Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

Posts

Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#1

Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Coming soon in Popular Woodworking will be an article by two frequent WoodCentralians, Kees Van Der Heiden and Wilbur Pan, on how to set up a hand plane to mitigate tear-out. It will compliment a WoodCentral article by David Weaver that many may not have studied. (It is not a stretch to say that WoodCentral has been key to the rediscovery and advancement of this knowledge.)

I have two purposes to make this post here and now. For persons that have figured out other, and in my mind more costly and/or complex, ways to mitigate tear-out this rediscovery will likely be dismissed. However, for those that tried and dismissed hand planes because they caused unexpected and disastrous tear-out, this technique makes the usefulness of hand planes in furniture building something to be reconsidered. This audience is more likely to hang out here than on hand tool forums. This post is intended to motivate this audience to go buy this issue of PW and read the article, then try it.

Examples:

My intention is not to demonstrate the technique, that will be/has been done nicely in the Articles. Rather, it is to show where a plane that doesn’t care what the grain is doing can be useful and make planing more reliable and accepted. Two situations come to mind, one where the grain is hard to read and the second where there is grain reversal .

PIC 1


(for unknown reasons my camera refuses to focus on this surface...best I can do)

I am into drawer making for Samantha's chest of drawers(will post soon) and that involves fitting. There is no better means of removing a few thousandths of an inch of lumber to get a precise fit than a hand plane. Unexpectedly tearing out a chunk of wood with the hand plane or jointer on a finished piece is demotivational and can result in outbursts.

The piece of wood is a drawer back and the need was to remove a bit from the top edge. The grain turned out to be hard to read, or at least counter intuitive and I yanked out a large divot when roughing it on the jointer. With a jointer or typical hand plane, it must be approached in the direction shown by the arrow or severe tear-out is experienced when jointing/planing the top edge (trust me!). I think most would consider this direction "against the grain," but in fact it isn’t. The edge face being planed is perfect quarter grain and I have found it often unpredictable.

PIC 2


Another case is when there is a grain reversal that must be planed. There is no “correct” direction to plane this edge.

With a closely set chip breaker (AKA cap iron, double iron) it matters not what direction this difficult-to-read grain or this grain reversal is approached. The result was a smooth cut (not illustrated, take my word for it, or not). The confidence that tear-out can be avoided is why I think this technique should be investigated by those that fear tear-out.

It works, period. And it works well on the typical Stanley type plane with little or no modification. Go forth and study up on it in the well prepared Articles.

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#2

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

BrianMonumentCO

Have you tried using a low angle plane? If so what results did you get?

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#3

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

don stephan

With some practice I have found hand planes valuable and essential tools. The one comment I would make is that for several years every how-to article was used to tune up (fettle?) my Stanley and Bailey planes, but I was always frustrated with the results. Backed into a significant corner by soft early season grain on a nearly finished sugar pine tabletop, I purchased a Lie Nielsen #8 jointer plane and the problem washboarding was put to rest in about five minutes. Since then as budget has allowed I have purchased foru additional Lie Nielsen planes, and I now work with my planes rather than on the Stanleys and Bailey. I would fully expect that the Veritas planes are equally functional. I admire those who get similar results with vintage planes.

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#4

Thank you Bill, Wilbur & Kees

Bob Lang

for holding our feet to the fire to get this published, and for your patience as we move at our typical glacial speed. If I remember, I'll post the opening photo from the article on the PopWood editor's blog tomorrow. The board in the photo was planed with a Stanley #4, with the stock blade. The entire board was planed "backwards", against the grain. On the half with all the tearout, the cap iron was set back about 1/16" from the end of the iron. On the good-looking half, the cap iron was set as close as I could get.

Knowledge and practice of how to set the cap iron puts planing within reach for almost everyone. While this particular plane was passed on to me by my grandfather and then my dad, it is common as dirt and you can find them everywhere. Yes, the boutique tools are very nice and worth the price, but if you can get great results with a garage sale/flea market plane for less than $50, I don't think you need to buy new, especially if you're just starting out and on a tight budget. You can take the savings and buy my books and renew your subscription.

I'd also like to thank Warren for taking me to task about this 5 or 6 years ago. That got me thinking and experimenting, and most important improved my work.

Bob Lang

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#5

planed Birdseye and Fiddleback Maple

Mark Hennebury

Here are some images of Birdseye and Fiddleback Maple that has been run through a Marunaka Supersurfacer. A Supersurfacer is basically a well tuned Giant handplane with the same functioning components as a handplane. This wood is some pretty tough wood in terms of extreme alternating grain, and this wood has been "baked" or "roasted" to darken it which also makes it harder and more brittle. A well tuned handplane can do a realy nice job on troublesome woods.

" border="0" alt="">

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#6

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

Kees

Hello. Usually I read the handtool forum, but Bill attended me to this thread. I cooperated with Wilbur to write the article. That was fun, especially because I live on the other side of the ocean. Skyping and sending drafts of the article back and forth was kind of hilarious.

I can see Bill's point. Many handtool enthousiasts are stuck in their own ways, regarding the planes they use. So the real public for an article like this could very well be the dyed in the wool ROS user. A sander like that is nice and easy of course, but it has some disadvantages. The noise and the dust is one thing. But it is also about the surface quality. You only have to see a succesfully handplaned surface once. Another less obvious advantage is the sharp details. A sander usually leads to dubbed edges and drooping corners of a surface.

The first skill you need to learn is sharpening the blade. From a 10 dollar yardsale Stanley to a multi thousand dollar infill, it won't work without a sharp blade. It is also good to check the sole of the plane, especially a concave sole doesn't work as well. Frog and blade should be seated solidly and the handles shouldn't be loose.

But having a perfect plane is still no guarantee that you won't get tearout. And it can be unpredictable too. Planes with high bedding angles or low angle planes with an obtuse sharpening angle are other ways to deal with this. But the cheapest entry into the world of handplaning is still the old and trusty Stanley plane. Making a Krenov type is a good option too, and a fun project for a weekend. Hock blades for such a plan come with a capiron too and aren't too expensive.

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#7

Additional practical applications

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have a large thickness planer as well as all the common sanding devices. I always finish sand a surface before staining (I can't control pigment staining on a planed surface). So what is left for a well behaved hand plane?


Kees alluded to maintaining crisp edges. The facing on this chest of drawers must be brought into the same plane, at least where the pieces intersect. Before rediscovery of the "cap iron effect" I scraped and sanded these pieces into submission and the result was not crisp edges. I feared planing them because a tear-out divot would be a disaster. Not any more.

When we speak of a "Stanley plane", we really mean any plane that has a chip breaker(cap iron). Once I opened up the mouth on this easy to make Krenov style plane so the shavings would clear I could reliably plane even the figured portions of the edge shown in the picture. It didn't matter what direction these edges were planed.


After gluing up a panel, in this case a case side, invariably the edges do not perfectly match everywhere along the joint. In this case it is hard to tell for sure what way the grain is running and in any case it is likely running the opposite way on the adjacent board. Hence, I used to belt sand these sides. I have had my share of belt sander disasters and I do not regard this tool as fool proof.

Again, employing the cap iron effect the sides of the panel can be reliably leveled. In my case I follow this leveling with finish sanding.

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#8

Ellis Walentine

Re: planed Birdseye and Fiddleback Maple

Ellis Walentine

You didn't mention whether your Marunaka has the equivalent of a closely set chipbreaker.

Ellis

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#9

Re: planed Birdseye and Fiddleback Maple

Mark Hennebury

Ellis,

I didn't do these samples, they were done by Marunaka the maker of the supersurfacers for a customer of mine, so i am not sure exactly what the chipbreaker setback was.

The recommended chipbreaker setback for hardwoods is 0.2 - 0.3mm or approx .008" - .012"

This of course can be adjusted a little to find what works best, and would most likely have been pretty tight for this wood.

Supersurfacers also can skew the blade angle to get a shear cut, like holding your hand plane at an angle to the feed direction.

The samples were run with two skew angles 35° and 45° which was noted on the samples to show any difference.

The samples had been resawn on a Wintersteiger multi-blade frame saw then were given two to three passes on a supersurfacer to clean them up.

The chipbreaker setback is critical to getting a good finish, and the supersurfacers use a micrometer jig to precisely set the distance from the cutting edge.

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#10

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The chipbreaker setback is critical to getting a good finish" What is the effect of too close and too far back from optimum?

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

#11

Re: question

Mark Hennebury

The surface finish will degrade;

too far back and you will notice some tearout,

too close and the shavings start to crumple up a resulting rougher surface will also be noticed, either way is getting away from a sweet-point, where the blade is cutting as many of the fibers as possible, either direction away from that and you are splitting or tearing not cutting.

If the chipbreaker is too far back, then it does not exert enough pressure to prevent the shaving lifting due to the wedging action of the knife, the fibers will separate ahead of the cutting edge resulting in torn fibers not cut ones, or tearout.

If the chipbreakers is too close the shaving bunches up ahead of the chipbreaker and tears the fibers before the cutting edge can cut them.

So chipbreaker setback measurements are given as a guideline, and would be tweeked to suit the actual pieces of wood. Hardwood setback is given as 0.2-0.3mm Softwoods as 0.3-0.4mm

The micro bevel at the chipbreaker edge is initially ground to 0.3 - 0.5 mm wide, and then rounded to blend into the main bevel.

Supersurfacers also use a variable skew angle to reach optimum surface. anywhere from 0° - 60°

Also throat opening adjustments by way of a nose-bar plate, which is adjustable for gap as in an adjustable throat handplane, and also adjustable in height relative to the sole of the plane.

The nosebar height ensures that the wood is pressed very tightly against the nose bar while the knife is cutting.