the way users tend to bang feet and knees on all those sturdy parts underneath. Then again, the annoying way in which I keep kicking the legs of our regular dining table leads me to believe that may be less of a problem specific to trestles :D

Re: Trestle Table question

#4

Re: Trestle Table question

don stephan

Having read a number of articles and one book by Chris Becksvoort, I would not have any hesitation to build one of his designs.

Re: Trestle Table question

#5

Re: Trestle Table question

Tom

Funny you should say that! As that same thought came to me this morning. That anything he would build would be substantial.

Thanks!

Re: Trestle Table question

#6

Ellis Walentine

Re: Trestle Table question

Ellis Walentine

JL, I didn't see a view of the stretcher on that table, did you? To me the table looks pretty delicate. Tall shoulders cooupled with the bedbolts in the description would make it quite sturdy, but I couldn't say from the one tiny photo in the Highland ad.

But then I tend to overbuild things.

Ellis

Re: Trestle Table question

#7

Re: Trestle Table question

Tom


It doesn't look all that strong. My trestle table is more elegant, and it is virtually strong enough to be a bench. This one has the high tie beam which is weaker than a mid one, and the arched foot, which is also weak. But on the positive, there is nothing to knock your shins on, or to block your feet. So assuming all the parts are well sized this one could be more comfortable, and strong enough. Aesthetically any time you just saw out curves and slap them into turned pieces, it looks cheap (code for "country"). And this one passes on the beauty opportunity presented by a spectacular beam, and an interesting and more practical wedge assembly, that is also more woody. But it is a nice looking table non the less, so it depends what look you are after. Apparently he gets 4500 for them. And I would certainly trust any of his designs.

Re: Trestle Table question

#8

Re: Trestle Table question

Tom

http://d2amilv9vi9flo.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/American_Trestle_Table1.pdf

Re: Trestle Table question

#9

Re: Trestle Table question

Tom

And pic of the plan table.