Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Posts

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#2

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

Keith Newton

Bill, I'm not disputing anything about the sharpening or setup, but you might consider choosing a better image to go with your text. You state, " Quartered lumber is especially prone to tear-out with hand plane or power jointer. " Yet, if you are calling that QS, then one of us needs to go back to school.

I think you would do well, to use a wood with considerable grain slope, not poplar, then take side by side passes against the grain, with properly set, and poorly set planes planes, then maybe use a raking light to show the results better.

If that is the best photo you can get to illustrate the point, I would get someone else to shoot it.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#4

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

The names have been changed to protect the innocent…

To set the record straight, the guilty party who is one of the coauthors of the upcoming article is Wilbur Pan, whose $300 humor can be found on "giant Cypress."

www.giantcypress.net

The other coauthor is Kees van der Heiden.

seekelot.blogspot.com

They both participate in the WoodCentral Hand Tools forum.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#5

craigd

Re: Avoiding tear-out when hand planing

craigd

Image plane-ing riven white oak. Both directions. Shown is a 50° single iron but, as has been pointed out, doubles work just fine (see the #7 in the background). I just prefer single irons because it is faster to remove/sharpen and I find Stanley cap irons finicky.


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#6

You have provided an example of......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....the kind of discussion I intended to get ahead of. While what the Japanese call the "cap iron effect" may be, and has been, used by planing enthusiasts they have all sorts of other approaches involving what may seem to the novice planer as arcane combinations of high bedding angles, tight mouths, expensive planes, double bevels, lapped soles and the like.

I believe the ripe market for the information is the person that owns a thickness planer, a random orbital sander and uses kiln dried woods, who wants to integrate the limited but useful benefits of a hand plane into their furniture making. My hope is that the "noise" provided by those that have discovered alternative ways to mitigate tear-out will not discourage the novice planers from trying it.

The bottom line is that if you own a Stanley plane with a sharp blade you will be able to plane most common woods without worrying about tear-out. It either will not happen, or as been recently rediscovered (I will wait for Kees to release the report providing details) it will greatly lessen the depth of the damage to where it is not a disaster.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#7

craigd

Re: You have provided an example of......

craigd

"Chip breakers" work. End of sentence. More information is wonderful and those supplying it are to be applauded. It is great to know WHY things work.

IMO, Stanley planes are cheap, in both senses of the word. Spend the effort of tune them up and get good performance. Or buy a LN, Veritas, etc and just use it. There is plenty of room for both and they both work. I suspect Joe Machine-tool, who likely doesn't read the manuals, just turns it on and pushes the wood in, isn't going to read how to set a chip breaker either.

Having both Stanley's and Sargents and "high" $ planes and using them side by side often, it is silly (for me) to say a $30 Stanley compares to a $300 LV/LN. The Warren's of the world, I suspect, make magic with Stanley's because they know wood, how it interacts with tools and how to correctly maintain said tools (apologies to Warren if I have misspoken). You are to be applauded for shining a light on the latter.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#8

Craig, so by "riven white oak" ?

Keith Newton

You started out with a log, then busted it down into lumber with only hand tools?

Where are you, and can you make your living doing work this way?

As I told Bill, I don't have an issue with the methods, but if you make the claims, show me something proving your metal. Show me a good clean fiddleback maple ribbon. That is what I like, don't you?

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#10

craigd

Re: Craig, so by "riven white oak" ? *PICS*

craigd

You started out with a log, then busted it down into lumber with only hand tools?

Yes. I bought a several rounds of a white oak that had been dropped, the butt of which was ~4' in diameter and had been cut into ~2' lengths. I split those into billets using the tools I had: a small axe, two wedges, a sledge and crowbars. Then hauled the billets home in my hatchback (many trips). It was an immense amount of work because the oak had some twisty grain and didn't want split and I had a broken collarbone at the time.

Then lots of action with a scrub plane (Stanley #40½), followed by a #7, with final clean up left to project time.

I now use a 16" bandsaw and a hand held planer to help square up the billets.

Where are you, and can you make your living doing work this way?

Mid Willamette Valley Oregon (Corvallis). No, I could not make a living wood working, I'm very slow. If I was efficient and had a simpler life style, I think so. But I do like indoor plumbing.

See Curtis Buchanan, Peter Follansbee, Peter Galbert, Brian Boggs for examples of people who make a living working wood using mostly hand tools and starting from logs.

As I told Bill, I don't have an issue with the methods, but if you make the claims, show me something proving your metal. Show me a good clean fiddleback maple ribbon. That is what I like, don't you?

I like wood. I like to think a project exists in any chunk of wood. All wood has beauty if you can figure out how to bring it out. And that is what I like doing, I'm not a furniture maker.

I'm not sure how to answer to mettle (I have made some nice metal planes, see below). I'll let some pictures talk, including some hand planed fiddle back maple (I've done the same with birds eye maple).






Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#11

Re: You have provided an example of......

Tom

"....the kind of discussion I intended to get ahead of. While what the Japanese call the "cap iron effect" may be, and has been, used by planing enthusiasts they have all sorts of other approaches involving what may seem to the novice planer as arcane combinations of high bedding angles, tight mouths, expensive planes, double bevels, lapped soles and the like."

That is because not every shaving is 1 thou, not all wood is gnarly (that being ideal wood only for western ornamental purposes), and not every plane can have a breaker on it. Different strokes for different folks. In your world, those who have been at this for the last 2000 years just didn't know how to set up a plane. If one starts with little enough knowledge one can discover many firsts.

"I believe the ripe market for the information is the person that owns a thickness planer, a random orbital sander and uses kiln dried woods, who wants to integrate the limited but useful benefits of a hand plane into their furniture making. My hope is that the "noise" provided by those that have discovered alternative ways to mitigate tear-out will not discourage the novice planers from trying it."

I don't think that is the problem. There are lots of people crossing over every day. Those that don't may not want to spend the money, or learn to sharpen, or own a bench, whatever. If tear out was in their future, they would have it in spades with the other stuff they already have. If the raw pleasure of wielding a hand plane doesn't get them it is going to be tough to do it by reason alone, but let's hope the article gives many a start and they discover a lifetime of accurate and easy work.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#12

learn to carve.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

if you don't already. Oak such as this was the traditional material for "Bible Boxes". See carving by Peter Follansbee for examples.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#13

craigd

Re: learn to carve.....

craigd

I love Peter F's work! I bought his book and made four joint stools using it. While I love his carvings, they work at a distance (much like Impressionistic paintings) and I have a really difficult doing "noisy" work in close. I wish it were otherwise!

The oak I have is not so great for carving but this Madrone is (my current learn-to-carve project):


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#14

Re: learn to carve.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

While not a fan of balls and claws I can appreciate that that is a nice one.

A friend who has spent a career of carving mahogany furniture as decided to do some Bible Boxes. I gave him a piece of quartered oak to try his hand at, hoping it would cure him of this diversion.

The carving gene is totally absent from my DNA. I could not carve my initials in a beech tree.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#15

Hey Craig!

John in NM

Has anyone said "Man those are nice planes!" this week? :D

I never get tired of looking at them, nice job!

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#16

craigd

Re: Hey Craig!

craigd

Thanks! No, not this week but last week I did while talking to myself and installing this: