Avoiding tear-out when hand planing
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Coming soon in Popular Woodworking will be an article by two frequent WoodCentralians, Kees Van Der Heiden and Wilbur Pan, on how to set up a hand plane to mitigate tear-out. It will compliment a WoodCentral article by David Weaver that many may not have studied. (It is not a stretch to say that WoodCentral has been key to the rediscovery and advancement of this knowledge.)
I have two purposes to make this post here and now. For persons that have figured out other, and in my mind more costly and/or complex, ways to mitigate tear-out this rediscovery will likely be dismissed. However, for those that tried and dismissed hand planes because they caused unexpected and disastrous tear-out, this technique makes the usefulness of hand planes in furniture building something to be reconsidered. This audience is more likely to hang out here than on hand tool forums. This post is intended to motivate this audience to go buy this issue of PW and read the article, then try it.
Examples:
My intention is not to demonstrate the technique, that will be/has been done nicely in the Articles. Rather, it is to show where a plane that doesn’t care what the grain is doing can be useful and make planing more reliable and accepted. Two situations come to mind, one where the grain is hard to read and the second where there is grain reversal .
PIC 1
(for unknown reasons my camera refuses to focus on this surface...best I can do)
I am into drawer making for Samantha's chest of drawers(will post soon) and that involves fitting. There is no better means of removing a few thousandths of an inch of lumber to get a precise fit than a hand plane. Unexpectedly tearing out a chunk of wood with the hand plane or jointer on a finished piece is demotivational and can result in outbursts.
The piece of wood is a drawer back and the need was to remove a bit from the top edge. The grain turned out to be hard to read, or at least counter intuitive and I yanked out a large divot when roughing it on the jointer. With a jointer or typical hand plane, it must be approached in the direction shown by the arrow or severe tear-out is experienced when jointing/planing the top edge (trust me!). I think most would consider this direction "against the grain," but in fact it isn’t. The edge face being planed is perfect quarter grain and I have found it often unpredictable.
PIC 2
Another case is when there is a grain reversal that must be planed. There is no “correct” direction to plane this edge.
With a closely set chip breaker (AKA cap iron, double iron) it matters not what direction this difficult-to-read grain or this grain reversal is approached. The result was a smooth cut (not illustrated, take my word for it, or not). The confidence that tear-out can be avoided is why I think this technique should be investigated by those that fear tear-out.
It works, period. And it works well on the typical Stanley type plane with little or no modification. Go forth and study up on it in the well prepared Articles.
" border="0" alt="">




