Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

The Projectionist Syndrome

Posts

The Projectionist Syndrome

#1

The Projectionist Syndrome

charlie belden

Back in my often misspent youth, I was a movie projectionist. And part of that job was knowing when to start Projector 2 running when the reel on Projector 1 was coming to an end. For a short period of time, both projectors would be running, their projected images synchronized.

Just before the currently running reel ended, there'd be a white square in the upper right corner of about a half second and several seconds later another white square. When the projectionist saw the first white square he or she would get ready to start Projector 2 running. When the second white square appeared, Projector 2 was started and two sets of images where being projected. The film would appear to be running continuosly so the audience wouldn't notice that reel one had ended and reel two was now running.

Unless someone in the audience was, or had been a projectionist, no one would notice the change over.

As a former movie projectionist, it was hard for me to just watch a movie in a theater. About the time I knew there would be a reel change, I'd start watching for the White Square - and miss what was going on near that switch over time.

Now I imagine the same type of thing happens to folks who direct, shoot or edit movies. We watch movies differenlty from the general population and thus experience them differently.

I burdened you with all that to get to this question

Can you, as a wood worker, see a piece done in wood - without looking for the White Square?

Put another way - can you see the forest or do you have to focus on just one tree and miss seeing the forest?

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#2

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

There's a juried show, sponsored by the county WW guild, every year, held in the county museum. I will confess that I can't look at a piece without noticing the details; but I do try to step back and admire the piece whole, too. Although some decisions by the maker will drive me nuts, and it then becomes hard to see it for what s/he intended it to be.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#3

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As a maker of furniture I am drawn to the technical details of what I see in shops and museums. I about got run out of the Smithsonian standing on my head looking at the the framing of a table I liked. In an antique shop I always ask if I may examine drawers. I like studying drawer construction and fitting. In a shop with studio furniture I cast a critical eye at hinges and drawers. If these often young woodworkers can't fit a hinge it does detract from my appreciation of their design (but I usually don't like their design anyway. I am not a fan of art projects posing as furniture).

Does that hamper me from admiring the overall piece? I think not.

Daughter suffered the same white square malady before digital projection took over. I never saw it.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#4

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

mdclor

A few years ago I was fortunate to see a Stickley exhibit in San Diego. It was comprised of about 70 pieces many of which were on loan from private collections. It was all spectacular but the highlight was a complete dining room ensemble. I was in awe. The individual pieces were fantastic and the impact created by the grouping was beyond my ability to describe.

I did not look for any "white squares". :)

In normal circumstances I like to look at the entire piece first, then drill down to the mechanics/execution.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#5

if all of the ducks aren't in a row

Mark Hennebury

its not much of a f***ing row now is it.

Of course, we look for details, the aggregate of which make up the piece.

Any detail slightly misplaced, omitted , badly executed, or overlooked reduces the rest, however well done, to trash.

We spend our lives fussing with minute details, so that others will not notice them and enjoy the piece as a whole.

This reminds me of a man that took one of my woodworking courses many years ago;

Part way through the course he approached me and said that he had recently purchased a housefull of expensive furniture, "high end" stuff from an exclusive store. He was quite proud of it and asked me to examine photos of it and explain how handmade furniture would differ.

I said that in the first place his door panels were made from 2" wide random rips rather than bookmatched panels and that they had been stained and tinted to obscure the grain so that he wouldn't notice... when i looked up at him i realized that he was in shock, and for the first time actually was seeing what he was looking at.

He was somewhat devastated by the critique of his furniture, and from this point on saw many things that he had not seen before.

I think that he felt like he had been blind and could now see.

He said that he could never look at his or any other furniture in the same way.

Amazing is difference, in what we look at vs.what we see.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#6

Re: This one made me chuckle

Dale Stansbery

In ancient times, one of the jobs I had to help pay for college was as a projectionist at the YMCA in Columbus Oh. We only had one projector, and if it were a two reel movie, the audience just had to wait for the change over.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#7

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

Gary Smyth

I admit I walk into a space and see the overall view. Sometimes that is quite enough, but many times there is a piece that stands out. That is where I head and that is where my interest and concentration stays. Not a good thing. More often than not I get stymied. It drives me nuts that in historic homes, museums, some gallery’s, and auction houses they don’t allow you to inspect (which for many pieces I understand), but also refuse to open a drawer or door, or permit anyone to get within fifteen feet of a piece while behind some rope or fence. It does me absolutely no good to view a unique piece if I can’t look at it closely. For example, I’m a fan of Shaker, Tansu, Campaign furniture. All of these styles have fakes and knock offs. To look at any of these from across a space is of no value to me. Without construction details, my time is better spent with a good book or video on the subject.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#8

Amen to that......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....which is why I like antique shops. I have always been able to examine a piece if I ask first.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#9

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Charlie, I find your comparison enlightening. I think you are quite correct in your assumption that once you are "educated" in any field you look at the objects far differently than folks that are not aware of the issues of design, joinery, fit and finish and other characteristics.

As was stated in an earlier post - most consumers of "high end" furniture are not aware of manufacturing "shortcuts" such as using stains to obliterate different grains (or in many cases use stains to mimic more expensive woods). Nor do they recognize inferior joinery or other construction.

I am sure expert automobile painters /body men would find flaws in finish and workmanship in an auto repair that I could not detect - nor even look for. I watch "Chasing Classic Cars, and am a little surprised at the issues that are exposed when experts inspect a totally restored automobiles.

Most of the woodworkers here can recognize many things that the average person would not look for nor care about - like hand cut dovetails, drawer construction, finishes, grain matching, etc.. I guess it does in some ways reduce our appreciation of "decent" furniture, but increases our delight when finding furniture that meets our increased standards.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#10

Clint Searl

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

Clint Searl

I think every experienced woodworker looks for the white square on seeing someone else's work. The only difference is whether the white square is design based or workmanship based. For me, design is the first thing that commands my attention. If the design is unappealing or of a style that I don't like, it doesn't matter how finely wrought the dovetails are or piston-like the drawers fit, the piece doesn't get a second glance. If I do like the design, then I'll examine the workmanship to establish the work's rank among the rest. But it's always design first.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#11

knowing how it's built and some theatre trivia

GolfSteve in Calgary

Knowing how high end furniture is build is why my house is full of Ikea and La-Z-Boy furniture. I can't or won't pay $5000 for a high-end dresser that is one or two steps above mass produced junk.

At least when I go to Ikea I know it's just above junk but it's honest and pretty good value.

BTW, Charlie, my grandfather was a projectionist in a small town theater for almost 60 years! When it was close to change-over, you would strike an arc in the second projector and get it ready to go. When you saw the first dot in the corner of the picture, you would get the second projector spinning, and when you saw the second dot, you would flip a lever that dropped a metal shutter in front of the running projector while simultaneously raising a shutter on the first projector (the shutters were connected with a chain). The second projector would then be in service.

Each reel was about 20 minutes long, so a movie was usually on 5 or 6 reels (shipped from small town to small town on Greyhound bus). Between change-overs he would load a new reel into the projector and rewind the previous reel.

The projection room was lead-lined and there were fire shutters over the projection apertures due to the extreme fire hazard of the old cellulose films. When Grandpa started you had to have a licence to run a projection booth, and he had to spend a couple of months in school getting it.

He also built his own sound system and I remember having to fire up big vacuum tube rectifiers that supplied DC power to the amplifiers.

Grandpa's theater was the last in Canada to use carbon-arc projectors. During his last 10 years running the projection room, they upgraded to a Xenon-arc lamps and also switched from a two projector system to a platter system using a single projector. I heard that they recently upgraded to a full digital projection system, pretty good for a town of 800 people!

Towards the end, Grandpa's friends were old and deaf so he set-aside a couple of seats directly under the projection booth where he would dangle a set of earphones down to them and crank up the volume.

After Grandpa died I would always look for the change-over dots and think of him during the movie. Sadly I haven't noticed a change-over dot for a long time so I think they may be dead as-well.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#12

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

Keith Weber

I misread the title as The Perfectionist Syndrome. I definitely have that! Don't know about The Projectionist Syndrome, though.

Re: The Projectionist Syndrome

#13

Interesting Posit Charlie!

Don Orr

I too was a projectionist in college and know the white dot as well. I try to look at furniture at a distance 1st before looking for details. I also try to look from a distance AFTER looking at the details to see if they work for me. I am no expert by any means but I enjoy looking closely as well as from afar.

My museum story is from when my wife and I went to Washuington DC and visited the Renwick Gallery to see the Greene & Greene exhibit. I asked the guard about taking photos and was told I could not. He watched me very closely as I got down on my hands and knees to look under the furniture for construction details. Somewhat surprisingly, the undersides were not as well finished as the "show" faces. Relates to the above post about finishing unseen surfaces. I did manage to set off a couple of proximity alarms when I got a little too close to some pieces. They didn't throw me out so I must not have been too bad.